Derwent ProColour vs Coloursoft: The Ultimate Watercolour Comparison 2024

When comparing professional watercolor pencils, the debate between Derwent Procolour and Coloursoft often arises among artists seeking the perfect balance of pigment richness and usability. Both lines promise high-quality performance, but they cater to slightly different artistic preferences and application techniques. Understanding the distinct characteristics of each can help you determine which product aligns best with your creative workflow.

Core Formulation and Pigment Quality

The fundamental difference lies in their core composition. Derwent Procolour pencils feature a waxy, oil-based binder that results in a harder, more brittle lead. This formulation delivers intense, highly saturated pigment that glides smoothly and layers beautifully without wax bloom. In contrast, Derwent Coloursoft utilizes a softer, clay-based binder, producing a creamy, dough-like consistency that deposits color more heavily and behaves similarly to oil pastels.

Performance in Layering and Blending

Layering capabilities differ significantly between the two. Procolour pencils are designed to be layered over without disturbing underlying layers, thanks to their non-greasy nature. Artists can build gradients and complex tones with precision. Coloursoft, being softer, can be more prone to smearing when layered over, but excels in quick, bold coverage and can be easily reactivated with water for watercolor effects, whereas Procolour requires a solvent or heavy layering to achieve similar water solubility.

Handling and Sharpening

Handling experience is where user preference plays a major role. Procolour pencils maintain a sharp point longer and sharpen cleanly without crumbling, making them ideal for detailed work and fine lines. Coloursoft pencils sharpen quickly but tend to break more easily due to their soft core, requiring frequent touch-ups. The tactile feel is distinctly different: Procolour feels firm and controlled, while Coloursoft feels lush and buttery.

Best Use Cases

For artists focused on botanical illustration, portraiture, or detailed mixed media, Derwent Procolour is often the superior choice due to its precision and layer integrity. Coloursoft shines in expressive, painterly styles, background washes, or when rapid color blocking is desired. Its soft nature makes it excellent for blending large areas quickly, though it may not suit meticulous hatching techniques.

Pigment Load and Lightfastness

Both series offer excellent pigment load, but the practical outcome varies. Procolour’s concentrated pigments provide strong tinctorial strength, meaning a little goes a long way. Coloursoft delivers immediate impact, which can be more consumptive for large works. Regarding longevity, both are generally lightfast, but the specific pigments used within each range will ultimately determine archival quality—always check individual pencil ratings for critical work.

Choosing Between Them

Ultimately, the choice between Derwent Procolour and Coloursoft depends on your artistic goals. If you value control, layering sophistication, and detailed execution, Procolour is the logical investment. If you prioritize vibrant, fast coverage, enjoy watercolor techniques, and embrace a more spontaneous approach, Coloursoft will likely become your go-to tool. Many professional artists keep both in their kit to leverage the unique advantages of each pencil type.