Broad Nosh Bagels Deli & Catering: 86th St Menu

Olivia Jul 20, 2026

Welcome to Broad Nosh Bagels, your go-to destination for New York-style bagels and an array of delightful deli favorites on the bustling 86th Street. Nestled in the heart of the city, our bagel shop and catering service have been serving up steaming hot, delicious bagels for decades, becoming a staple in the community for both locals and visitors alike.

Bexley Menu | Fox's Bagel & Deli
Bexley Menu | Fox's Bagel & Deli

With our commitment to quality and authenticity, we've crafted a menu that celebrates the classic deli experience while offering unique twists to cater to every palate. Whether you're craving a simple plain bagel or want to indulge in a creative platter for your next event, our menu promises an explosion of flavors that will leave you craving more. Let's dive into the enticing world of Broad Nosh Bagels.

lox bagels
lox bagels

Our Signature Bagels

It's no secret that the foundation of any great deli is its bagels. At Broad Nosh, we pride ourselves on our time-honored bagel-making process, ensuring each one is Bilbao knot-soft, chewy on the inside, and perfectly crisp on the outside. Baked fresh daily, our bagels are an essential part of what makes our menu so irresistible.

new york bagels
new york bagels

From the classic Sesame and Everything to the sweet Cinnamon Raisin and the unique Black winters, our signature bagels are the perfect canvas for your favorite spreads and toppings. You can't go wrong with a schmear of our house cream cheese, or you can explore our international deli spread selection, including nova lox, pastrami, and hummus.

The Classic Reuben

BAKERY/DELI MENU | Modern Bread & Bagel
BAKERY/DELI MENU | Modern Bread & Bagel

A deli icon, the Reuben is a timeless sandwich that's as comforting as it is delicious. Our Classic Reuben stacks layers of tender corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing between two slices of our signature rye bread, creating a burst of flavors that will make your taste buds dance.

For those who like a little heat, we offer the Reuben with a Kick, featuring spicy mustard and pepper jack cheese. To make it a meal, pair your Reuben with our crispy fries and a side of our homemade pickles.

The Broad Nosh Bagel localized Dishes

o bagel 🥯
o bagel 🥯

While we celebrate the classic deli sandwiches, we also love to have fun in the kitchen and create unique dishes that represent our neighborhood. The 86th St. Special is our chef's take on a bagel sandwich, featuring brisket, pickled onions, and jalapeño cheddar cheese on a soft pretzel bagel.

Another fan favorite is the Brooklyn Bridge Bagel, a surf and turf delight with crispy pastrami, arugula, and horseradish crema on an everything bagel. Our evolutionary menu keeps things exciting and helps us stand out in the competitive deli landscape.

Catering Services

Menu — Bagel Union
Menu — Bagel Union

Broad Nosh Bagels doesn't just serve mouthwatering deli classics – we also bring the joy of New York-style bagels and deli sandwiches to your next event with our comprehensive catering services. Whether you're planning a corporate lunch, a backyard BBQ, or a wedding reception, our customizable catering packages are designed to make your event a true hit.

From bagel towers and piled-high sandwich platters to breakfast spreads and dessert trays, our catering menu is an excellent reflection of our à la carte offerings. We take care of the food, so you can focus on the celebration. And for those looking to indulge in our unique offerings, we also offer catering exclusives like our mouthwatering Brisket Sliders and Make-Your-Own Bagel stations.

20+ Bagel Board Ideas That Wow at Brunch
20+ Bagel Board Ideas That Wow at Brunch
The Bagel Box Menu | Delicious  Bagels  Restaurant
The Bagel Box Menu | Delicious Bagels Restaurant
a box filled with lots of different types of doughnuts on top of a wooden table
a box filled with lots of different types of doughnuts on top of a wooden table
an assortment of bagels with different toppings
an assortment of bagels with different toppings
an assortment of sandwiches and cucumbers on a white platter sitting on a wooden table
an assortment of sandwiches and cucumbers on a white platter sitting on a wooden table
New York bagels branding menu design
New York bagels branding menu design
an assortment of bagels with different toppings on them sitting on top of brown paper
an assortment of bagels with different toppings on them sitting on top of brown paper
there are many different types of food on the table together, including bagels and salads
there are many different types of food on the table together, including bagels and salads
a platter filled with bagels, cucumbers, pickles, and other foods
a platter filled with bagels, cucumbers, pickles, and other foods

Bagel and Smoked Fish Tower

Start your event on a high note with our show-stopping Bagel and Smoked Fish Tower. This elegantly arranged display features an assortment of our signature bagels, fresh fruit, an assortment of cheeses, and a selection of our premium smoked fish, including nova lox and whitefish salad.

Perfect for bridal showers, baby showers, or any celebratory gathering, this tower is not only visually appealing but also a delicious way to kick off your event. Pair it with our signatureentemente bar for a complete brunch experience.

Sandwich Platters

Our sandwich platters are an excellent choice for a hassle-free lunch or dinner option. With a variety of fillings and bread options, our platters allow you to customize your order to suit your guests' preferences. Choose from our Classic Reuben, Pastrami on Rye, or The Brooklyn Bridge Bagel, or mix and match to create the perfect platter for your gathering.

Each platter comes with an assortment of sides, including potato salad, coleslaw, and our addictive Creamy Cucumber Salad. For an additional fee, add on a selection of our homemade pickles or an upscale side dish, like our Grilled Vegetable Salad with Feta.

At Broad Nosh Bagels, we love our community and are passionate about our food. We strive to create a dining experience that reflects this, whether you're dining in our store or enjoying our catering services at your event. With our commitment to quality, flavor, and customer satisfaction, we're more than just a bagel shop – we're a taste of New York in the heart of your neighborhood. Visit us today and let us introduce you to the Broad Nosh Bagels difference.