How to Make a Pickle and Olive Tray

Kelly Jul 01, 2026

Craving a tangy, savory snack? A pickle and olive tray is the perfect solution, offering a delightful blend of flavors and textures. Whether you're hosting a party or simply satisfying your own cravings, creating a pickle and olive tray is an easy and impressive feat. Let's dive into the art of crafting this delectable dish.

a tray filled with different types of food on top of a table next to wine glasses
a tray filled with different types of food on top of a table next to wine glasses

Before we begin, gather your ingredients. You'll need a variety of pickles, olives, and some additional components to make your tray truly special. Don't be afraid to get creative with your choices!

The Best Relish Tray
The Best Relish Tray

Selecting Your Pickles and Olives

Choosing the right pickles and olives is the foundation of your tray. Aim for a mix of flavors, colors, and textures to create visual appeal and a delightful taste experience.

the pickle board is full of different kinds of vegetables
the pickle board is full of different kinds of vegetables

For pickles, consider a combination of classic dill, sweet gherkins, and perhaps some spicy or bread and butter pickles. As for olives, opt for a mix of green and black olives, and include some stuffed varieties like almond or garlic for added flavor.

Variety in Pickles

Delicious Old School Relish Trays 🥒✨ (Classic, Easy & Crowd-Pleasing!)
Delicious Old School Relish Trays 🥒✨ (Classic, Easy & Crowd-Pleasing!)

Dill pickles are a must-have, but don't stop there. Spicy pickles add a kick, while bread and butter pickles offer a sweet and tangy twist. Experiment with different brands and flavors to find your perfect blend.

Don't forget to consider the size and shape of your pickles. A mix of spears, chips, and whole pickles can add visual interest to your tray.

Exploring Olive Options

an assortment of olives, peppers, and pickles on a platter
an assortment of olives, peppers, and pickles on a platter

Green and black olives are the staples, but there's a world of olive varieties out there. Kalamata olives offer a rich, fruity flavor, while Cerignola olives are large and meaty. Stuffed olives like almond or garlic add a unique twist.

Think about the size and shape of your olives as well. A mix of sizes can create a visually appealing tray, and don't forget to consider pitted or unpitted olives based on your preference.

Building Your Tray

Modern Relish Tray and Olive Platter
Modern Relish Tray and Olive Platter

Now that you've chosen your stars, it's time to build your tray. Presentation is key, so take your time to create a visually stunning display.

Start by placing your largest pickles and olives around the edges of the tray. This creates a border and helps contain the smaller pieces. Then, fill in the center with an assortment of the remaining pickles and olives.

a bowl filled with olives and pickles on top of a white countertop
a bowl filled with olives and pickles on top of a white countertop
The 5-Minute Hack That Will Take Your Summer Barbecues To The Next Level - Kosher.com
The 5-Minute Hack That Will Take Your Summer Barbecues To The Next Level - Kosher.com
a platter filled with assorted vegetables on top of a tile floor next to a bowl of pickles
a platter filled with assorted vegetables on top of a tile floor next to a bowl of pickles
an assortment of green olives and pickles on a white plate with the words old fashioned basic relish tray
an assortment of green olives and pickles on a white plate with the words old fashioned basic relish tray
Relish Tray (how to make one and what to put on it) - Simply Whisked
Relish Tray (how to make one and what to put on it) - Simply Whisked
How To Make The Perfect Relish Tray
How To Make The Perfect Relish Tray
Relish Tray Ideas - The Ultimate How to Guide | gritsandpinecones.com
Relish Tray Ideas - The Ultimate How to Guide | gritsandpinecones.com
How To Make A Relish Tray
How To Make A Relish Tray
Easy Relish Tray Ideas - Good Cheap Eats
Easy Relish Tray Ideas - Good Cheap Eats
a platter filled with assorted vegetables and olives on top of a wooden table
a platter filled with assorted vegetables and olives on top of a wooden table
Bring Back the Relish Tray - Home Made
Bring Back the Relish Tray - Home Made
a platter filled with olives, pickles, peppers and other food items
a platter filled with olives, pickles, peppers and other food items
Easy Relish Tray Ideas - Good Cheap Eats
Easy Relish Tray Ideas - Good Cheap Eats
Thanksgiving Day Traditions - My Kind of Holiday
Thanksgiving Day Traditions - My Kind of Holiday
a table topped with bowls filled with different types of pickles and other food items
a table topped with bowls filled with different types of pickles and other food items
Pickle Charcuterie Board
Pickle Charcuterie Board
Easy Modern Relish Tray Recipe
Easy Modern Relish Tray Recipe
the steps to make an appetizer platter with olives, pickles, tomatoes and other vegetables
the steps to make an appetizer platter with olives, pickles, tomatoes and other vegetables
a platter filled with lots of different types of vegetables and fruits on top of each other
a platter filled with lots of different types of vegetables and fruits on top of each other
Relish Tray stock image. Image of wholesome, close, tray - 48365205
Relish Tray stock image. Image of wholesome, close, tray - 48365205

Creating a Focal Point

A beautiful pickle and olive tray often has a focal point. This could be a unique pickle or olive, a decorative element like a sprig of fresh herbs, or even a small bowl of marinade for dipping.

Position your focal point in the center of the tray, surrounded by your pickles and olives. This will draw the eye and make your tray even more inviting.

Adding Garnishes and Accompaniments

Garnishes and accompaniments can elevate your tray from ordinary to extraordinary. Consider adding some of the following:

  • Fresh herbs like parsley, thyme, or rosemary
  • Sliced red onion or shallots
  • Capers or pepperoncini
  • Marinated artichoke hearts or asparagus
  • Cheese cubes or slices
  • Crackers or crostini

Arrange these garnishes around your focal point or scatter them throughout the tray for a more casual look.

Your pickle and olive tray is now ready to impress! Serve it at your next gathering or enjoy it as a satisfying snack. Don't forget to experiment with different combinations and presentation styles to make it your own. Happy snacking!