Feature Story

Best Brooklyn Restaurants According to Zagat

If you're a food enthusiast exploring Brooklyn, you're in luck. This vibrant borough is dotted with an incredible array of culinary delights, and no list showcases this diversity better than Zagat's "Best Restaurants in Brooklyn". Zagat, renowned for its crowd-sourced restaurant reviews, has curated a list that's a veritable feast of Brooklyn's finest dining experiences. Let's dive into the top picks and must-visits, organized into categories to help you navigate the gastronomic landscape of Brooklyn.

15+ Unforgettable Brooklyn Eats Every Foodie Needs To Try
15+ Unforgettable Brooklyn Eats Every Foodie Needs To Try

From the bustling streets of Williamsburg to the cozy nooks of Park Slope, Brooklyn's culinary scene offers a unique blend of classic favorites and innovative newcomers. Whether you're craving wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas, farm-to-table seasonal comfort food, or the hottest new tasting menu, Brooklyn's dining scene has something to satisfy every appetite.

an italian restaurant with cars parked in front
an italian restaurant with cars parked in front

Hand-Picked Picks from Zagat: Iconic Brooklyn Eateries

The following restaurants stand out as Zagat's top picks, highlighting the unique character of Brooklyn's food culture. Each offers a distinctive dining experience, making them essential additions to your foodie bucket list.

an empty restaurant with tables and chairs in front of large windows that look out onto the street
an empty restaurant with tables and chairs in front of large windows that look out onto the street

At the top of Zagat's list is Luksus, a Michelin-starred gem tucked within the bar of Torst, a craft beer haven. This intimate dining space offers a tasting menu that changes nightly, delighting guests with its innovative approach to new Nordic cuisine.

New Nordic Culinary Heights

a woman holding a plate with food on it
a woman holding a plate with food on it

Luksus is a temple to the new Nordic cuisine movement, where chef Daniel Burns crafts incredible dishes using locally sourced ingredients. The five- or nine-course tasting menus are artfully prepared, showcasing the best of Brooklyn's artisanal producers and Burn's unique culinary vision.

Signature dishes like the cedar-plank smoked Hudson Valley mousse or the pickled beet terrine are not to be missed. The elegant, refined dining experience is amplified by the cozy, inviting atmosphere at Luksus, making it a top choice for special occasions.

Don't Miss: Peter Lugers Steak House

Most Instagrammable Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York City
Most Instagrammable Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York City

No list of Brooklyn's best restaurants would be complete without paying homage to Peter Lugers, a classic New York City steakhouse that's been serving up well-marbled, perfectly grilled porterhouse steaks since 1950. Zagat voters consistently rank Peter Lugers as one of the city's best steakhouses, and it's easy to see why.

Fans flock to Williamsburg for the legendary steaks, tender and flavorful, cut tableside, and served with a side of shoestring onions and Lyonnaise potatoes. The no-frills atmosphere is pure old-school New York, with a buzzing energy and an open kitchen that's a destination for food lovers and celebrity chefs alike.

Culinary Neighborhood Guide: Must-Stop Borough Dining

New ‘Zagat’ guide has zero Brooklyn kosher restaurants, Councilman kvetches • Brooklyn Paper
New ‘Zagat’ guide has zero Brooklyn kosher restaurants, Councilman kvetches • Brooklyn Paper

Brooklyn is vast and diverse, boasting unique dining scenes in each of its neighborhoods. From artisanal pizzas in Bushwick to sustainable seafood in Red Hook, here are some must-stop borough dining experiences curated by Zagat.

Williamsburg: Artisanal Gems and Hot Spots

Zagat Best Brooklyn Restaurants — 2016 Survey
Zagat Best Brooklyn Restaurants — 2016 Survey
16 Best Restaurants in Dumbo (Local's Foodie Picks!)
16 Best Restaurants in Dumbo (Local's Foodie Picks!)
a table topped with plates of food next to a glass of orange juice and a cactus
a table topped with plates of food next to a glass of orange juice and a cactus
Zagat Names Top Vegetarian Restaurants in NYC
Zagat Names Top Vegetarian Restaurants in NYC
the interior of a restaurant with many tables and chairs
the interior of a restaurant with many tables and chairs
the best places to eat in new york city, including restaurants and other food items
the best places to eat in new york city, including restaurants and other food items

Williamsburg, the epicenter of Brooklyn's foodie scene, is home to a plethora of must-try eateries. Di Fara Pizza, an old-school Brooklyn classic, serves up wood-fired Neapolitan pies that are worth the pilgrimage. The secret, say regulars, is in the fresh, high-quality ingredients and the love that goes into each pie.

For a modern take on Italian cuisine, head to A Voce, where chef Andrew Carmellini crafts innovative, seasonally-driven dishes that showcase classic Italian flavors. With its slick, industrial-chic atmosphere and attentive service, A Voce is a perfect date spot or night out with friends.

Greenpoint & Bushwick: Emerging Foodie Hubs

Neighborhoods like Greenpoint and Bushwick are quickly emerging as Brooklyn's newest foodie hot spots. Egg, a beloved Greenpoint brunch spot, serves up creative, comforting takes on breakfast and brunch classics. The differently-flavored pancakes are a must-try, as are the innovative egg sandwiches.

In Bushwick, Claudette offers a taste of the South, with a menu filled with comfort food classics like crawfish beignets and duck confit with cheese grits. The lively, vibrant atmosphere and excellent cocktail program make Claudette a standout among Bushwick's ever-growing dining scene.

The unparalleled culinary diversity of Brooklyn, as highlighted by Zagat's top picks, is a testament to the borough's thriving, vibrant food culture. From neighborhood staples to innovative newcomers, Brooklyn's dining scene offers something for every taste and every occasion. So, food lover, grab a fork - it's time to explore!