Switch Sink Types: Replace Undermount with Overmount

Austin Aug 03, 2026

Ever wondered if it's possible to swap an undermount sink for an overmount sink? The short answer is yes, but it's not just a simple matter of uninstalling one and installing the other. The process involves careful planning, consideration of your kitchen's aesthetic, and potential complications. Let's delve deeper into this question, exploring the intricacies of these sink types, the conversion process, and what you need to know before you start.

How to Install Undermount Sink in Existing Countertop
How to Install Undermount Sink in Existing Countertop

Undermount and overmount sinks, also known as undercounter and drop-in sinks respectively, are two of the most popular sink types. They each have their own unique features, benefits, and drawbacks, which can significantly impact your kitchen's functionality and appearance.

How to Upgrade your Kitchen Sink - at home with Ashley
How to Upgrade your Kitchen Sink - at home with Ashley

Understanding Undermount and Overmount Sinks

Undermount sinks are installed below the countertop, giving a sleek, seamless look. They're typically more expensive than overmount sinks but are easier to clean as crumbs and debris can be swept directly into the sink. They are usually made from materials like stainless steel, composite granite, or porcelain, and can be custom-sized to fit your cabinet.

Client Challenge
Client Challenge

On the other hand, overmount sinks rest on top of the counter, with their edges tucked underneath the counter rim. They're typically less expensive, easier to install, and come in a variety of materials including stainless steel, cast iron, and even fireclay. However, they may not fit snugly against the countertop, allowing crumbs to accumulate in the small gap.

Why Consider Replacing an Undermount Sink with an Overmount Sink?

How to Replace and Install an Undermount Kitchen Sink — House by the Preserve
How to Replace and Install an Undermount Kitchen Sink — House by the Preserve

There could be several reasons why you might want to replace an undermount sink with an overmount sink. Perhaps you're looking to update the aesthetic of your kitchen, or your current undermount sink isn't holding up as well as you'd like. Maybe you're looking to save money by opting for a less expensive option. Whatever your reason, it's important to understand the implications of the switch.

One of the most significant considerations is the potential need to replace your countertop. Undermount sinks require a different installation process than overmount sinks, which may involve cutting into or replacing the countertop. This can add significantly to the cost and complexity of the project.

Can You Replace an Undermount Sink with an Overmount Sink? A Step-by-Step Guide

Drop-In vs. Undermount Sink – Which One Is Better For You?
Drop-In vs. Undermount Sink – Which One Is Better For You?

If you're set on replacing your undermount sink with an overmount sink, it's possible, but it's not a DIY job for everyone. Here's a simplified guide to the process:

1. **Measure Your Cabinet and Sink**: Ensure your new overmount sink will fit your cabinet and leave enough room for plumbing connections. Also, consider the sink's undermount dimensions to see if it should be installed in the same location.

2. **Prepare Your Countertop**: If your undermount sink was installed properly, you should have support bracing that can be reused. If not, you'll need to install new supports.

How to Replace and Install an Undermount Kitchen Sink — House by the Preserve
How to Replace and Install an Undermount Kitchen Sink — House by the Preserve

3. **Remove Your Undermount Sink**: Carefully remove your undermount sink, being careful not to damage your countertop or the surrounding area.

4. **Install Your Overmount Sink**: Position your new sink on the countertop, ensuring it's level and properly aligned. Secure it in place using screws or silicone adhesive.

How to Replace and Install an Undermount Kitchen Sink — House by the Preserve
How to Replace and Install an Undermount Kitchen Sink — House by the Preserve
Undermount vs. Drop-in Sinks: Which is Right For You?
Undermount vs. Drop-in Sinks: Which is Right For You?
Undermount vs Drop in Sink: Which One is Better?
Undermount vs Drop in Sink: Which One is Better?
a kitchen sink with the words 7 reasons why you should have an undermount sink in your kitchen
a kitchen sink with the words 7 reasons why you should have an undermount sink in your kitchen
How to Replace a Tiled-In Under-Mount Kitchen Sink Without Replacing Any Tile
How to Replace a Tiled-In Under-Mount Kitchen Sink Without Replacing Any Tile
Undermount Sink Installation Tips and Tricks - Making Manzanita
Undermount Sink Installation Tips and Tricks - Making Manzanita

5. **Connect the Plumbing**: Reconnect the plumbing to your new sink, ensuring all connections are tight and leak-free.

The Pros and Cons of Making the Switch

Before you decide to replace your undermount sink with an overmount sink, it's crucial to weigh the pros and cons. Here's a brief overview:

Pros of Overmount Sinks:

  • Easier and less expensive to install.
  • Come in a wide variety of materials and styles.
  • Can provide a more traditional look.

Cons of Overmount Sinks:

  • Can be more difficult to clean due to the crevice between the sink and countertop.
  • May not be as durable or long-lasting as undermount sinks.
  • Can look less contemporary than undermount sinks.

Ultimately, the decision to replace an undermount sink with an overmount sink depends on your personal preferences, your budget, and the effort you're willing to put into the project. It's always a good idea to consult with a professional if you're unsure about any aspect of the process.

Once you've made your decision and the job's done, step back and admire your new sink. Whether you've chosen to keep the undermount look or switch to an overmount sink, you've likely updated your kitchen's style and added value to your home.