Feature Story

Valspar vs. Sherwin-Williams: Paint Showdown

Valspar and Sherwin-Williams, two prominent names in the paint industry, often find themselves in the same conversations due to their quality products and wide range of colors. While both brands have their unique features and loyal customer bases, understanding the differences between Valspar and Sherwin-Williams can help you make an informed decision when choosing paint for your next project.

Valspar Modern Victorian Paint Color Palette
Valspar Modern Victorian Paint Color Palette

Brief History and Reputation

Top 25 Sherwin Williams Paint Colors for 2026
Top 25 Sherwin Williams Paint Colors for 2026

Valspar, founded in 1806, is one of the oldest paint manufacturers in the United States. It's known for its high-quality paints and innovative products. On the other hand, Sherwin-Williams, established in 1866, is another industry veteran with a strong reputation for its durable and long-lasting paints. Both brands have extensive experience and have built their reputations over time.

Paint Quality and Durability

Valspar Color Palette — Magic Mist & Modest Silver & More Paint Colors
Valspar Color Palette — Magic Mist & Modest Silver & More Paint Colors

When it comes to paint quality, both Valspar and Sherwin-Williams offer excellent products. However, Sherwin-Williams is often praised for its superior durability and resistance to fading. Valspar, on the other hand, is known for its excellent adhesion and easy application. The choice between the two may depend on your specific needs, such as the surface you're painting and the expected wear and tear.

Valspar Paint Quality

The 25 Most Popular Paint Colors from Sherwin Williams for 2026
The 25 Most Popular Paint Colors from Sherwin Williams for 2026
  • Excellent adhesion and easy application
  • Wide range of colors and finishes
  • Affordable pricing

Sherwin-Williams Paint Quality

  • Superior durability and fade resistance
  • High-quality pigments for vibrant colors
  • Premium prices for top-tier performance
Valspar vs. Sherwin-Williams Paint: What’s the Difference?
Valspar vs. Sherwin-Williams Paint: What’s the Difference?

Color Selection and Finish Options

Both brands offer a wide range of colors and finishes to cater to diverse customer preferences. Valspar, for instance, offers over 3,000 colors, while Sherwin-Williams has over 1,500 colors in its popular SW Paint Collection alone. Both brands also offer a variety of finishes, from flat to high-gloss, to suit different surfaces and desired effects.

Pricing and Availability

7 Timeless Sherwin Williams Colors You'll Never Regret - Simple DIY
7 Timeless Sherwin Williams Colors You'll Never Regret - Simple DIY

Valspar is generally considered more affordable than Sherwin-Williams. Valspar paints are often found in big-box stores like Lowe's and Home Depot, making them easily accessible. Sherwin-Williams, while slightly more expensive, is known for its high-quality products and is available in its own stores and some hardware stores.

Brand Average Price per Gallon Availability
Valspar $25-$40 Big-box stores, online
Sherwin-Williams $35-$60 Sherwin-Williams stores, hardware stores, online
Sherwin Williams Upward SW 6239
Sherwin Williams Upward SW 6239
The Best Valspar Paint Colors for Every Room (2026)
The Best Valspar Paint Colors for Every Room (2026)
Sherwin Williams Waterloo: Is This the Perfect Bold Blue Gray?
Sherwin Williams Waterloo: Is This the Perfect Bold Blue Gray?
Top 50 Sherwin-Williams Paint Colors Loved by All
Top 50 Sherwin-Williams Paint Colors Loved by All
Valspar Tempered Gray: The Perfect Blend of Modern and Elegance
Valspar Tempered Gray: The Perfect Blend of Modern and Elegance
Valspar Silver Eucalyptus and More Eucalyptus Green Paint Colors For 2026 (From Every Brand!)
Valspar Silver Eucalyptus and More Eucalyptus Green Paint Colors For 2026 (From Every Brand!)
A Deep Dive into Valspar Filtered Shade (Plus Coordinating Colors!)
A Deep Dive into Valspar Filtered Shade (Plus Coordinating Colors!)
a living room filled with furniture and lots of different color scheme options for the walls
a living room filled with furniture and lots of different color scheme options for the walls
Valspar’s 2026 Color Pick Makes Any Space Feel Calmer—Without Going Neutral
Valspar’s 2026 Color Pick Makes Any Space Feel Calmer—Without Going Neutral
The 8 Best Sherwin Williams Sage Green Paint Colors
The 8 Best Sherwin Williams Sage Green Paint Colors
6 BEST WHITE AND NEUTRAL PAINT COLORS BY VALSPAR - SEE THEM IN MY HOME!
6 BEST WHITE AND NEUTRAL PAINT COLORS BY VALSPAR - SEE THEM IN MY HOME!
Valspar vs. Sherwin-Williams: Finding the Right Paint for Every Type of DIYer
Valspar vs. Sherwin-Williams: Finding the Right Paint for Every Type of DIYer
8 Coordinating Colors that Will Make Valspar Warm Putty Look Expensive! - Mod & Mood
8 Coordinating Colors that Will Make Valspar Warm Putty Look Expensive! - Mod & Mood
Valspar Color Palette — Courtyard Shadow & Lavender Mist & More Paint Colors
Valspar Color Palette — Courtyard Shadow & Lavender Mist & More Paint Colors
Top 10 Most Popular Sherwin-Williams Paint Colors 2025
Top 10 Most Popular Sherwin-Williams Paint Colors 2025
Melanie - A whole house color palette for a modern farmhouse | Facebook
Melanie - A whole house color palette for a modern farmhouse | Facebook

Which Brand is Right for You?

Choosing between Valspar and Sherwin-Williams ultimately depends on your specific needs, budget, and personal preference. If you're looking for a wide range of colors and affordability, Valspar might be your best bet. However, if durability and fade resistance are your top priorities, Sherwin-Williams could be the better choice. Always consider your project's requirements and consult with a paint professional if needed.