Feature Story

Is Sign Language a Language?

Is Sign Language a Language? This question has been the subject of debate among linguists, psychologists, and the wider public. The answer is complex and tient on multiple factors,including the definition of 'language' itself.

ASL Basic Needs Sign Language Chart, Visual Learning Poster (digital Download) - Etsy
ASL Basic Needs Sign Language Chart, Visual Learning Poster (digital Download) - Etsy

To dive into this topic, let's first understand what we mean by 'language'. The Cambridge Dictionary defines it as "a system of communication used by a particular country or community, consisting of words, grammar, and syntax." Now, let's put sign language under the microscope and see if it fits this definition.

What is sign language? A blog about signing by Jenie Yolland
What is sign language? A blog about signing by Jenie Yolland

Universal Features of Language

All languages share certain common features, such as semantics (meaning), syntax (structure), and pragmatics (usage). Let's explore how sign languages stack up against these universal features.

the basic sign language for kids to learn
the basic sign language for kids to learn

Sign languages are semantic-rich, with signs representing concepts, objects, and actions. They have complex grammatical structures, including word order, verb conjugations, and complex sentences. They also have their own pragmatics, with specific ways to indicate questions, emphasize points, or show disagreement.

Arbitrariness

ASL - American Sign Languagein in ASL. This should be posted in every classroom in America starting from Kindergarten!! | Facebook
ASL - American Sign Languagein in ASL. This should be posted in every classroom in America starting from Kindergarten!! | Facebook

Words in spoken languages are arbitrary, meaning there's no inherent connection between the sound of a word and its meaning (like "cat" for a feline). Sign languages are similar, with signs arbitrarily assigned to concepts.

For instance, the sign for 'cat' in American Sign Language (ASL) involves moving the flat hand towards the chin, mimicking the movement of a cat's whiskers. However, there's nothing inherently feline about this sign, making it arbitrary.

Cultural Variation

the words i love you are written in black on a white background with hand gestures
the words i love you are written in black on a white background with hand gestures

Just like spoken languages, sign languages vary from culture to culture. For example, the sign for 'okay' in some sign languages isn't universal and varies in form and meaning across different communities.

This cultural variation is a testament to sign languages being fully fledged languages, as they evolve and change with their communities, much like spoken languages do.

Neural Underpinnings of Language

a poster with the words color signs in different languages and pictures of people holding their hands together
a poster with the words color signs in different languages and pictures of people holding their hands together

Neuroscientists have found that sign languages activate the same brain regions as spoken languages. A study by Emmorey et al. (2003) showed that bilingual signers had the same language-related brain activity whether they were processing spoken or sign language.

Moreover, research has shown that sign languages can be learned as a first language by deaf babies, just like hearing babies learn spoken languages. Their brains develop language centers in response to exposure to sign language.

the four types of question words
the four types of question words
a poster with the words make two hands put thumbs together to make a family circle
a poster with the words make two hands put thumbs together to make a family circle

Canada's Legal Recognition

In Canada, the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms recognizes ASL and other Indigenous sign languages. This legal recognition underscores the fact that sign languages are indeed languages, entitled to the same protections as spoken languages.

This recognition also acknowledges the unique cultures and identities of Deaf communities, who have their own history, customs, and literature – all of which are intrinsically linked to their sign languages.

So, is sign language a language? Based on the vast body of research and evidence, the answer is a resounding yes. They exhibit the same universal features as spoken languages, activate the same brain regions, and are recognized as such by governments around the world.

However, this isn't to say that everyone agrees. Some continue to debate the status of sign languages, often due to misunderstandings about their nature or apert-hand access to sign languages in education and society. As our understanding of language and the human brain continues to grow, let's hope that this debate will soon be a thing of the past, paving the way for true equality and inclusion for all languages and linguistic communities.