Four makeup artists discuss their favorite strategies to picking the best eyeliner shades to make your natural eye color pop. From smudge-proof liquid black eyeliner to foolproof eyeliner pencils, here are our favorite black eyeliners. Black, brown, burgundy, and more.
Flatters fair features While anyone can wear any shade of eyeliner they please, makeup artists say brown tones are particularly flattering on lighter features because they're less harsh than their inky-black counterparts. "Green and gray eye colors and very fair skin tones with pink undertones are best suited for brown eyeliner," says Rivero. This eyeliner stick is designed with a waterproof and smudge-proof formula, ensuring your bold goth eye makeup stays intact through sweat, rain, or long nights.
Matte Finish for Goth Glam - Instant Dark Intensity: With a rich black pigment and matte finish, this eyeliner gives you the intense, dramatic effect you're looking for. Makeup artists explain the most complementary eyeliner colors for each eye shade. Whether you have blue, hazel, or brown eyes, there's one that will look gorge.
Silver Eyeliner: Silver eyeliner can complement cool undertones by adding a cool-toned metallic sheen to the eyes. It creates a bright and eye-catching look. Slate Gray Eyeliner: This cooler.
Keep reading for the ultimate breakdown of the most flattering eyeliners for your eye color. What are the best gray eye liners products in 2026? We analyzed 10,493 gray eye liners reviews to do the research for you. Shop Black Eyeliner at Ulta Beauty.
Free Shipping Offers & Free Store Pickup Available Same Day. Join ULTAmate Rewards To Earn Points.
