Best Places to Buy Red Pepper Jelly: Ultimate Guide

Austin Aug 03, 2026

If you're a fan of unique culinary creations and seeking a standout accompaniment to your cheese boards, sandwiches, or even as a spicy base for Asian-inspired dishes, you've come to the right place. The exotic and fiery red pepper jelly is a versatile concoction that's earned its spot in many households. But where to buy this zesty delicacy? Let's delve into some top sources.

easy homemade red pepper jelly recipe in a jar
easy homemade red pepper jelly recipe in a jar

Before diving in, remember that the quality and taste of red pepper jelly can vary greatly. Some store-bought options may be too sweet or lack the right kick, while homemade versions allow for perfecting your preferred level of spiciness. So, let's explore where you can find the best bottles, and how to make it yourself if you're up for the challenge.

a glass jar filled with red pepper jelly
a glass jar filled with red pepper jelly

Store-Bought Red Pepper Jelly

For those who value convenience and want to try before committing to making it at home, store-bought pepper jelly offers a convenient solution. Here are some places you can check:

How to Make Red Pepper Jelly
How to Make Red Pepper Jelly

Grocery Stores

You might be surprised to find red pepper jelly in your local grocery store. Mainstream brands like Pepper Palace, B & G Gourmet Foods, and Stonewall Kitchen offer their versions. Check refrigerated sections, condiment aisles, or ask store personnel if you can't locate it. Remember, grocery stores' inventories can vary, so it's best to call ahead.

Sweet & Spicy Red Pepper Jelly
Sweet & Spicy Red Pepper Jelly

Specialty Food Stores and Markets

Specialty food stores and gourmet markets often carry a bigger selection of artisanal and unique products. Visit these stores to discover handcrafted pepper jellies with exotic twists, like pineapple-serrano or mango-habanero flavors. Examples include Whole Foods Market, Trader Joe's, and local co-ops. Don't hesitate to ask store staff for recommendations on brands or flavors.

Online Retailers

Red Pepper Jelly
Red Pepper Jelly

With the rise of online shopping, you can now order your favorite pepper jelly straight to your doorstep. Websites like Amazon, Pepper Palace's official store, and small-batch producers' websites carry various brands and flavors. Online shopping also enables you to explore lesser-known or hard-to-find options.

Homemade Red Pepper Jelly

Making red pepper jelly at home lets you control the ingredients, spiciness level, and flavor profile. Plus, it's a fun DIY project! Here's a simple recipe to get you started:

How to Make Easy Red Pepper Jelly
How to Make Easy Red Pepper Jelly

Ingredients

You'll need:

Red Pepper Jelly
Red Pepper Jelly
Red Pepper Jelly
Red Pepper Jelly
Best Pepper Jelly Recipe: Preserving Food Recipes
Best Pepper Jelly Recipe: Preserving Food Recipes
a glass jar filled with red liquid sitting on top of a stone floor next to grass
a glass jar filled with red liquid sitting on top of a stone floor next to grass
the cover of 25 ways to eat pepper jelly, including crackers and other appetizers
the cover of 25 ways to eat pepper jelly, including crackers and other appetizers
three jars filled with peppers and vegetables on top of a counter
three jars filled with peppers and vegetables on top of a counter
  • 6 large red bell peppers, deseeded and roughly chopped
  • 4 cups white vinegar
  • 6 cups granulated sugar
  • 1 (1.75 oz) package pectin (e.g., Ball Real Fruit Powdered Pectin)

A note on spiciness: For a mild jelly, use only bell peppers. To add heat, incorporate one or more of the following: a few jalapeños, habaneros, or a pinch of cayenne pepper.

Instructions

1. Place the peppers and vinegar in a large pot. Bring to a boil, then reduce heat and simmer for 20 minutes. Let the mixture steep for an hour.

2. Strain the pepper-vinegar mixture through a food mill or blender, then transfer the purée back into the pot. Stir in the sugar and pectin until fully dissolved.

3. Bring the mixture to a full rolling boil over medium-high heat. Let it boil for exactly 1 minute, then remove from heat and skim any foam.

4. Ladle the jelly into clean, sterilized glass jars, leaving about 1/4-inch headspace at the top. Seal the lids and process in a water bath for 10 minutes to preserve the jelly (optional but recommended).

Enjoy your homemade red pepper jelly as a spread, dip, or glaze. And remember, once you've mastered the recipe, you can always experiment with different peppers, spices, or even fruits to create unique flavor combinations.

Embark on your red pepper jelly adventure today, whether you prefer store-bought convenience or the reward of crafting it yourself. Happy tasting!