Fun Paper Plate Award Ideas: 25 Creative & Easy DIY Designs

Ella Jun 26, 2026

Throwing a memorable party often hinges on the small, thoughtful touches that make guests feel recognized and appreciated. While elaborate trophies have their place, there is a unique, charming charm in simple, creative awards that celebrate the spirit of the event. Fun paper plate award ideas offer a perfect solution, blending low-cost materials with high-impact recognition.

paper plate awards
paper plate awards

Why Choose Paper Plate Awards?

paper plates with words written on them are arranged in the shape of a circle and have different colors
paper plates with words written on them are arranged in the shape of a circle and have different colors

The beauty of using paper plates for awards lies in their delightful contradiction. They are inherently casual and disposable, which removes the pressure of creating a "perfect" prize, yet this very quality allows for boundless creativity and humor. The circular shape is a natural canvas, suggesting a medal or a badge of honor. Because they are lightweight and inexpensive, you can create a whole collection of unique winners without breaking the budget. This approach is ideal for casual gatherings, family reunions, game nights, or any event where the goal is laughter and connection over high-stakes competition.

Design and Preparation Tips

Office/Work Paper Plate Awards
Office/Work Paper Plate Awards

Getting started is straightforward and part of the fun. Begin by selecting sturdy paper plates; the heavier the paper stock, the more substantial your award will feel. You’ll also need markers, stickers, glitter, colored paper, tape, and plenty of imagination. The key to great design is embracing a theme. Are you celebrating a cheesy movie night, a backyard barbecue, or a silly sports tournament? Your theme will guide your color schemes and the types of awards you create, ensuring a cohesive and polished look despite the humble medium.

Creative Award Categories to Consider

19+ Creative Paper Plate Award Ideas to Try
19+ Creative Paper Plate Award Ideas to Try

The categories you create will set the tone for the entire event. Move beyond simple "1st, 2nd, 3rd" and think about the specific personalities and moments of your gathering. The best categories are funny, specific, and universally relatable, ensuring that every guest feels seen and appreciated in some way. Here are a few engaging categories to spark your creativity.

The "Spirit of the Event" Awards

These awards focus on enthusiasm and participation rather than skill. They are guaranteed to get laughs and make guests feel energized.

a bunch of paper plates that have different designs on them, all in different shapes and sizes
a bunch of paper plates that have different designs on them, all in different shapes and sizes
  • The Overtures Award: For the guest who asked "Are we there yet?" with the most enthusiasm.
  • Most Spirited Sidekick: For the person who cheered the loudest for absolutely everyone.
  • The Connector: For the guest who successfully introduced two people who instantly became friends.

The "Unsung Hero" Awards

These recognize the essential, often invisible, contributions that make an event run smoothly.

Fun & Easy Team Awards Kids Will Love
Fun & Easy Team Awards Kids Will Love
  • The Human Name Tag: For the person who remembered everyone’s name on the first try.
  • Table Ambassador: For the guest who kept the conversation flowing at their table, preventing any awkward silences.
  • Master of Shenanigans: For the person who started the most fun game or activity, even if they were the last to join in.

Presentation and Ceremony Ideas

some paper plates that are on the ground
some paper plates that are on the ground
there are many paper plates that have been decorated with words and phrases on them, all in different colors
there are many paper plates that have been decorated with words and phrases on them, all in different colors
Paper Plate Award
Paper Plate Award
a person standing in front of a bunch of paper plates with different designs on them
a person standing in front of a bunch of paper plates with different designs on them
Paper Plate Awards - elementary
Paper Plate Awards - elementary
a bunch of paper plates that have pictures on them with the names of each person
a bunch of paper plates that have pictures on them with the names of each person
Celebrate Staffulty with Paper Plate Awards 🏆
Celebrate Staffulty with Paper Plate Awards 🏆
Paper Plate #1 Award Ribbon Craft
Paper Plate #1 Award Ribbon Craft
many plates with words painted on them sitting on a wooden table top, all in different colors
many plates with words painted on them sitting on a wooden table top, all in different colors
Paper Plate Awards
Paper Plate Awards
many different types of badges on a wooden surface with words written in them and the names of each team
many different types of badges on a wooden surface with words written in them and the names of each team
10 Heartfelt Father's Day Paper Plate Crafts
10 Heartfelt Father's Day Paper Plate Crafts
Softball team paper plate awards! 🥎
Softball team paper plate awards! 🥎
paper plate awards
paper plate awards
a table topped with lots of plates covered in different types of sticker designs on it
a table topped with lots of plates covered in different types of sticker designs on it
How to Make Paper Plate Awards - Crafty Little Gnome superlative awards most likely to
How to Make Paper Plate Awards - Crafty Little Gnome superlative awards most likely to
Volleyball paper plate awards
Volleyball paper plate awards
glax paper plate award
glax paper plate award
Volleyball paper plate awards
Volleyball paper plate awards

The delivery of the award is just as important as the object itself. A dramatic presentation turns a simple paper plate into a coveted trophy. Consider creating a makeshift podium using a stack of books or a decorated crate. Have a volunteer act as a witty emcee, building suspense with playful commentary before calling out the winner. You could even have a redirection "curtain" made from a bedsheet for a classic touch. The goal is to play up the silliness of the moment, encouraging the winner to embrace the spotlight with good humor.

Integrating Awards into Game Night

For game nights, these awards are a perfect, low-effort way to end the evening. Instead of focusing solely on the winner of the final game, create a point system that tracks various behaviors throughout the night. Award a point for every game won, but also for the most creative bluff, the best sportsmanship after a loss, or the most strategic alliance formed. At the end of the night, tally the points and present a series of paper plate medals. This method ensures that everyone leaves feeling like a winner, reinforcing the positive social dynamics of the evening.

Customization and Personalization

To make your awards feel truly special, a little personalization goes a long way. Before the event, write down the names of your guests and brainstorm potential awards based on what you know about them. Did someone bring an unexpectedly sophisticated appetizer to a casual potluck? They might win "Culinary Overachiever." Did someone tell a particularly memorable story? They could be "Our Featured Narrator." Writing the award title and a short, funny citation on the plate beforehand with a metallic marker feels bespoke and shows you put thought into the celebration.