Smoke Tree vs Smoke Bush: Which shrub suits your garden?

In the realm of gardening, two plants often cause confusion due to their similar names and appearances: the smoke tree and the smoke bush. Both are beloved for their unique beauty, but they have distinct characteristics that set them apart. Let's delve into the world of these smoke-hued plants to understand the differences and similarities between the smoke tree vs. smoke bush.

How to Grow Smoke Bush: Get Both Flower Plumes and Purple Foliage by Mastering One Pruning Decision
How to Grow Smoke Bush: Get Both Flower Plumes and Purple Foliage by Mastering One Pruning Decision

Smoke tree and smoke bush are both deciduous shrubs, but they belong to different plant families and have unique growth habits, foliage, and flowers. Understanding these key aspects will help you make an informed decision when choosing between these two captivating plants for your garden.

15 Colorful Trees That Add Year-Round Color and Instant Curb Appeal to Your Landscape
15 Colorful Trees That Add Year-Round Color and Instant Curb Appeal to Your Landscape

Smoke Tree (Cotinus coggygria)

The smoke tree, native to Eastern Europe and Western Asia, is a member of the sumac family (Anacardiaceae). It's known for its smoky purple-pink inflorescences and showy fall foliage. This versatile plant can be grown as a small tree or a large shrub, adding vertical interest and-seasonal color to your landscape.

15+ Small Trees Safe to Plant Near Your House (That Won’t Damage Foundations)
15+ Small Trees Safe to Plant Near Your House (That Won’t Damage Foundations)

Smoke trees can reach heights of 15 to 20 feet (4.5 to 6 meters) with a similar spread, making them excellent choices for specimen planting, screens, or mixed borders. They grow best in full sun to partial shade and prefer well-drained, evenly moist soil.

Foliage

Smokin
Smokin

Cotinus coggygria features medium to dark green, trifoliate leaves that turn stunning shades of red, purple, and orange in fall. The leaves have serrated margins and a somewhat coarse texture, adding to the plant's unique character.

The foliage appears after the flowers, in stark contrast to the smoke bush, which sheds its leaves before blooming. This difference can help differentiate between the two plants during different times of the year.

Flowers and Inflorescences

Smoke Tree
Smoke Tree

The smoke tree's true flowers are small, greenish, and inconspicuous. However, it's the inflated, smoky-purple to pale pink,tailed panicles that steal the show. These inflorescences can reach up to 12 inches (30 cm) in length and extend beyond the leaves, creating a dazzling spectacle during late summer to early fall.

Some popular cultivars, like 'Royal Purple,' 'Velvet Cloak,' and 'Goldflame,' are prized for their exceptional foliage color, flowershow, and unique features. 'Golden Spirit' boasts golden spring foliage, while 'Jeffers Red' offers brilliant fall color.

Smoke Bush (Cotinus obovatus)

a purple bush in front of an apartment building
a purple bush in front of an apartment building

The smoke bush, on the other hand, hails from North America and is a relative newcomer to the horticultural scene. It's a member of thebusiness (Moraceae) family and is known for its rounded growth habit and showy, smoky rose-pink plumes. This deciduous shrub typically grows 6 to 10 feet (1.8 to 3 meters) tall and wide, making it an excellent choice for smaller gardens, hedges, or foundation plantings.

Smoke bushes thrive in full sun to partial shade and prefer well-drained, medium moisture soil. They are generally more drought-tolerant once established compared to smoke trees.

American Smoke Tree - Heritage Tree Care - Central Texas Arborist Services
American Smoke Tree - Heritage Tree Care - Central Texas Arborist Services
Cotinus 'Grace'
Cotinus 'Grace'
a chair sitting in the middle of a lush green field next to a pink tree
a chair sitting in the middle of a lush green field next to a pink tree
Tips For Growing Clematis - How To Care And Prune Clematis
Tips For Growing Clematis - How To Care And Prune Clematis
an image of a garden with flowers and plants in the foreground, next to a house
an image of a garden with flowers and plants in the foreground, next to a house
Purple Smokebush (Conospermum) — A True Australian Native
Purple Smokebush (Conospermum) — A True Australian Native
a bush with purple flowers in front of a house
a bush with purple flowers in front of a house
pink flowers are growing on the side of a building in front of a tree with green leaves
pink flowers are growing on the side of a building in front of a tree with green leaves

Foliage

Cotinus obovatus features medium to dark green, broadly ovate leaves with smooth or slightly serrated margins. The foliage emerges in spring and provides a lush green backdrop for the showy inflorescences. As the plant matures, it may develop exfoliating bark, adding winter interest.

The leaves of the smoke bush are generally broader and have less prominent serrations than those of the smoke tree, making them easily distinguishable.

Flowers and Inflorescences

The smoke bush's true flowers are inconspicuous and green, but its real charm lies in the smoky pink to lavender plumes that emerge in late summer to early fall. These inflorescences are slightly smaller than those of the smoke tree, ranging from 6 to 8 inches (15 to 20 cm) in length, and provide an outstanding display of color when floating above the foliage.

You can choose from various smoke bush cultivars, such as ' moderate ('Robbins' Red' for its exceptional fall color), and 'Grace' for its more compact growth habit and improved disease resistance.

In warmer climates, both smoke trees and smoke bushes can be planted as an alternative to invasive ligustrum (privet) hedges due to their unique smoky appeal and overall beauty. By understanding the differences and similarities between these plants, you can make informed decisions about incorporating either or both into your garden design. When it comes to choosing between the smoke tree vs. smoke bush, consider your garden size, soil conditions, and the specific features you desire for your landscape. Whether you prefer the tall, striking presence of the smoke tree or the more compact, rounded form of the smoke bush, these captivating plants are sure to add a touch of smoke-hued elegance to your garden.