Okc Cake Lady: Reviews, Complaints & Customer Experiences

By Andrew

In the bustling culinary scene of Oklahoma City, one name has consistently risen to the top of dessert enthusiasts' lists: the Okc Cake Lady. Known for her artisanal, custom cakes and treats, she has garnered a significant following. However, as with any popular establishment, reviews and complaints paint a mixed picture. Let's delve into the Okc Cake Lady reviews and complaints to provide a comprehensive understanding of her offerings.

The OKC Cake Lady
The OKC Cake Lady

The Okc Cake Lady, or more formally, Cakes by Yelissa, has been a staple in the OKC dessert scene for over a decade. With a focus on unique designs and flavors, she has catered to numerous weddings, birthdays, and corporate events. Her Instagram feed is a testament to her creativity, showcasing intricate designs and mouth-watering treats that have drawn in countless customers.

a woman standing in front of a table full of cakes and desserts on it
a woman standing in front of a table full of cakes and desserts on it

Positive Reviews and Praises

Many customers praise the Okc Cake Lady for her exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail. The quality of her cakes is a recurring theme in positive reviews, with customers raving about the moistness and flavor of her sponge cakes and the richness of her buttercreams. One customer commented, "The cake was not only beautiful but also delicious. The flavor was perfect, and the texture was light and moist."

a cake that is shaped like a basketball
a cake that is shaped like a basketball

Another standout feature is her customization skills. Customers appreciate her ability to bring their visions to life, whether it's a specific design, color scheme, or flavor combination. A satisfied customer shared, "Yelissa created the most beautiful cake for our wedding. She perfectly captured our theme and made the process stress-free."

Exceptional Customer Service

a woman standing in a kitchen with her arms crossed and looking at the camera while wearing an apron
a woman standing in a kitchen with her arms crossed and looking at the camera while wearing an apron

Many reviews highlight the Okc Cake Lady's exceptional customer service. She is praised for her prompt responses to inquiries and her willingness to accommodate last-minute changes or special requests. One customer noted, "Yelissa was always quick to respond to my emails and made me feel like my cake was her top priority."

Her professionalism and friendliness also leave a lasting impression. A customer shared, "From our initial consultation to the delivery of our cake, Yelissa was a pleasure to work with. She made the entire process enjoyable and stress-free."

Rave-Worthy Flavors

White buttercream cake
White buttercream cake

The Okc Cake Lady's unique flavor combinations have also earned her high praise. Her menu includes classic favorites like vanilla and chocolate, but she also offers more exotic flavors like lavender honey, salted caramel, and even a "dirty south" flavor featuring banana, peanut butter, and chocolate. A customer exclaimed, "The cake was absolutely delicious! The flavor was unlike anything I've ever tasted, and it was perfect for our event."

Her willingness to create custom flavors based on customer preferences has also been a hit. A customer shared, "Yelissa created a custom flavor for our wedding cake that was a hit with all our guests. It was a perfect blend of our favorite flavors, and it was absolutely delicious."

Complaints and Areas for Improvement

a birthday cake with the logo of the basketball team is on a white tablecloth
a birthday cake with the logo of the basketball team is on a white tablecloth

While the Okc Cake Lady receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, there are some complaints and areas for improvement. The most common issues revolve around pricing and lead time.

Several customers have noted that her cakes are on the pricier side, which can be a barrier for some. One customer commented, "The cakes are beautiful, but they're quite expensive. I wish there were more affordable options for those on a budget." Another customer suggested, "Offering some smaller, less expensive cake options would be great for those who want to try her cakes but can't afford a large, custom cake."

an advertisement for cake pop cakes and more, with the description in black on white
an advertisement for cake pop cakes and more, with the description in black on white
a facebook page with an image of a cake
a facebook page with an image of a cake
Contact
Contact
a woman sitting at a kitchen counter with several cakes on plates in front of her
a woman sitting at a kitchen counter with several cakes on plates in front of her
a birthday cake made to look like a basketball player on top of a basket ball
a birthday cake made to look like a basketball player on top of a basket ball
there is a pink and white cake with two spoons sticking out of the top
there is a pink and white cake with two spoons sticking out of the top
Teacher Cake
Teacher Cake
a cake with two tomatoes on it that says i can't you from my head to ma - toes
a cake with two tomatoes on it that says i can't you from my head to ma - toes
Nielsen-Massey Vanillas
Nielsen-Massey Vanillas
Made for the moments that matter!
Made for the moments that matter!
10 Southern Cakes Everyone Should Bake At Least Once
10 Southern Cakes Everyone Should Bake At Least Once
four cakes are arranged on top of each other in a metal tray with straw and pineapple decorations
four cakes are arranged on top of each other in a metal tray with straw and pineapple decorations
Your Sweet Connection Cake Cookies, Cake
Your Sweet Connection Cake Cookies, Cake
Easy Peach Cobbler Cake With Fresh Peaches Recipe
Easy Peach Cobbler Cake With Fresh Peaches Recipe
3 questions with Amy Craparo, cake designer
3 questions with Amy Craparo, cake designer
Oklahoma Cake Artist Spotlight Series: Andrea Howard Cakes
Oklahoma Cake Artist Spotlight Series: Andrea Howard Cakes
a cake with the letter k on it is sitting on a blue and white plate
a cake with the letter k on it is sitting on a blue and white plate
Gwendolyn Shares Her Fall Desserts With The Fox 59 Morning Team
Gwendolyn Shares Her Fall Desserts With The Fox 59 Morning Team
a display case filled with lots of cards and magnets on the side of a wall
a display case filled with lots of cards and magnets on the side of a wall
a woman holding a cell phone in front of a bundt cake
a woman holding a cell phone in front of a bundt cake

Lead Time and Availability

Another common complaint is the lead time required for ordering a cake. Due to her popularity, the Okc Cake Lady often requires customers to book well in advance, sometimes up to six months for weddings. A frustrated customer shared, "I wanted to order a cake for my daughter's birthday, but I couldn't because I didn't book far enough in advance."

Similarly, some customers have expressed disappointment when they find out that the Okc Cake Lady is booked for their desired date. One customer noted, "I was really hoping to have a cake made by the Okc Cake Lady for my son's graduation party, but she was already booked."

Limited Availability and Accessibility

Some customers have also expressed frustration with the limited availability of her cakes. As a one-woman operation, the Okc Cake Lady can only produce so many cakes per week. A customer commented, "I wish she could make more cakes each week so that more people could enjoy them."

Additionally, her physical location in Oklahoma City may pose a challenge for those living outside the metro area. A customer suggested, "It would be great if she could offer delivery or shipping options to make her cakes more accessible to those living outside OKC."

In the dynamic world of Oklahoma City's dessert scene, the Okc Cake Lady continues to make a significant impact with her artisanal cakes. While there are areas for improvement, her exceptional craftsmanship, unique flavors, and outstanding customer service have solidified her place as a beloved local institution. As the dessert landscape continues to evolve, it will be exciting to see how the Okc Cake Lady grows and adapts to meet the changing demands of her customers. So, whether you're planning a wedding, a birthday party, or just craving a delicious treat, consider visiting the Okc Cake Lady for an unforgettable dessert experience.