How to Fix a Broken Tub Handle

Austin Aug 03, 2026

Is your bathtub handle broken, wobbling, or loose? Don't let a faulty handle ruin your bathing experience or pose a safety hazard. Follow this comprehensive guide to learn how to fix a broken tub handle. We've simplified the process into clear, step-by-step instructions, ensuring you tackle this DIY project with confidence.

a person's hand is holding onto a faucet in a sink with the words how to replace your tub spout
a person's hand is holding onto a faucet in a sink with the words how to replace your tub spout

Before we dive into the repair process, let's ensure you have the right supplies. You'll need a screwdriver, utility knife, handlepuller tool (if the handle is stuck), replacement handle, plumbing tape, and possibly some PVC cement if your pipes are PVC.

Video: Replace a Bathtub Faucet Handle
Video: Replace a Bathtub Faucet Handle

Identify the Type of Tub Handle

Before attempting any repairs, it's crucial to determine your tub handle's type. The repair process differs depending on whether the handle is plastic, metal, or connected to a ballet wheel faucet.

Guide to Fixing a Leaky Bathtub Faucet, Step-By-Step
Guide to Fixing a Leaky Bathtub Faucet, Step-By-Step

The most common types are straight, long handles, and knuckle handles. Start by observing your handle's shape and material. This will help you choose the right replacement handle and guide your repair steps.

Plastic or Metal Tub Handles

a person is holding a toothbrush in front of a wall mounted soap dispenser
a person is holding a toothbrush in front of a wall mounted soap dispenser

For plastic or metal handles, follow these general steps:

  • Turn off the water supply to your tub.
  • Use a screwdriver to remove any existing screws.
  • If the handle is stuck, use a handlepuller tool to remove it gently.
  • Clean the area around the handle and remove any remaining debris or old screws.
  • Wrap the new handle's shank in plumbing tape for a tight fit.
  • Insert the new handle and secure it with screws or washers and nuts.

Ballet Wheel Faucet Handles

Shower Diverter Valve - Fix Tub Spout Leak Causing Weak Shower
Shower Diverter Valve - Fix Tub Spout Leak Causing Weak Shower

Ballet wheel faucets often have a distinct ball indicator for water temperature. Repairing these handles requires a different approach:

  • Disconnect the water supply and remove the escutcheon (the decorative cap around the handle).
  • Unscrew the handle and remove the ball and spring.
  • Remove the broken handle and clean the area.
  • Wrap the new handle's shank in plumbing tape and reattach the ball and spring.
  • Secure the new handle and replace the escutcheon.

Test the New Tub Handle

Plastic broken handle repair
Plastic broken handle repair

Once you've replaced the handle and reconnected the water supply, it's time to test your new handle.

If the handle turns smoothly and the faucet works correctly, you've successfully fixed your broken tub handle. If not, go back through the repair steps to ensure you haven't missed anything.

a person is using a hair dryer on the sink's faucet
a person is using a hair dryer on the sink's faucet
How to Replace a Bathtub Faucet - The Home Depot
How to Replace a Bathtub Faucet - The Home Depot
How to Replace a Bathtub Faucet
How to Replace a Bathtub Faucet
a faucet that is pouring water into a sink with green and blue bowls
a faucet that is pouring water into a sink with green and blue bowls
30+ Inexpensive Home Improvement and Repair Ideas
30+ Inexpensive Home Improvement and Repair Ideas
How to Easily Repair a Chipped Bathtub
How to Easily Repair a Chipped Bathtub

Inspect for Leaks

Perform a thorough visual inspection around the tub faucet and handle for any signs of leaks. Tighten any connections if necessary.

In case of persistent leaks, you might need to replace the faucet cartridge, but that's a more involved process. If you're unsure, don't hesitate to consult a professional plumber.

There you have it – a smooth, efficient guide to fixing your broken bathtub handle. By following the steps outlined above, you'll have your tub back in working order in no time. Happy DIY-ing!