Shower or tub—both remain staples in home bathrooms, but Reddit users consistently share passionate debates and personal insights on this age-old question. The subreddit r/homebathroom features vibrant discussions where homeowners weigh the pros and cons of rainfall showers versus deep-soak tubs, often sharing photos, DIY setup ideas, and long-term cost analyses.
Many users praise the space-saving benefits and easy maintenance of showers, especially in small bathrooms. Yet, others advocate for tubs, citing their hydrotherapy benefits and relaxation advantages, particularly for those recovering from workouts or managing stress. Reddit threads frequently highlight real-life trade-offs—water pressure, space constraints, accessibility for seniors—making the dilemma feel deeply personal.
From waterproof liner hacks to eco-friendly showerheads, the community offers actionable tips backed by user experience. Engaging with these conversations helps homeowners make informed choices, whether upgrading existing fixtures or planning a full bathroom remodel. Join the dialogue on Reddit to discover honest, community-driven insights that go beyond surface-level decisions.
This ongoing conversation reflects more than just fixture preference—it’s about lifestyle, sustainability, and comfort. Share your own shower or tub experience in the comments and help others find their ideal bathing solution.
Ultimately, the shower or tub choice depends on lifestyle and space, but Reddit proves it’s more than a simple preference. With countless voices sharing honest experiences and expert-backed advice, the community empowers homeowners to make confident decisions. Dive into the conversation, learn from others, and start shaping your ideal bathing space today.
A bathroom with only a shower is not considered a full bathroom, it is a 3/4 bathroom which can effect home value and marketability. Your house should have at least one bathroom with a tub. We have tub/shower combos in our two main bathrooms (we added a shower stall to the guest bathroom which was previously a half bath, with toilet and sink only).
Shower people may not want a bathtub in their home at all and might even remove a primary suite bathtub in favor of a walk-in shower. If they stay in the home long-term, excluding a tub really isn. Shower/tub combinations are the most common type of fixture you'll see in household bathrooms.
This is because they're practical, they're efficient, and they give you the option of taking either a long bath or a quick shower. However, there are some cons as well. While they're practical for families with young kids, they can pose.
Explore the bathtub vs. shower debate in our guide, weighing pros, cons, and costs to make an informed choice for your bathroom remodel. Discover the pros and cons of shower vs bathtub for your bathroom remodel.
Learn about costs, resale value, and more before making a decision. Choosing between installing a tub or a shower in your bathroom impacts the layout significantly, involves weighing various pros and cons, and affects the property's resale value differently. Showers Take up Less Space If you have a small bathroom, bringing in a tub is going to make your bathroom seem even tinier.
Removing a bathtub during a remodel continues to be a trend. But is it right for you? Here are the questions you should ask before removing a tub. plus, a few pros and cons of removing a tub to help with your decision.
Stuck between choosing a bathroom tub or a shower? Total Bath walks you through the pros, cons, and considerations to help you make the right call. I just renovated my own bathroom and replaced the old shower-over-tub with a nice modern shower-over-tub, which can still be tiled nicely and have glass doors. I dont have kids so my decision was objective as I will sell this place in 3.