Explore Our Delicious Menu at the Random Bagel Bar

By Teresa

Dive into the world of freshly baked goodness at our lively Random Bagel Bar, where every meal is an invigorating blend of New York-inspired tradition and innovative culinary creativity. Our extensive menu is designed to tantalize your taste buds and brighten your morning, noon, or night. Let's explore the delightful culinary journey that awaits you at our bustling bagel hub.

the menu for bagels is displayed in front of a brick wall and glass window
the menu for bagels is displayed in front of a brick wall and glass window

At Random Bagel Bar, we're committed to sourcing the finest, locally sourced ingredients to craft our delectable bagels and accompany them with a tantalizing array of spreads, toppings, and complementing dishes. From our classic New York-style bagels to our innovative California-inspired creations, there's something to satisfy every craving and curiosity.

Bagel Menu Board🥯
Bagel Menu Board🥯

Bagel Basics

No matter how you like your bagel, whether toasted, plain, or smothered in our homemade cream cheeses, we've got you covered. Our.html menu offers an enticing variety of flavors, each one handcrafted with care and love.

the menu for bagel restaurant is shown in black and white
the menu for bagel restaurant is shown in black and white

Choose from our selection of mouth-watering flavors:

  • Sesame Seed
  • Poppy Seed
  • Everything
  • Plain
  • ganze broth
  • Onion
  • Cinnamon Sugar
Bagel Bar Sign Template Instant Download * Brunch Sign * Bridal Brunch Sign * Bridal Menu Sign * Editable, Printable Instant Download
Bagel Bar Sign Template Instant Download * Brunch Sign * Bridal Brunch Sign * Bridal Menu Sign * Editable, Printable Instant Download

Traditional Flavors

Indulge in the timeless charm of our traditional bagel flavors, evoking memories of bustling New York City streets and the comforting aroma of fresh-baked bread. Our Sesame Seed, Poppy Seed, Plain, and Onion bagels provide a canvas for your culinary creativity, ready to be topped with your favorite spread or accompaniment.

For a truly authentic experience, try one of our classic monsters: a colossal bagel piled high with our schmears,, and your choice of meats, cheeses, or veggies. It's a New York-style bagel sandwich that's sure to leave you satisfied and craving more.

the ultimate bagel bar checklist for valentine's day is shown in pink
the ultimate bagel bar checklist for valentine's day is shown in pink

Signature Flavors

At Random Bagel Bar, we like to think outside the kneading bowl, which is why we're proud to offer a selection of signature bagel flavors that set us apart from the crowd. Our Everything bagel is a symphony of seeds and spices, while the whole wheat Newfoundland's Delight satisfies your sweet tooth with a hint of orange and cranberry.

For something truly unique, try our Green Goddess bagel, adorned with bright green spirals and a flavor reminiscent of fresh pesto. It's the perfect base for our vegetable-laden sandwiches or a schmear of our weekend-only 'Green Goddess Schmear,' made with avocado, lemon, and fresh herbs.

a menu board showing different types of sandwiches
a menu board showing different types of sandwiches

Schmears and Spreads

No bagel is complete without its schmear – the creamy, flavorful spread that elevates your meal from good to extraordinary. Our house-made schmears are crafted with love and yielded with pride, offering a tantalizing array of textures and flavors to complement your bagel or dish.

ベーグル屋さんメニュー
ベーグル屋さんメニュー
two menus with different types of sandwiches on them, one is for bagel sandwich
two menus with different types of sandwiches on them, one is for bagel sandwich
Menu — The Bagel Stop
Menu — The Bagel Stop
MENU | Modern Bread & Bagel
MENU | Modern Bread & Bagel
the ultimate bagel bar checklist is shown in pink and white with red dots
the ultimate bagel bar checklist is shown in pink and white with red dots
Menu — Bagel Union
Menu — Bagel Union
20+ Bagel Toppings for an Easy Brunch Party!
20+ Bagel Toppings for an Easy Brunch Party!
Bagel Menu and Poster Design - Bakery cafe menu design
Bagel Menu and Poster Design - Bakery cafe menu design
bagel shop
bagel shop

From the classic to the creative, our schmears include:

  • Plain
  • Chive & Onion
  • Garrett Socco
  • Scallion & everything Bagel
  • Honey Walnut
  • Garlic & Herb

Classic Schmears

The purist's choice, our Plain schmear lets the natural taste of our bagels shine, while Chive & Onion provides a mild, savory kick to jump-start your day. For a taste of nostalgia, try our Garrett Socco – a creamy, tangy nod to the classic spread that's been delighting bagel lovers for generations.

For those looking to combine their savory and sweet cravings, our Scallion & everything Bagel schmear offers a harmonious blend of flavors that's as addictive as it is unique.

Signature Schmears

Embrace the unexpected with our signature schmears, designed to take your bagel experience to the next level. The Honey Walnut schmear is a sweet counterpart to our savory offerings, while the Garlic & Herb schmear imparts a rich, aromatic depth that's perfect for fans of Mediterranean flavors.

And don't miss out on our weekend-only creations – from our tangy Green Goddess schmear to our smoky jalapeño cheddar, each one is designed to surprise and delight your palate.

Bagel Accompaniments

At Random Bagel Bar, we believe that the perfect meal is more than the sum of its parts. That's why we offer a plethora of accompaniments to complement your bagel or sandwich and create a well-rounded, satisfying dining experience.

Meat & Veggies

A bagel sandwich isn't a bagel sandwich without a generous helping of protein and produce. That's why we're proud to offer a selection of house-cured meats, smoked fish, and locally sourced vegetables to elevate your meal.

Choose from our rotation of meats and fish, including:

  • Lox
  • Nova Scotia Salmon
  • Pastrami
  • Corned Beef
  • Turkey Breast

And enjoy our selection of crisp, fresh veggies, such as:

  • Cucumber
  • Red Onion
  • Tomato
  • Avocado
  • Arugula

Extras and Sides

Sometimes, a bagel alone just won't do. That's why we offer an array of extras and sides to round out your meal and keep you satisfied.

Grab a side of our golden French fries, crisp yet tender and perfectly salted. Or try our house-made pickles, brined in-house for the perfect tangy crunch. And for those in the mood for something sweet, our New York-style cheesecake or seasonal fruit salad provides the perfect finish to your meal.

But we're not done yet! Every day, we introduce a new, rotating special – a unique bagel creation or unexpected twist on a classic, crafted by our culinary team to surprise and delight your taste buds. So, stop in regularly to see what's new and explore the ever-evolving menu at Random Bagel Bar.

At Random Bagel Bar, we're more than just a bagel shop. We're a community of food lovers, united by our passion for creativity, tradition, and exceptional taste. So, whether you're a seasoned bagel aficionado or a curious newcomer, we invite you to join us and experience the joy of freshly baked goodness, one bite at a time. Your bagel adventure awaits!