Owning an inground pool is often seen as a symbol of luxury, but the initial investment doesn't have to break the bank. If you are looking for the cheapest way to fill in an inground pool, the focus shifts from immediate aesthetics to long-term value, structural integrity, and smart material choices. The goal is to achieve a finished look that is safe and durable without funding a full-scale construction project.
Prioritize Dirt and Gravel Over Specialty Finishes
The single most effective strategy for minimizing cost is to eliminate expensive pool finishes. While plaster and pebble finishes create a stunning visual appeal, they come with a significant price tag. For the absolute cheapest solution, consider leaving the interior walls and floor of the pool shell exposed as dirt or filling it with gravel. This approach drastically reduces material and labor costs, transforming the structure from a water feature into a basic excavation. It is crucial, however, to consult with your excavator regarding compaction and drainage to ensure the dirt or gravel remains stable and does not shift over time.
The Trade-Off of Skipping Plaster
Choosing a dirt or gravel fill means accepting that the pool will never hold water. This method is purely for filling the void to create level ground, not for creating a swimming environment. The savings on plaster, which can cost tens of thousands of dollars, are substantial. You also avoid the ongoing maintenance costs associated with plaster, such as re-finishing every decade or repairing cracks. If your goal is to create a safe, usable space in the footprint of the pool, this is the most direct path to a low-cost resolution.
Utilize the Excavated Soil On-Site
One of the most overlooked aspects of pool removal or installation is the cost of hauling dirt. When you are filling in an inground pool, the cheapest way to manage the excess soil is to use it on your property. Rather than paying a landfill fee to have the excavator haul the dirt away, work with the contractor to strategically place the soil around your foundation, use it to build up low spots in your yard, or create berms for drainage. This simple act of recycling the earth can save you thousands of dollars in disposal fees and save you money on purchasing topsoil elsewhere.
Strategic Landscaping with DIRT
The soil removed from the pool can become a valuable resource for landscaping. By planning the placement during the excavation phase, you can avoid the need to import soil later. Use the dirt to create raised garden beds, build up the grade around your house for better water runoff, or fill in other sunken areas of your yard. This method not only cuts costs but also reduces the environmental impact of your project by minimizing waste transportation.
Explore Alternative Landscaping Materials
If you need to fill the pool to create a stable surface for decking or gardening, but dirt isn't sufficient, look at cheaper alternatives than concrete. Sand is a cost-effective material that can be used to level the bottom of the filled pit before laying a final surface. Additionally, crushed rock or compacted fill dirt provides excellent drainage and stability at a fraction of the cost of pouring a thick slab of cement. These materials are often sufficient for supporting light structures or creating a base for artificial turf.
| Fill Material | Cost Per Cubic Yard | Best Use Case |
|---|---|---|
| Native Soil (On-Site) | Free - Hauling Only | General filling, landscaping berms |
| Fill Dirt | $15 - $50 | Leveling, base layers |
| Crushed Gravel | $40 - $60 | Drainage, driveways |
| Concrete Slab | $100 - $200 | Permanent, load-bearing surfaces |
DIY vs. Professional Installation
The labor market significantly impacts the final price of filling a pool. The cheapest way to fill in an inground pool is often the most labor-intensive route: doing it yourself. If you have the physical capability and time, renting a dump truck and hauling the dirt yourself can save you thousands in labor costs. However, this is only viable if you have the right vehicle and understand the legal restrictions on hauling large quantities of dirt. For most homeowners, hiring a professional is necessary, but you can still manage costs by ensuring the site is clear and accessible, reducing the time the crew needs to spend on-site.
Minimizing Labor Costs
Contractors price their jobs based on man-hours. You can keep labor costs low by planning the logistics efficiently. Ensure the fill material is readily available near the site so the truck doesn't have to make long trips to source soil. Clear the area of debris and obstacles so the crew can work quickly. By acting as a project manager on your own property, you can ensure the job moves smoothly and remains within budget.
Long-Term Value Over Short-Term Savings
While the goal is to find the cheapest way to fill in an inground pool, it is vital to consider the longevity of the solution. Opting for the absolute cheapest material without regard for drainage can lead to future problems like subsidence or water pooling, which could cost you more to fix later. Sometimes, spending a little more on a compacted fill rock layer ensures a stable surface for years. The "cheapest" option is the one that effectively solves the problem without creating new, expensive issues down the road.
Finalizing Your Budget-Friendly Plan
Determining the cheapest way to fill in an inground pool requires a balance of material science and financial pragmatism. By prioritizing dirt fill, leveraging on-site soil, and minimizing specialty finishes, you can transform an expensive liability into a neutral landscape feature. The key is to communicate clearly with your contractor about your budget constraints and be willing to take on some of the labor yourself if possible. This approach allows you to achieve a safe and level property without sacrificing your financial stability.
