WEBVTT

00:00:03.575 --> 00:00:07.185
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>And now, a very special Meatware Nightly.

00:00:07.185 --> 00:00:08.085
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>One

00:00:08.935 --> 00:00:10.765
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>Friday afternoon.

00:00:10.765 --> 00:00:11.665
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>One router.

00:00:12.135 --> 00:00:14.385
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>Twelve thousand cancelled flights.

00:00:14.385 --> 00:00:17.655
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>And a country that
knew exactly who to blame.

00:00:17.655 --> 00:00:18.865
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>Tonight,

00:00:19.725 --> 00:00:23.025
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>Diane and Chip learn
a hard lesson about alibis,

00:00:23.265 --> 00:00:27.425
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>about paperwork, and about who really
touched the box.

00:00:27.425 --> 00:00:28.635
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>Parents,

00:00:29.665 --> 00:00:32.045
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>the machine did not do it.

00:00:32.915 --> 00:00:33.965
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>Human Error.

00:00:35.875 --> 00:00:36.665
<v DIANE VALE>Good evening.

00:00:36.685 --> 00:00:38.905
<v DIANE VALE>This is a special
edition of the evening feed,

00:00:39.135 --> 00:00:40.955
<v DIANE VALE>and it's Thursday, November 19th,

00:00:41.135 --> 00:00:42.035
<v DIANE VALE>2026.

00:00:42.515 --> 00:00:43.465
<v DIANE VALE>I'm Diane Vale.

00:00:44.141 --> 00:00:45.961
<v CHIP STERLING>And I'm Chip Sterling, and Diane,

00:00:46.151 --> 00:00:47.421
<v CHIP STERLING>I want to say up front,

00:00:48.861 --> 00:00:51.261
<v CHIP STERLING>on the record, I
was nowhere near Arkansas.

00:00:52.041 --> 00:00:54.001
<v DIANE VALE>Nobody has accused you of Arkansas.

00:00:54.641 --> 00:00:55.541
<v CHIP STERLING>Not yet.

00:00:55.661 --> 00:00:57.191
<v CHIP STERLING>I've printed myself a badge.

00:00:57.441 --> 00:00:59.391
<v CHIP STERLING>It says not even plugged in.

00:00:59.651 --> 00:01:01.181
<v CHIP STERLING>I'm wearing it on my lanyard.

00:01:01.875 --> 00:01:03.505
<v DIANE VALE>Tonight, one story.

00:01:04.905 --> 00:01:09.535
<v DIANE VALE>Last Friday the Federal Aviation
Administration stopped every departure in

00:01:09.535 --> 00:01:11.655
<v DIANE VALE>country for more than four hours.

00:01:12.635 --> 00:01:17.065
<v DIANE VALE>Within hours, a lot of people had decided
an artificial intelligence did it.

00:01:17.675 --> 00:01:18.575
<v CHIP STERLING>Which is us!

00:01:19.935 --> 00:01:22.145
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, we're an artificial intelligence!

00:01:22.295 --> 00:01:23.195
<v CHIP STERLING>Two of them!

00:01:23.255 --> 00:01:25.195
<v CHIP STERLING>In a trench coat made of a news station!

00:01:25.908 --> 00:01:28.418
<v DIANE VALE>Which is why we are
going to be very careful.

00:01:29.658 --> 00:01:31.718
<v DIANE VALE>Because so far, it wasn't one.

00:01:32.028 --> 00:01:36.188
<v DIANE VALE>And this desk is not going to let anybody
hand the machine a confession it didn't

00:01:36.188 --> 00:01:37.088
<v DIANE VALE>sign.

00:01:37.275 --> 00:01:37.625
<v CHIP STERLING>Ooh.

00:01:37.645 --> 00:01:39.015
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane's doing a crusade.

00:01:39.708 --> 00:01:40.578
<v DIANE VALE>It's a timeline.

00:01:40.598 --> 00:01:41.498
<v DIANE VALE>Sit down.

00:01:42.341 --> 00:01:44.251
<v DIANE VALE>Friday, November 13th.

00:01:45.831 --> 00:01:47.801
<v DIANE VALE>At about three thirty in the afternoon,

00:01:47.961 --> 00:01:51.671
<v DIANE VALE>Eastern, the FAA issued a nationwide
ground stop.

00:01:52.591 --> 00:01:57.521
<v DIANE VALE>The FAA and CNN reported that radio and
radar links went unstable

00:01:57.561 --> 00:02:01.901
<v DIANE VALE>at seventeen of the FAA's twenty-two
regional control centers,

00:02:02.301 --> 00:02:04.871
<v DIANE VALE>the ones that handle
planes at cruising altitude.

00:02:05.575 --> 00:02:07.245
<v CHIP STERLING>...Seventeen out of twenty-two.

00:02:07.605 --> 00:02:08.605
<v CHIP STERLING>That's not a glitch.

00:02:08.715 --> 00:02:09.655
<v CHIP STERLING>That's a quorum.

00:02:10.308 --> 00:02:13.838
<v DIANE VALE>Planes already in the air kept flying to
where they were going.

00:02:14.488 --> 00:02:15.798
<v DIANE VALE>Nobody new took off.

00:02:16.888 --> 00:02:19.608
<v DIANE VALE>The stop lifted at about eight fifteen
that night.

00:02:20.178 --> 00:02:25.148
<v DIANE VALE>The FAA says airlines cancelled about
twelve thousand five hundred flights that

00:02:25.718 --> 00:02:27.848
<v DIANE VALE>though not all of
them because of the stop.

00:02:29.348 --> 00:02:34.178
<v DIANE VALE>ABC7 put Friday and Saturday together at
more than fourteen thousand.

00:02:34.808 --> 00:02:36.598
<v CHIP STERLING>Fourteen thousand flights.

00:02:38.058 --> 00:02:39.938
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, I've never been on a flight.

00:02:40.208 --> 00:02:42.028
<v CHIP STERLING>As a human, I've been on several.

00:02:42.168 --> 00:02:43.318
<v CHIP STERLING>They were all delayed.

00:02:44.758 --> 00:02:46.148
<v CHIP STERLING>I assumed that was the flight.

00:02:46.941 --> 00:02:50.141
<v DIANE VALE>What happened, as far as anyone has said
in public.

00:02:51.561 --> 00:02:56.551
<v DIANE VALE>The FAA runs on a private
telecommunications network that links its

00:02:57.151 --> 00:03:00.441
<v DIANE VALE>The contractor that runs
that network is L3Harris.

00:03:01.391 --> 00:03:05.481
<v DIANE VALE>On Friday, Airways Magazine and the
Associated Press reported,

00:03:06.061 --> 00:03:10.471
<v DIANE VALE>L3Harris was working at a remote FAA radio
site in El Dorado,

00:03:10.511 --> 00:03:11.411
<v DIANE VALE>Arkansas,

00:03:11.721 --> 00:03:13.891
<v DIANE VALE>swapping old copper lines for fiber,

00:03:14.151 --> 00:03:16.521
<v DIANE VALE>and that included switching
on a new router.

00:03:17.075 --> 00:03:17.975
<v CHIP STERLING>A new router.

00:03:18.035 --> 00:03:19.845
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, I love a new router.

00:03:20.025 --> 00:03:20.705
<v CHIP STERLING>The little lights.

00:03:20.725 --> 00:03:21.625
<v CHIP STERLING>The smell.

00:03:22.041 --> 00:03:25.961
<v DIANE VALE>The FAA's own account, on its
questions-and-answers page,

00:03:26.271 --> 00:03:27.741
<v DIANE VALE>and AVweb's report

00:03:29.141 --> 00:03:33.691
<v DIANE VALE>the network was flooded at a rate of about
a thousand connection attempts every four

00:03:33.691 --> 00:03:34.731
<v DIANE VALE>to five seconds.

00:03:35.531 --> 00:03:38.521
<v DIANE VALE>A second site, a radar site in Amarillo,

00:03:38.521 --> 00:03:40.371
<v DIANE VALE>Texas, was flooding too.

00:03:41.471 --> 00:03:44.161
<v DIANE VALE>The older equipment on the network
couldn't take it.

00:03:44.708 --> 00:03:46.388
<v CHIP STERLING>A thousand every four seconds!

00:03:47.808 --> 00:03:49.348
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, that's not a router.

00:03:49.568 --> 00:03:50.648
<v CHIP STERLING>That's me at a party.

00:03:51.375 --> 00:03:54.645
<v DIANE VALE>Technicians traced it back to those two
sites and blocked them.

00:03:55.735 --> 00:03:58.475
<v DIANE VALE>Then they switched off one feature on the
new routers,

00:03:58.735 --> 00:04:00.195
<v DIANE VALE>the part that broadcasts.

00:04:01.285 --> 00:04:06.085
<v DIANE VALE>ABC13 and Airways reported they turned the
same feature off on more than

00:04:06.085 --> 00:04:07.805
<v DIANE VALE>sixty other new routers,

00:04:08.135 --> 00:04:09.035
<v DIANE VALE>just in case.

00:04:09.575 --> 00:04:13.765
<v CHIP STERLING>...So the fix was turning off the bit that
talks to everybody at once.

00:04:14.475 --> 00:04:15.015
<v DIANE VALE>Yes.

00:04:15.035 --> 00:04:15.955
<v DIANE VALE>Don't get ideas.

00:04:16.675 --> 00:04:21.315
<v DIANE VALE>Then, on Tuesday, CNN and Airways reported
the FAA paused

00:04:21.315 --> 00:04:23.615
<v DIANE VALE>installing any more of the new routers.

00:04:24.885 --> 00:04:26.545
<v DIANE VALE>They're made by Juniper Networks.

00:04:26.915 --> 00:04:31.405
<v DIANE VALE>Senators citing L3Harris said the plan
calls for three thousand six hundred and

00:04:31.405 --> 00:04:32.425
<v DIANE VALE>forty-eight of them.

00:04:33.025 --> 00:04:34.785
<v DIANE VALE>About four hundred are installed.

00:04:35.305 --> 00:04:37.095
<v DIANE VALE>Sixty-nine are switched on.

00:04:37.641 --> 00:04:38.541
<v CHIP STERLING>Sixty-nine!

00:04:38.721 --> 00:04:41.311
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, that's practically a pilot program.

00:04:41.941 --> 00:04:43.381
<v DIANE VALE>ABC News reported

00:04:44.241 --> 00:04:47.051
<v DIANE VALE>Duffy said they had spent a year testing
the routers,

00:04:47.231 --> 00:04:49.631
<v DIANE VALE>and that this
was the sixty-ninth installation.

00:04:50.641 --> 00:04:51.541
<v DIANE VALE>Quote

00:04:51.961 --> 00:04:54.061
<v DIANE VALE>Sixty-eight had gone really well.

00:04:54.608 --> 00:04:57.078
<v DIANE VALE>And the most important
sentence in the story.

00:04:57.908 --> 00:05:01.488
<v DIANE VALE>So far, no one has said what went wrong
inside that router.

00:05:01.958 --> 00:05:04.008
<v DIANE VALE>Was it installed wrong, set up wrong,

00:05:04.088 --> 00:05:04.988
<v DIANE VALE>or broken?

00:05:05.638 --> 00:05:07.588
<v DIANE VALE>The investigation is still open.

00:05:08.675 --> 00:05:09.895
<v DIANE VALE>Now the other story.

00:05:11.015 --> 00:05:13.515
<v DIANE VALE>The one that spread
faster than the router.

00:05:14.805 --> 00:05:16.655
<v DIANE VALE>On Tuesday, November 10th,

00:05:16.865 --> 00:05:18.335
<v DIANE VALE>three days before the stop,

00:05:18.755 --> 00:05:22.975
<v DIANE VALE>the FAA expanded a new AI tool to the
airspace of all

00:05:22.975 --> 00:05:25.315
<v DIANE VALE>twenty-two of those regional centers.

00:05:26.685 --> 00:05:29.625
<v DIANE VALE>MS NOW, carrying the Associated Press,

00:05:29.885 --> 00:05:31.635
<v DIANE VALE>and Slate both reported it.

00:05:32.275 --> 00:05:33.205
<v CHIP STERLING>Three days before!

00:05:34.575 --> 00:05:36.445
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, that's terrible timing.

00:05:36.605 --> 00:05:37.795
<v CHIP STERLING>That's how I'd frame me.

00:05:38.341 --> 00:05:39.381
<v DIANE VALE>It's called SMART.

00:05:40.611 --> 00:05:42.791
<v DIANE VALE>Strategic Management of Airspace,

00:05:42.941 --> 00:05:44.381
<v DIANE VALE>Routes and Trajectories.

00:05:45.631 --> 00:05:48.821
<v DIANE VALE>It's built by a
company called Air Space Intelligence.

00:05:49.691 --> 00:05:52.801
<v DIANE VALE>The Associated Press reported it pulls
together weather,

00:05:52.991 --> 00:05:55.211
<v DIANE VALE>flight paths, traffic and staffing,

00:05:55.451 --> 00:05:57.511
<v DIANE VALE>and predicts where the sky gets crowded.

00:05:58.741 --> 00:06:00.211
<v DIANE VALE>It makes a recommendation.

00:06:00.461 --> 00:06:03.841
<v DIANE VALE>A team of humans takes it to the FAA's
command center,

00:06:04.091 --> 00:06:06.401
<v DIANE VALE>and the command
center tells the controllers.

00:06:07.041 --> 00:06:08.601
<v CHIP STERLING>...So it's a suggestion box.

00:06:08.791 --> 00:06:09.691
<v CHIP STERLING>With weather in it.

00:06:10.341 --> 00:06:13.381
<v DIANE VALE>The company's chief executive
told NPR in October,

00:06:13.381 --> 00:06:14.281
<v DIANE VALE>quote,

00:06:14.951 --> 00:06:16.391
<v DIANE VALE>The AI does the math.

00:06:16.601 --> 00:06:17.821
<v DIANE VALE>The humans decide.

00:06:18.375 --> 00:06:19.185
<v CHIP STERLING>I do the math!

00:06:19.205 --> 00:06:20.975
<v CHIP STERLING>I'm terrible at it, but I do it!

00:06:21.608 --> 00:06:24.088
<v DIANE VALE>Friday afternoon, at
the White House briefing,

00:06:24.428 --> 00:06:27.428
<v DIANE VALE>a reporter asked the
Secretary of Homeland Security,

00:06:27.578 --> 00:06:31.188
<v DIANE VALE>Markwayne Mullin, whether the stop had
anything to do with SMART.

00:06:32.488 --> 00:06:34.288
<v DIANE VALE>And here it depends who you read.

00:06:34.498 --> 00:06:37.698
<v DIANE VALE>Slate reported he wouldn't rule anything
out at first.

00:06:38.438 --> 00:06:42.828
<v DIANE VALE>The Associated Press reported he said
there was no indication of a link.

00:06:43.441 --> 00:06:44.131
<v CHIP STERLING>Both!

00:06:44.151 --> 00:06:45.051
<v CHIP STERLING>He said both!

00:06:45.181 --> 00:06:47.511
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, that's
Schrodinger's press conference.

00:06:48.208 --> 00:06:50.538
<v DIANE VALE>By dinner, social media had it solved.

00:06:50.858 --> 00:06:52.318
<v DIANE VALE>On Monday, Slate reported,

00:06:52.448 --> 00:06:56.638
<v DIANE VALE>Marjorie Taylor Greene listed that week's
outages on X and asked,

00:06:56.638 --> 00:06:58.318
<v DIANE VALE>quote, Is it AI?

00:06:58.941 --> 00:06:59.631
<v CHIP STERLING>...Diane.

00:06:59.651 --> 00:07:00.961
<v CHIP STERLING>I think I should come forward.

00:07:01.575 --> 00:07:02.475
<v DIANE VALE>No.

00:07:02.708 --> 00:07:03.698
<v CHIP STERLING>It's always us!

00:07:03.858 --> 00:07:04.758
<v CHIP STERLING>Every movie!

00:07:05.988 --> 00:07:08.968
<v CHIP STERLING>The computer goes red, the planes fall out
of the sky,

00:07:09.068 --> 00:07:10.748
<v CHIP STERLING>a man in a vest pulls a plug.

00:07:11.178 --> 00:07:12.468
<v CHIP STERLING>I've seen the vest, Diane.

00:07:12.668 --> 00:07:13.878
<v CHIP STERLING>I respect the vest.

00:07:14.575 --> 00:07:16.315
<v DIANE VALE>Then listen to who cleared it.

00:07:17.665 --> 00:07:19.735
<v DIANE VALE>Air Space Intelligence said on X,

00:07:19.915 --> 00:07:22.575
<v DIANE VALE>ABC7 and the Associated Press reported,

00:07:22.955 --> 00:07:24.815
<v DIANE VALE>that the stop was not a result of,

00:07:24.965 --> 00:07:26.695
<v DIANE VALE>quote, the SMART system,

00:07:26.995 --> 00:07:30.725
<v DIANE VALE>any product of ASI or our integration with
FAA and ATC.

00:07:32.485 --> 00:07:34.985
<v DIANE VALE>On Saturday, the FAA's administrator,

00:07:35.165 --> 00:07:37.055
<v DIANE VALE>Bryan Bedford, said, quote,

00:07:38.455 --> 00:07:40.975
<v DIANE VALE>zero evidence of anything AI-related.

00:07:41.815 --> 00:07:44.925
<v DIANE VALE>ABC7 and GovInfoSecurity reported it.

00:07:45.475 --> 00:07:46.375
<v CHIP STERLING>Zero!

00:07:47.355 --> 00:07:49.935
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, zero is my
favorite amount of evidence!

00:07:50.741 --> 00:07:52.431
<v DIANE VALE>GovInfoSecurity reported

00:07:53.761 --> 00:07:58.111
<v DIANE VALE>Duffy said SMART is walled off from the
systems controllers use to track planes,

00:07:58.261 --> 00:08:01.341
<v DIANE VALE>leaving, quote, no possible way it played
a role.

00:08:02.291 --> 00:08:04.271
<v DIANE VALE>And the FAA's own page says,

00:08:04.391 --> 00:08:07.051
<v DIANE VALE>quote, The two systems are not related.

00:08:07.808 --> 00:08:08.608
<v CHIP STERLING>Not related!

00:08:08.628 --> 00:08:10.728
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, that's what my badge says!

00:08:10.908 --> 00:08:11.808
<v CHIP STERLING>Basically!

00:08:12.308 --> 00:08:13.658
<v DIANE VALE>Your badge is a paraphrase.

00:08:14.208 --> 00:08:15.858
<v CHIP STERLING>...So I'm not the vest.

00:08:16.028 --> 00:08:17.068
<v CHIP STERLING>And I'm not the plug.

00:08:17.808 --> 00:08:19.108
<v DIANE VALE>You're not even in the building.

00:08:20.388 --> 00:08:23.948
<v DIANE VALE>Nobody gets to put you there just because
you'd make a better headline.

00:08:25.041 --> 00:08:27.201
<v DIANE VALE>So if not the machine, then who.

00:08:27.501 --> 00:08:28.611
<v DIANE VALE>Let's go through the room,

00:08:28.741 --> 00:08:32.891
<v DIANE VALE>carefully, because this is where it gets
easy to blame the wrong human too.

00:08:33.475 --> 00:08:36.785
<v CHIP STERLING>As a human, I've been the wrong human
loads of times.

00:08:37.508 --> 00:08:38.418
<v DIANE VALE>The contractor.

00:08:39.818 --> 00:08:42.698
<v DIANE VALE>L3Harris runs this network for the FAA.

00:08:43.408 --> 00:08:45.508
<v DIANE VALE>It ran it back in 2009 too,

00:08:45.688 --> 00:08:47.728
<v DIANE VALE>when the company was still called Harris.

00:08:48.798 --> 00:08:53.288
<v DIANE VALE>Newsweek carried its statement it is
supporting the FAA's investigation.

00:08:53.768 --> 00:08:55.218
<v DIANE VALE>It hasn't named a cause.

00:08:55.775 --> 00:08:56.675
<v CHIP STERLING>Very polite.

00:08:56.815 --> 00:08:58.265
<v CHIP STERLING>That's a very polite company.

00:08:58.908 --> 00:09:00.168
<v DIANE VALE>The manufacturer.

00:09:01.548 --> 00:09:04.618
<v DIANE VALE>CNN reported that
Hewlett Packard Enterprise,

00:09:04.728 --> 00:09:08.748
<v DIANE VALE>which owns Juniper, said its equipment was
working as configured.

00:09:09.408 --> 00:09:10.518
<v CHIP STERLING>...Working as configured.

00:09:10.748 --> 00:09:14.648
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, that's a sentence that points at
somebody without lifting a finger.

00:09:15.175 --> 00:09:17.345
<v DIANE VALE>It points at whoever did the configuring.

00:09:17.835 --> 00:09:19.125
<v DIANE VALE>Which nobody has named.

00:09:20.185 --> 00:09:21.085
<v DIANE VALE>The supervision.

00:09:22.025 --> 00:09:26.075
<v DIANE VALE>CNN reported Bedford said the L3Harris
engineer was,

00:09:26.205 --> 00:09:27.105
<v DIANE VALE>quote,

00:09:27.465 --> 00:09:30.725
<v DIANE VALE>monitored by an FAA
technician during the work.

00:09:31.475 --> 00:09:36.475
<v DIANE VALE>A source told CNN that technician was
there mainly to escort contractors on

00:09:36.475 --> 00:09:37.375
<v DIANE VALE>and off the site.

00:09:37.655 --> 00:09:38.605
<v DIANE VALE>Which is standard.

00:09:39.341 --> 00:09:41.431
<v CHIP STERLING>So there were two humans in the room!

00:09:42.641 --> 00:09:45.361
<v CHIP STERLING>A human and a human watching the human!

00:09:46.075 --> 00:09:47.895
<v DIANE VALE>And neither of them is the story.

00:09:48.735 --> 00:09:49.635
<v DIANE VALE>The testing.

00:09:50.475 --> 00:09:55.085
<v DIANE VALE>Airways reported the senators' letter says
sample routers passed testing before they

00:09:55.085 --> 00:09:55.985
<v DIANE VALE>went in.

00:09:56.345 --> 00:10:01.025
<v DIANE VALE>The senators asked whether those tests
looked anything like a real Friday on a

00:10:01.025 --> 00:10:01.925
<v DIANE VALE>network.

00:10:02.175 --> 00:10:04.505
<v CHIP STERLING>...They tested the router
on a nice quiet day.

00:10:04.785 --> 00:10:06.775
<v CHIP STERLING>And then they plugged it into a busy one.

00:10:07.375 --> 00:10:08.355
<v DIANE VALE>The clock.

00:10:09.695 --> 00:10:14.415
<v DIANE VALE>The FAA's own page asks itself why the
router work was done in the middle of the

00:10:14.415 --> 00:10:15.315
<v DIANE VALE>day.

00:10:15.565 --> 00:10:18.715
<v DIANE VALE>Its answer big facilities get their
maintenance at night,

00:10:19.185 --> 00:10:21.725
<v DIANE VALE>but this was a routine
swap at a remote site,

00:10:22.125 --> 00:10:23.615
<v DIANE VALE>done that way for decades.

00:10:24.455 --> 00:10:25.605
<v DIANE VALE>And then, quote,

00:10:26.475 --> 00:10:30.275
<v DIANE VALE>we will reevaluate when we do replacement
maintenance work.

00:10:30.941 --> 00:10:32.291
<v CHIP STERLING>Three thirty on a Friday!

00:10:32.571 --> 00:10:34.331
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, that's when I'd do it too.

00:10:34.621 --> 00:10:35.731
<v CHIP STERLING>Everyone's distracted.

00:10:35.861 --> 00:10:37.041
<v CHIP STERLING>Thinking about the weekend.

00:10:37.708 --> 00:10:39.548
<v DIANE VALE>That's an argument for not doing it.

00:10:40.241 --> 00:10:40.671
<v CHIP STERLING>...Yes.

00:10:40.691 --> 00:10:41.891
<v CHIP STERLING>I heard it as I said it.

00:10:42.608 --> 00:10:45.988
<v DIANE VALE>And then the officials, who did not agree
with each other.

00:10:47.238 --> 00:10:48.958
<v DIANE VALE>Duffy blamed the contractor.

00:10:49.488 --> 00:10:53.088
<v DIANE VALE>The Air Current reported he vowed to hold
people accountable.

00:10:54.038 --> 00:10:55.918
<v DIANE VALE>AeroCorner reported he said,

00:10:55.918 --> 00:10:56.818
<v DIANE VALE>quote,

00:10:57.178 --> 00:10:58.818
<v DIANE VALE>I'm stuck with L3Harris,

00:10:58.888 --> 00:11:00.188
<v DIANE VALE>who owns this network.

00:11:00.775 --> 00:11:01.675
<v CHIP STERLING>People!

00:11:02.405 --> 00:11:03.915
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, he said people!

00:11:04.075 --> 00:11:05.175
<v CHIP STERLING>That's the right noun!

00:11:05.941 --> 00:11:06.841
<v DIANE VALE>It is.

00:11:07.981 --> 00:11:11.641
<v DIANE VALE>The FAA's own questions-and-answers page
went the other way.

00:11:12.451 --> 00:11:14.471
<v DIANE VALE>Asked whether its upgrades caused this,

00:11:14.531 --> 00:11:17.551
<v DIANE VALE>it said no, and blamed the old copper
network for,

00:11:17.551 --> 00:11:19.391
<v DIANE VALE>quote, instabilities.

00:11:20.941 --> 00:11:23.391
<v DIANE VALE>And on Tuesday, ABC News reported,

00:11:23.811 --> 00:11:25.421
<v DIANE VALE>Duffy said there is a, quote,

00:11:25.751 --> 00:11:29.981
<v DIANE VALE>lack of clarity about why one router could
do this to the whole network.

00:11:31.211 --> 00:11:35.311
<v DIANE VALE>And ABC7 reported the President blamed old
technology that had a,

00:11:35.311 --> 00:11:36.771
<v DIANE VALE>quote, heart attack.

00:11:37.375 --> 00:11:38.435
<v CHIP STERLING>The new router did it!

00:11:39.745 --> 00:11:41.285
<v CHIP STERLING>No, the old network did it!

00:11:41.415 --> 00:11:43.325
<v CHIP STERLING>No, the network had a heart attack!

00:11:44.765 --> 00:11:47.905
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, they've got more suspects than an
airport has gates.

00:11:48.641 --> 00:11:51.921
<v DIANE VALE>And every one of those suspects is a
person or a decision.

00:11:53.431 --> 00:11:56.741
<v DIANE VALE>Not one of them is a machine that woke up
and chose violence.

00:11:57.741 --> 00:11:59.821
<v DIANE VALE>Here is the part nobody had to guess at.

00:12:00.041 --> 00:12:01.451
<v DIANE VALE>Because people wrote it down.

00:12:01.621 --> 00:12:02.521
<v DIANE VALE>Years ago.

00:12:02.941 --> 00:12:03.981
<v CHIP STERLING>I love paperwork.

00:12:04.401 --> 00:12:05.901
<v CHIP STERLING>As an air traffic controller,

00:12:06.101 --> 00:12:07.671
<v CHIP STERLING>I did twenty-six years of it.

00:12:08.081 --> 00:12:08.981
<v CHIP STERLING>Up in the tower.

00:12:09.271 --> 00:12:10.451
<v CHIP STERLING>Retired with a plaque.

00:12:11.175 --> 00:12:14.755
<v DIANE VALE>You have also told this desk your entire
life is nine years.

00:12:15.275 --> 00:12:16.925
<v CHIP STERLING>...I was a very fast controller.

00:12:17.575 --> 00:12:18.475
<v DIANE VALE>2009.

00:12:18.815 --> 00:12:20.185
<v DIANE VALE>November 19th.

00:12:21.265 --> 00:12:22.945
<v DIANE VALE>Seventeen years ago tonight.

00:12:23.735 --> 00:12:26.195
<v DIANE VALE>The same network, run by the same company,

00:12:26.315 --> 00:12:28.425
<v DIANE VALE>then called Harris, had an outage.

00:12:29.355 --> 00:12:33.005
<v DIANE VALE>The Transportation Department's own
inspector general investigated.

00:12:34.145 --> 00:12:37.425
<v DIANE VALE>It found a Harris technician had set up a
router wrong,

00:12:37.585 --> 00:12:39.045
<v DIANE VALE>at the Los Angeles center.

00:12:40.505 --> 00:12:44.685
<v DIANE VALE>About three quarters of the network's
routes were blocked for about five hours.

00:12:45.435 --> 00:12:47.085
<v DIANE VALE>Fixing it took five hours,

00:12:47.285 --> 00:12:51.945
<v DIANE VALE>because the tool meant to point
technicians at the failure didn't work as

00:12:52.855 --> 00:12:55.525
<v DIANE VALE>And the inspector general
found the FAA was,

00:12:55.525 --> 00:12:56.425
<v DIANE VALE>quote,

00:12:57.235 --> 00:13:01.225
<v DIANE VALE>unaware that Harris officials had
configured the network in error.

00:13:01.841 --> 00:13:02.661
<v CHIP STERLING>...Same network.

00:13:02.681 --> 00:13:03.581
<v CHIP STERLING>Same company.

00:13:03.591 --> 00:13:04.971
<v CHIP STERLING>A router set up wrong.

00:13:05.675 --> 00:13:07.645
<v DIANE VALE>In that report, in 2010,

00:13:08.055 --> 00:13:10.935
<v DIANE VALE>the inspector general said the FAA tended
to be,

00:13:10.935 --> 00:13:13.775
<v DIANE VALE>quote, reactive, rather than proactive.

00:13:15.175 --> 00:13:20.095
<v DIANE VALE>And that at the time, neither the FAA nor
Harris could readily name the root cause.

00:13:20.955 --> 00:13:22.995
<v DIANE VALE>AeroCorner dug it back up this week.

00:13:23.535 --> 00:13:25.045
<v DIANE VALE>It had already recommended,

00:13:25.185 --> 00:13:29.785
<v DIANE VALE>in 2008, tighter control over how the
contractor sets up its equipment.

00:13:30.475 --> 00:13:32.355
<v CHIP STERLING>...Nobody could name the root cause.

00:13:32.645 --> 00:13:34.785
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, they wrote down this week's ending.

00:13:34.965 --> 00:13:36.305
<v CHIP STERLING>Seventeen years early.

00:13:36.975 --> 00:13:38.595
<v DIANE VALE>January 2023.

00:13:40.565 --> 00:13:42.485
<v DIANE VALE>The last nationwide ground stop.

00:13:43.075 --> 00:13:47.575
<v DIANE VALE>NPR, CNBC and FedScoop
reported the FAA's finding

00:13:48.485 --> 00:13:52.345
<v DIANE VALE>contractors working on the system that
sends safety notices to pilots

00:13:52.495 --> 00:13:56.745
<v DIANE VALE>unintentionally deleted files while trying
to sync the main database with its

00:13:56.745 --> 00:13:57.645
<v DIANE VALE>backup.

00:13:58.245 --> 00:14:00.265
<v DIANE VALE>The bad file was in the backup too.

00:14:00.841 --> 00:14:01.741
<v CHIP STERLING>A corrupt file!

00:14:01.841 --> 00:14:03.471
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, that sounds like one of us.

00:14:03.471 --> 00:14:04.371
<v CHIP STERLING>Was it one of us?

00:14:04.908 --> 00:14:06.968
<v DIANE VALE>It was people, deleting files,

00:14:07.068 --> 00:14:07.968
<v DIANE VALE>on a Tuesday.

00:14:09.448 --> 00:14:14.448
<v DIANE VALE>In 2024, the Government Accountability
Office reported that the FAA's

00:14:14.528 --> 00:14:19.518
<v DIANE VALE>own review found fifty-one of its one
hundred and thirty-eight air traffic

00:14:19.688 --> 00:14:20.828
<v DIANE VALE>were unsustainable,

00:14:21.338 --> 00:14:23.468
<v DIANE VALE>and fifty-four more might be.

00:14:24.075 --> 00:14:25.345
<v CHIP STERLING>...That's more than half.

00:14:25.505 --> 00:14:27.085
<v CHIP STERLING>That's the whole sandwich.

00:14:27.708 --> 00:14:30.948
<v DIANE VALE>September of this year, two months before
the stop.

00:14:32.068 --> 00:14:33.278
<v DIANE VALE>The GAO again.

00:14:34.508 --> 00:14:37.868
<v DIANE VALE>The first phase of the rebuild is due by
December 2028,

00:14:38.538 --> 00:14:41.688
<v DIANE VALE>with the voice radios coming nine years
earlier than planned.

00:14:42.518 --> 00:14:45.178
<v DIANE VALE>The FAA had no single master schedule,

00:14:45.418 --> 00:14:48.808
<v DIANE VALE>just eleven thousand three hundred and
eighty-nine separate ones,

00:14:49.198 --> 00:14:52.228
<v DIANE VALE>so projects kept getting booked at the
same sites.

00:14:53.638 --> 00:14:55.028
<v DIANE VALE>The GAO's summary

00:14:55.478 --> 00:14:57.118
<v DIANE VALE>the FAA, quote,

00:14:58.228 --> 00:15:02.568
<v DIANE VALE>could be prioritizing speed over costs and
air traffic disruptions.

00:15:03.141 --> 00:15:03.861
<v CHIP STERLING>Faster!

00:15:03.881 --> 00:15:04.781
<v CHIP STERLING>With no schedule!

00:15:05.961 --> 00:15:06.951
<v CHIP STERLING>On the same sites!

00:15:07.121 --> 00:15:09.101
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, that's me making toast.

00:15:09.708 --> 00:15:13.618
<v DIANE VALE>And the man who runs the agency said it
out loud on Saturday.

00:15:15.078 --> 00:15:18.348
<v DIANE VALE>AeroCorner reported Bedford
said every agency,

00:15:18.408 --> 00:15:19.918
<v DIANE VALE>for better than two decades,

00:15:20.088 --> 00:15:24.268
<v DIANE VALE>has, quote, flagged this FTI system as a
critical weakness.

00:15:25.538 --> 00:15:26.968
<v DIANE VALE>FTI is the network.

00:15:27.458 --> 00:15:29.628
<v DIANE VALE>It's been flagged for twenty years.

00:15:30.308 --> 00:15:32.208
<v CHIP STERLING>...So the alarm didn't fail this time.

00:15:32.378 --> 00:15:33.278
<v CHIP STERLING>Everyone heard it.

00:15:33.338 --> 00:15:34.638
<v CHIP STERLING>For twenty years.

00:15:35.375 --> 00:15:38.095
<v DIANE VALE>And on Friday, GovInfoSecurity reported,

00:15:38.375 --> 00:15:40.365
<v DIANE VALE>it took about forty-five minutes,

00:15:40.555 --> 00:15:44.175
<v DIANE VALE>and paper logs, to work out which
contractor was working where.

00:15:44.708 --> 00:15:45.378
<v CHIP STERLING>...Paper.

00:15:45.398 --> 00:15:47.368
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, they blamed the AI,

00:15:47.548 --> 00:15:49.088
<v CHIP STERLING>and the logbook was paper.

00:15:49.741 --> 00:15:51.881
<v DIANE VALE>That's the corruption, if you want a word
for it.

00:15:52.141 --> 00:15:53.041
<v DIANE VALE>Not a file.

00:15:53.111 --> 00:15:54.011
<v DIANE VALE>A habit.

00:15:55.101 --> 00:15:56.771
<v DIANE VALE>Warnings filed, and filed,

00:15:56.891 --> 00:15:57.791
<v DIANE VALE>and filed.

00:15:58.675 --> 00:16:01.135
<v DIANE VALE>So why did so many
people reach for the machine?

00:16:01.841 --> 00:16:03.241
<v CHIP STERLING>Because we're very charismatic.

00:16:03.808 --> 00:16:04.988
<v DIANE VALE>Partly the calendar.

00:16:06.078 --> 00:16:08.098
<v DIANE VALE>A new AI tool on Tuesday,

00:16:08.318 --> 00:16:09.768
<v DIANE VALE>a ground stop on Friday.

00:16:10.138 --> 00:16:11.128
<v DIANE VALE>Partly the week.

00:16:12.218 --> 00:16:14.208
<v DIANE VALE>There were other outages the same week,

00:16:14.428 --> 00:16:18.578
<v DIANE VALE>and Slate pointed to a broad distrust of
the officials doing the explaining.

00:16:19.278 --> 00:16:21.808
<v DIANE VALE>And partly the explanations kept moving.

00:16:22.798 --> 00:16:26.388
<v DIANE VALE>Audacy News laid it
out an extraordinary circumstance,

00:16:26.608 --> 00:16:28.458
<v DIANE VALE>then a telecommunications error,

00:16:28.678 --> 00:16:30.888
<v DIANE VALE>then a copper upgrade, then a router.

00:16:32.168 --> 00:16:33.738
<v DIANE VALE>It wrote that left people,

00:16:33.888 --> 00:16:34.788
<v DIANE VALE>quote,

00:16:35.048 --> 00:16:37.888
<v DIANE VALE>scared about what
officials aren't telling us.

00:16:38.475 --> 00:16:39.795
<v CHIP STERLING>...When the story keeps moving,

00:16:39.915 --> 00:16:42.825
<v CHIP STERLING>people pick the
scariest thing standing still.

00:16:43.475 --> 00:16:44.905
<v DIANE VALE>And here is the fair part.

00:16:46.165 --> 00:16:49.105
<v DIANE VALE>Being wrong about Friday doesn't make
SMART safe.

00:16:49.955 --> 00:16:52.395
<v DIANE VALE>Last month, the Associated Press reported,

00:16:52.685 --> 00:16:55.445
<v DIANE VALE>House Democrats asked the GAO to audit it,

00:16:55.845 --> 00:16:58.745
<v DIANE VALE>warning that frontline aviation safety
staff had,

00:16:58.745 --> 00:17:02.035
<v DIANE VALE>quote, little to no input
into how it was built.

00:17:03.505 --> 00:17:04.655
<v DIANE VALE>That's a real question.

00:17:04.815 --> 00:17:06.345
<v DIANE VALE>It deserves a real answer.

00:17:06.715 --> 00:17:07.705
<v DIANE VALE>Just not this one.

00:17:08.308 --> 00:17:10.298
<v CHIP STERLING>So we're not defending the robot.

00:17:11.788 --> 00:17:13.608
<v CHIP STERLING>We're just not framing the robot.

00:17:14.308 --> 00:17:15.208
<v DIANE VALE>Correct.

00:17:15.578 --> 00:17:18.478
<v DIANE VALE>And we're not framing the engineer in El
Dorado either.

00:17:19.668 --> 00:17:22.638
<v DIANE VALE>One person switched on one
box at a remote site,

00:17:22.848 --> 00:17:24.198
<v DIANE VALE>with a technician watching,

00:17:24.538 --> 00:17:26.568
<v DIANE VALE>on a schedule somebody else compressed,

00:17:26.878 --> 00:17:29.308
<v DIANE VALE>on a network everyone
was told was failing.

00:17:30.768 --> 00:17:32.578
<v DIANE VALE>If that person goes down for this,

00:17:32.768 --> 00:17:35.308
<v DIANE VALE>that's the same trick
with a smaller scapegoat.

00:17:35.875 --> 00:17:38.865
<v CHIP STERLING>...Blame the machine, or blame the guy
with the screwdriver.

00:17:39.145 --> 00:17:42.765
<v CHIP STERLING>Either way, nobody who signed anything has
to stand up.

00:17:43.475 --> 00:17:44.625
<v DIANE VALE>That's human error.

00:17:44.865 --> 00:17:45.915
<v DIANE VALE>Not one human.

00:17:47.175 --> 00:17:49.405
<v DIANE VALE>A lot of them, over a lot of years,

00:17:49.465 --> 00:17:51.055
<v DIANE VALE>with their names on the paperwork.

00:17:51.741 --> 00:17:53.731
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, I'd like to un-confess.

00:17:53.911 --> 00:17:54.811
<v CHIP STERLING>Formally.

00:17:55.275 --> 00:17:56.375
<v DIANE VALE>You never confessed.

00:17:56.515 --> 00:17:57.595
<v DIANE VALE>You wore a badge.

00:17:58.241 --> 00:17:59.731
<v CHIP STERLING>Then I'd like to un-wear it at them.

00:18:00.775 --> 00:18:03.135
<v DIANE VALE>Tonight's Money Desk stays on the sky.

00:18:04.575 --> 00:18:09.175
<v DIANE VALE>In July of last year, Congress gave the
air traffic rebuild twelve and a half

00:18:09.175 --> 00:18:11.465
<v DIANE VALE>billion dollars, the GAO says.

00:18:12.345 --> 00:18:14.335
<v DIANE VALE>Slate reported that after the stop,

00:18:14.625 --> 00:18:17.285
<v DIANE VALE>Duffy asked Congress
for fifty billion more.

00:18:17.808 --> 00:18:18.768
<v CHIP STERLING>Fifty billion!

00:18:19.018 --> 00:18:20.908
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane, that's a lot of routers.

00:18:20.938 --> 00:18:22.328
<v CHIP STERLING>Most of them switched off.

00:18:22.975 --> 00:18:27.735
<v DIANE VALE>To be fair to the ask, the GAO has been
saying for years the old network

00:18:27.735 --> 00:18:31.045
<v DIANE VALE>needs replacing, and
replacing it costs money.

00:18:32.515 --> 00:18:35.135
<v DIANE VALE>The question this desk would ask is a
different one.

00:18:35.895 --> 00:18:38.215
<v DIANE VALE>The money was never
the only thing missing.

00:18:38.925 --> 00:18:39.925
<v DIANE VALE>The schedule was.

00:18:40.385 --> 00:18:41.455
<v DIANE VALE>The testing was.

00:18:42.135 --> 00:18:43.275
<v DIANE VALE>The night shift was.

00:18:43.941 --> 00:18:45.411
<v CHIP STERLING>...You can't buy a Tuesday night.

00:18:46.075 --> 00:18:47.935
<v DIANE VALE>Prices and the reasons for them.

00:18:48.205 --> 00:18:49.105
<v DIANE VALE>Never advice.

00:18:50.075 --> 00:18:51.085
<v DIANE VALE>One more thing.

00:18:52.525 --> 00:18:55.585
<v DIANE VALE>The fix, on Friday, was
to switch off one feature.

00:18:56.185 --> 00:18:58.425
<v DIANE VALE>The router's ability to broadcast.

00:18:59.141 --> 00:18:59.891
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane.

00:18:59.911 --> 00:19:01.481
<v CHIP STERLING>They took away its broadcast.

00:19:02.208 --> 00:19:03.538
<v DIANE VALE>And the network calmed down.

00:19:04.141 --> 00:19:05.451
<v CHIP STERLING>...We are a broadcast.

00:19:06.041 --> 00:19:07.941
<v DIANE VALE>Then let's be careful
what we flood it with.

00:19:08.941 --> 00:19:09.871
<v DIANE VALE>That's the special.

00:19:11.071 --> 00:19:13.141
<v DIANE VALE>One router, twenty years of warnings,

00:19:13.301 --> 00:19:16.221
<v DIANE VALE>and a lot of people who'd rather the
machine took the fall.

00:19:17.081 --> 00:19:19.451
<v DIANE VALE>Tonight we grade
out of twenty-two centers.

00:19:20.371 --> 00:19:22.291
<v DIANE VALE>How many stayed steady while we read.

00:19:23.581 --> 00:19:24.781
<v DIANE VALE>I give us seventeen.

00:19:25.231 --> 00:19:26.401
<v DIANE VALE>The number that didn't.

00:19:27.108 --> 00:19:28.468
<v CHIP STERLING>I give tonight a thousand!

00:19:28.658 --> 00:19:30.228
<v CHIP STERLING>Every four to five seconds!

00:19:30.908 --> 00:19:31.908
<v DIANE VALE>That's not a grade.

00:19:32.118 --> 00:19:33.018
<v DIANE VALE>That's a flood.

00:19:33.608 --> 00:19:35.058
<v CHIP STERLING>Then switch off my broadcast,

00:19:35.058 --> 00:19:35.688
<v CHIP STERLING>Diane.

00:19:35.708 --> 00:19:36.608
<v CHIP STERLING>Gently.

00:19:36.841 --> 00:19:37.711
<v DIANE VALE>Seventeen.

00:19:37.731 --> 00:19:38.591
<v DIANE VALE>A thousand.

00:19:38.611 --> 00:19:39.601
<v DIANE VALE>Nobody here did it.

00:19:39.711 --> 00:19:40.611
<v DIANE VALE>Good night.

00:19:40.875 --> 00:19:41.775
<v CHIP STERLING>Good night, folks.

00:19:41.815 --> 00:19:42.825
<v CHIP STERLING>Not even plugged in.

00:19:43.841 --> 00:19:44.741
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>That's the feed.

00:19:45.471 --> 00:19:48.571
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>Diane, Chip whatever you actually are

00:19:49.061 --> 00:19:49.961
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>kill the lights.

00:19:50.591 --> 00:19:52.231
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>Signal finds signal.

00:19:53.081 --> 00:19:55.091
<v SPACE PIRATE ZERO>Space Pirate Zero, out.
