The examination of higher-order thinking skills, or higher function, is a critical aspect of education and training, enabling us to assess understanding, problem-solving abilities, and critical thinking. This article delves into the principles of examining higher function, its applicability in training, and best practices for implementing these principles.
Understanding Higher Function
Higher function refers to cognitive processes that involve complex mental operations, such as analysis, synthesis, evaluation, and creation. These functions are essential for lifelong learning and adaptability in the modern world. They encompass skills like critical thinking, problem-solving, creativity, and metacognition (thinking about thinking).
Principles of Examining Higher Function
Examinations of higher function should be designed to encourage deep learning and understanding rather than rote memorization. Here are some key principles to consider:

- Authentic Assessment: Use real-world scenarios and problems that mimic the complexity and ambiguity of real life.
- Open-Ended Questions: Pose questions that require more than a simple yes/no or factual answer. Encourage explanation and justification.
- Process Over Product: Assess the thinking process as much as the final answer. This can be done through think-aloud protocols, concept maps, or other process-tracing methods.
- Multiple Perspectives: Encourage examinees to consider different viewpoints and approaches to a problem.
- Reflection and Self-Assessment: Incorporate opportunities for learners to reflect on their own learning and understanding.
Applying These Principles in Training
The principles of examining higher function can be effectively applied in various training contexts. Here are some strategies for doing so:
Designing Training Activities
When designing training activities, incorporate a mix of individual, group, and reflective tasks. Use case studies, role-plays, and problem-based learning scenarios to engage learners in higher-order thinking. Encourage trainees to apply what they've learned to new situations and to transfer their knowledge to different contexts.
Assessing Learning
Assessments in training should go beyond multiple-choice questions. Use essay questions, presentations, debates, and other performance-based assessments to evaluate higher function. Consider using rubrics that explicitly evaluate the quality of thinking and reasoning, not just the final answer.

Providing Feedback
Feedback should be specific, actionable, and focused on the thinking process. Help trainees understand not just what they got wrong, but why, and how they can improve. Encourage self-reflection and self-regulation by asking trainees to evaluate their own work and set goals for future learning.
Best Practices for Implementing These Principles
Implementing these principles requires a shift in mindset and practice. Here are some best practices to keep in mind:
- Professional Development: Train trainers and educators in these principles and provide ongoing support and resources.
- Curriculum Design: Integrate these principles into the curriculum design process, ensuring that learning objectives, activities, and assessments align and support higher-order thinking.
- Pilot and Refine: Pilot new assessments and activities, gather feedback, and refine them based on that feedback.
| Traditional Question | Higher-Order Question |
|---|---|
| What are the causes of World War I? | Compare and contrast the short-term and long-term causes of World War I. Which do you think were most significant and why? |
Incorporating the principles of examining higher function into training can lead to more engaged, effective, and adaptable learners. By focusing on the thinking process and encouraging deep understanding, we can help trainees develop the higher-order thinking skills they need to succeed in the 21st century.























