Favorite Things Gift Exchange Game Ideas

Amanda Jul 20, 2026

In the spirit of joyous celebrations and strengthening bonds, the Favorite Things gift exchange game has become a popular holiday tradition. It's a delightful twist on the classic white elephant gift swap, encouraging participants to share unique, thoughtful, and deeply personal presents. As the game's popularity grows, so do the creative ideas for themes and executions. Let's explore various Favorite Things gift exchange game ideas to make your next gathering truly special.

a christmas dice game is shown with presents around it and the words, christmas dice
a christmas dice game is shown with presents around it and the words, christmas dice

Modeled after the tried-and-true Secret Santa format, the Favorite Things game's essence lies in inviting participants to share their likes, dislikes, and unique passions. This information helps them—and others—in selecting the perfect surprise gift. By fostering this personalized approach, the event becomes more about the exchanging of stories and connections than just the gifts.

Throw the Ultimate My Favorite Things Party: A Simple Step by Step Guide
Throw the Ultimate My Favorite Things Party: A Simple Step by Step Guide

Theme Ideas

Themes can elevate the Favorite Things game experience, providing inspiration for both gifters and recipients. Here are some creative themes to consider:

a christmas dice game with the text,'the most fun christmas dice game gift exchange idea
a christmas dice game with the text,'the most fun christmas dice game gift exchange idea

menistan

Movie Night

a poster with the words switch, steal, unwrap and gift exchange on it
a poster with the words switch, steal, unwrap and gift exchange on it

Turning your Favorite Things game into a movie-themed extravaganza is a fantastic idea for film buffs and casual viewers alike. Invite participants to share their favorite films, actors, or directors, and enjoy discussing the chosen movies as their gifts are revealed.

To fully embrace this theme, you could set up a cozy movie-watching lounge, complete with popcorn, candy, and even a DIY red carpet. Movie-themed gifts could range from retro posters and vintage movie memorabilia to streaming service subscriptions and exclusive behind-the-scenes books.

Music Festival

santa's helper gift exchange with two women in red and green sweaters
santa's helper gift exchange with two women in red and green sweaters

Pay homage to the beloved music festival culture with a Favorite Things game devoted to the power of sound. Participants can share their favorite genres, artists, or even specific songs that hold deep personal significance.

Encourage your guests to dress up in festival-inspired attire, decorate the space with whimsical festival signage, and provide craft services that mimic those found at real-life music fests. Musical gifts could include concert DVDs, high-quality earphones, or band memorabilia that reflects the recipient's love for a particular artist or style of music.

Game Variations

Everything You Need to Host a Favorite Things Party | The Dating Divas
Everything You Need to Host a Favorite Things Party | The Dating Divas

While the classic Favorite Things game format focuses on each person's unique interests, variations can mix up the dynamic and encourage more interactivity. Consider these engaging game variations:

Wrap

The
The
NEW CHRISTMAS GIFT EXCHANGE IDEAS (Best Holiday Gift Exchange Games That You've Never Played!)
NEW CHRISTMAS GIFT EXCHANGE IDEAS (Best Holiday Gift Exchange Games That You've Never Played!)
the deck of cards gift exchange game is shown in front of a christmas tree with ornaments
the deck of cards gift exchange game is shown in front of a christmas tree with ornaments
7.9M views · 24K reactions | Small gift exchange trend with my friends. This was so much fun and simple way to share little surprises with your friends. #smallgiftexchangetrend #funwithfriends #giftexchange | Cherie Morrow | Facebook
7.9M views · 24K reactions | Small gift exchange trend with my friends. This was so much fun and simple way to share little surprises with your friends. #smallgiftexchangetrend #funwithfriends #giftexchange | Cherie Morrow | Facebook
The best gift exchange ideas! Gift exchange themes, games, and more! Fun Ideas For Christmas Gift Exchange, Theme Ideas For Gift Exchange, Ideas For Gift Exchange At Work, Fun Xmas Gift Exchange Ideas, Xmas Exchange Ideas, White Elephant Gift Theme Ideas, Exchange Ideas, Christmas Gift Exchange Ideas For Family, Christmas Fun Gift Exchange Ideas
The best gift exchange ideas! Gift exchange themes, games, and more! Fun Ideas For Christmas Gift Exchange, Theme Ideas For Gift Exchange, Ideas For Gift Exchange At Work, Fun Xmas Gift Exchange Ideas, Xmas Exchange Ideas, White Elephant Gift Theme Ideas, Exchange Ideas, Christmas Gift Exchange Ideas For Family, Christmas Fun Gift Exchange Ideas
Christmas Gift Exchange Game
Christmas Gift Exchange Game
67 Gift Exchange Game
67 Gift Exchange Game
Share and Share Alike: All About the Favorite Things Party
Share and Share Alike: All About the Favorite Things Party
Christmas Gift Exchange Game Tags - Studio 120 Underground
Christmas Gift Exchange Game Tags - Studio 120 Underground

Stealing and Sharing

In this competitive twist, participants first pull a secret recipient's name and find out their favorite things. They then purchase a gift they believe the recipient will love. After all gifts have been revealed, the recipient ranks their gifts, and the most coveted item is "stolen" by another participant who had their eye on it.

To create a friendly atmosphere, set a limit on the number of times a gift can be stolen or implement a "protection fee" that allows recipients to safeguard their favorite gift by paying a small fee. This variation adds an exciting and interactive element to the traditional Favorite Things game.

Regifting Round Robin

Transform your Favorite Things game into a round-robin event by having each participant bring a gently-used item they love and would like to share with the group. After appearances and stories are exchanged, the item is passed around until it finds its new favorite person.

This regifting round robin encourages participants to think creatively about the items they've cherished throughout the years, providing a unique opportunity to share stories and memories attached to them. Plus, it's an eco-friendly way to celebrate the spirit of gift-giving!

As you plan your Favorite Things gift exchange, remember that the true essence of the event lies in fostering connections, shared experiences, and a sense of camaraderie among your group. Embrace creativity and personalization to make your Favorite Things game a memorable and heartwarming tradition for all involved. Happy gift exchanging!"