{ "data": [ "v0.2", { "title": "Envision Bhutan 2035", "description": "T3C Pipeline Analysis Results", "date": "2025-08-22T14:19:32.030Z", "addOns": {}, "topics": [ { "id": "a0c49c6b-b9d0-4ada-bcf7-71f473365e7c", "title": "How can Bhutan leverage technology to build a thriving, inclusive, and sustainable society by 2035?", "description": "How can Bhutan leverage technology to build a thriving, inclusive, and sustainable society by 2035?", "subtopics": [ { "id": "9cd56910-29b7-49db-a214-bf6b61320ab4", "title": "AI and Blockchain Applications", "description": "AI and Blockchain Applications", "claims": [ { "id": "196d5020-b347-406c-b855-3b5beb765d9d", "title": "Adopting blockchain for identity management can enhance transparency and trust.", "quotes": [ { "id": "fb1b9249-f7d3-4e6a-b5d6-e61c88df922e", "text": "Blockchain in identity", "reference": { "id": "86bf060a-283b-4d47-a1a8-797cd88fe1c6", "sourceId": "e017370f-5375-4988-ba2c-087b1b0ee138", "interview": "87862e980a85b868b9611a281240df0e2d011b31d69d7f13251db6022a935076", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 22 } ] } } ], "number": 1, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "66b6f969-4844-48dd-9408-924c628d5152", "title": "Blockchain and data science technology should be leveraged to advance Bhutan's society.", "quotes": [ { "id": "7884d2a4-ca1d-4e40-9b97-78dadf20666a", "text": "Blockchain and data science technology", "reference": { "id": "144bdec5-d78b-4f83-9392-5705c8322e6f", "sourceId": "63b3a706-079f-4a9a-a6ac-b00d42d3ecc2", "interview": "e85c8c8cc9686a3b213d06fbb67250a65fc4317b019d19ae0448bac473213fe3", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 38 } ] } } ], "number": 2, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "2e69f13d-fe70-46c0-878f-f28f70906fe8", "title": "Integrating advanced technologies like blockchain at the core of government is a positive step for Bhutan's future.", "quotes": [ { "id": "dd6d181a-5b0d-4fff-a924-52d536a0973d", "text": "I see the Bhutan is very actively working and technology, like Blockchain and they are integrating it to the core of the system, even at the Government level. I think Bhutan has a great future.", "reference": { "id": "bcce5f86-d7c8-47c4-aa75-5660dd35d206", "sourceId": "0c2a1010-47d4-4239-8c03-34eff63efbcd", "interview": "c93f2ef5ea178642fdf85a002a7403718cf43412448c939cb1e36294e189fd85", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 193 } ] } } ], "number": 3, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "de2d1584-560e-4bd2-adce-32af8471ed61", "title": "Integrating AI and blockchain with the National Digital Identity (NDI) system will improve its effectiveness.", "quotes": [ { "id": "6f7fe26c-92c4-441b-b3e0-d47e0e6823cd", "text": "AI and Block chain integration in NDI", "reference": { "id": "cb5aed1d-3cc1-4d4b-a8ce-af52176da96c", "sourceId": "bd629629-4218-4907-874b-783e4e783074", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 38 } ] } } ], "number": 4, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "ecfceb29-0480-4488-b37a-4a107fb0d1b2", "title": "AI and robotics should be leveraged through automation.", "quotes": [ { "id": "2de0df1e-087a-45d5-aeb0-31d6ff69e055", "text": "AI automation for both digital and robotics.", "reference": { "id": "218391f2-f9ed-4ca5-96e3-7aa1ea426e13", "sourceId": "30725807-4a09-483d-ba57-84642a5349ad", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 44 } ] } } ], "number": 5, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "e83b7e97-7099-4234-8813-a61c2f4a2481", "title": "Digital signatures and remote banking will reduce the need for physical travel and streamline access to financial services.", "quotes": [ { "id": "5c372020-915f-497a-9c85-2b12dfc7ce16", "text": "there are other things like digital signature and things like that whereby people don't have to go to the banks to process for their loans and do a physical signature of the documents", "reference": { "id": "fa3fdba4-3c83-4876-ab49-b2adcb3b5466", "sourceId": "beb7bcfc-149c-45be-92e9-f05d2eeb458a", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 183 } ] } } ], "number": 6, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "07f2f5b5-c512-41e8-826e-e378963725af", "title": "Bhutan should use Ethereum to build tamperproof, verifiable applications that are always available.", "quotes": [ { "id": "dac56a77-59fc-4d7d-a4df-7bf39a454482", "text": "i want to see them using ethereum for always on tamperproof, verifiable apps", "reference": { "id": "7420901e-d932-419e-9daf-da614d9a5d15", "sourceId": "d6792faf-7cc4-4ba0-92fa-388d535d9312", "interview": "f4dfa0191407beba5ecb691b819262098732659b63d628e6b3903a98d9c18917", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 76 } ] } } ], "number": 7, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "7bf37d5e-bccb-4511-9489-fe0e001b87cd", "title": "AI and blockchain can help remove middlemen from supply chains.", "quotes": [ { "id": "6bb79c47-d351-4034-9d1b-a18f32b4229b", "text": "removing middle men", "reference": { "id": "e20a1aff-939f-4b1b-b58b-87dfaec59e66", "sourceId": "08f2ad31-88d5-41a9-b6b9-a94bfba459b1", "interview": "f4dfa0191407beba5ecb691b819262098732659b63d628e6b3903a98d9c18917", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 19 } ] } } ], "number": 8, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "4dececdb-e7de-476b-b03a-8005fa851e76", "title": "Blockchain-verified supply chains will improve product quality.", "quotes": [ { "id": "e53bc118-ca9b-490a-a14f-8ac3d42222bb", "text": "getting better products through verified supply chains", "reference": { "id": "7125b76b-2fdd-456a-9a6a-10bb780b9d73", "sourceId": "08f2ad31-88d5-41a9-b6b9-a94bfba459b1", "interview": "f4dfa0191407beba5ecb691b819262098732659b63d628e6b3903a98d9c18917", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 54 } ] } } ], "number": 9, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "eb6cced1-8fa3-4b71-b65d-8a84921681ce", "title": "Image recognition should be integrated to enhance Bhutan's technological development.", "quotes": [ { "id": "cdba7cf7-0c79-40ca-8704-3a136d3b2b8a", "text": "I recommend integrating image recognition", "reference": { "id": "2a43298c-ab8c-4ede-adf5-f75404da0057", "sourceId": "c1610c0e-59a2-4169-a334-5fcda4ba343f", "interview": "6e070ed885ccc7f2538bcfed69c4434498d0a0fe9fc96bcc26c66e5c3e4a7a81", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 41 } ] } } ], "number": 10, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "f13ce782-da21-408f-ad37-7c53ab69e02f", "title": "AI can increase the capacity to review governance proposals and funding applications.", "quotes": [ { "id": "8926ef1d-298b-43f5-b3d3-09bb0d6cdefe", "text": "AI can be used [...] to increase the bandwidth in reviewing governance proposals and applications for funding requests.", "reference": { "id": "bf9c2664-6184-431c-97c4-52c2af54a9c6", "sourceId": "4c25b689-e863-4a7a-92c6-8f9da2fa98b0", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 119 } ] } } ], "number": 11, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "5517c576-f229-46f2-9efa-1ce18eab08d1", "title": "AI should be used to process large amounts of data and enable more proposals and initiatives to be approved and funded.", "quotes": [ { "id": "882d8005-90a8-46c1-8beb-bc08042df2dc", "text": "Ai for making sense of large amounts of data and increasing the bandwidth for how many proposals and initiatives can be approved and funded.", "reference": { "id": "19d9508e-0292-41a7-9174-a23afb1d0f75", "sourceId": "955f3942-80fa-4be7-963b-44ac10fe50ff", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 140 } ] } } ], "number": 12, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "b27e1e8c-d4c3-4ebb-b1c4-379cbc5861c8", "title": "AI-driven tools can help reviewers make more informed and faster decisions on citizen proposals.", "quotes": [ { "id": "783d8276-029f-44ad-af45-b74054ca7821", "text": "aid reviewers of them to help them make more informed and better decisions at a faster rate.", "reference": { "id": "d5cd5525-1486-4b81-9a17-415fd74432c0", "sourceId": "638fff61-4531-4013-8cf7-40049414eec7", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 92 } ] } } ], "number": 13, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "c8d2fd53-ccdb-4dcb-ad3a-5e7ccc0a683d", "title": "Technology should be used to provide seamless and secure services for citizens.", "quotes": [ { "id": "8e68d219-4be5-4e3c-9dbc-1d231500460d", "text": "Seamless, Secure Services", "reference": { "id": "26803799-9878-4069-9bf1-6cf890b2e3a0", "sourceId": "5d543716-45c1-4a94-837b-d7c2c3743746", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 25 } ] } } ], "number": 14, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "9c4dba3b-c2d5-4905-ab10-273c15f6dab1", "title": "Technology can support citizens and reviewers by providing suggestions to strengthen proposals.", "quotes": [ { "id": "e8d1c8d9-a1a8-4242-a882-a91e5701ab6e", "text": "providing suggestions for what would make proposal stronger. Both for the citizens who write the proposals but also to aid reviewers[...]", "reference": { "id": "6eee0aa6-3a66-4181-9a05-1738d41cac12", "sourceId": "638fff61-4531-4013-8cf7-40049414eec7", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 137 } ] } } ], "number": 15, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "f79526bc-0dea-42e2-ba76-001d14e383b5", "title": "Blockchain can ensure transparency and accountability in Bhutan\u2019s development aid and government budgets.", "quotes": [ { "id": "015dac48-5473-4efb-84ee-7fef433086f8", "text": "Blockchain could track development aid or local government budgets, ensuring accountability and trust in every ngultrum spent.", "reference": { "id": "96417eda-fdd6-42a4-945e-2a5d7f41db42", "sourceId": "84fe8168-4647-42df-8f54-4d7ae4e2455f", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 126 } ] } } ], "number": 16, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "b422d171-3d27-44fb-b169-5109da04fa43", "title": "Digital Identity and Inclusion", "description": "Digital Identity and Inclusion", "claims": [ { "id": "97ee3034-4102-4b0f-8229-8b3f4308f170", "title": "Blockchain should be used to strengthen digital identity systems in Bhutan.", "quotes": [ { "id": "6a50a2ad-127e-48b8-aedb-713c87746a16", "text": "Blockchain in identity", "reference": { "id": "d9dd0de4-0027-458c-a210-9f663ba336b2", "sourceId": "e017370f-5375-4988-ba2c-087b1b0ee138", "interview": "87862e980a85b868b9611a281240df0e2d011b31d69d7f13251db6022a935076", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 22 } ] } } ], "number": 17, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "0cd1463f-b5a8-4f5d-bd85-5362a214a6d0", "title": "Allowing citizens to hold their data on their own device through NDI is an important first step for Bhutan's digital transformation.", "quotes": [ { "id": "4977d0b9-7e08-47ce-a70d-087191a5a6b8", "text": "put on NDI whereby we allow citizens to hold their data on their own device. And this is, we feel like it's one of the first steps towards digitalization and digital transformation.", "reference": { "id": "8c329abd-04b7-422d-a03d-8a8fac991cb0", "sourceId": "153e1c87-a71a-45fe-9d60-dfc994d39a06", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 181 } ] } } ], "number": 18, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "02f83187-0cfb-4033-b96e-d988e8c04719", "title": "NDI aims to increase digital inclusion by allowing citizens to access online services from home, especially given Bhutan's challenging mountainous terrain.", "quotes": [ { "id": "f3b5e7dc-5759-49f8-839f-8eb25206dad0", "text": "it's very important to create a very inclusive society in a digital manner. So one of the aims is to allow people to access online services from the comfort of their home because sometimes even in the summer or in the winter the roads get blocked and people can't commute to physical offices", "reference": { "id": "d5a45c07-5793-4da9-9cb6-dc0f5968ea89", "sourceId": "beb7bcfc-149c-45be-92e9-f05d2eeb458a", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 291 } ] } } ], "number": 19, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "f3a238fd-b995-4aaa-a65f-88944c7d39b0", "title": "NDI\u2019s offline capabilities could provide remote citizens with equal access to public services.", "quotes": [ { "id": "de770b38-a96a-4e20-b76d-87d032397c6a", "text": "Citizens in remote highlands or forest villages could access the same public services as those in urban centers, thanks to mobile connectivity and NDI\u2019s offline capabilities.", "reference": { "id": "5985d0fe-e715-4b31-9caa-19bcd74f958d", "sourceId": "ad9776d7-2d2c-4bb6-9402-189d697f5de6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 174 } ] } } ], "number": 20, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "c36f52c6-4c90-4897-b134-b13227103876", "title": "The National Digital Identity (NDI) can enable citizens in remote areas to access the same public services as those in urban centers.", "quotes": [ { "id": "30596184-11d6-46eb-b3c3-d46bc480facb", "text": "Citizens in remote highlands or forest villages could access the same public services as those in urban centers, thanks to mobile connectivity and NDI\u2019s offline capabilities.", "reference": { "id": "50e71074-a99c-48e5-8371-238528a80ca6", "sourceId": "cdad00d6-4d3d-4676-8b68-b730b3bd894d", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 174 } ] } } ], "number": 21, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "1c55c9d4-1623-4833-a2c0-cfdbe3cdb7e2", "title": "NDI will make people's lives a lot easier by linking multiple services together.", "quotes": [ { "id": "a30c1dfa-a351-47af-a463-5f8886d4851d", "text": "as many services are cross linked via NDI... it's gonna make people's lives a lot easier.", "reference": { "id": "428dcd27-f704-4cfe-92bf-b3e45fc79a28", "sourceId": "c18ca6fd-3243-492a-89b1-70b0f84738f1", "interview": "c93f2ef5ea178642fdf85a002a7403718cf43412448c939cb1e36294e189fd85", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 89 } ] } } ], "number": 22, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "f665bd3e-3f43-4bf8-b2d0-5ee049d0d6d4", "title": "AI-assisted NDI could make digital services fully accessible to persons with disabilities.", "quotes": [ { "id": "df1a7caf-2472-4b5e-993a-9f7992b45fcc", "text": "AI-assisted NDI platforms could include voice commands, text-to-speech, and visual recognition\u2014making every digital service accessible, from applying for jobs to teleconsultations with doctors.", "reference": { "id": "3bea2b81-a9d0-44a2-8656-0901139dbf8c", "sourceId": "ad9776d7-2d2c-4bb6-9402-189d697f5de6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 193 } ] } } ], "number": 23, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "743759b7-1e49-4020-b2a3-d52651ea4050", "title": "AI-assisted NDI platforms should be built with accessibility features like voice commands and text-to-speech to empower persons with disabilities.", "quotes": [ { "id": "1a7e9629-f75c-43f0-bfe3-c150a39a7271", "text": "AI-assisted NDI platforms could include voice commands, text-to-speech, and visual recognition\u2014making every digital service accessible, from applying for jobs to teleconsultations with doctors.", "reference": { "id": "62ee8426-a80d-4b4e-857c-7af6291ca1fd", "sourceId": "cdad00d6-4d3d-4676-8b68-b730b3bd894d", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 193 } ] } } ], "number": 24, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "b282f58f-8f96-4a4a-b4d7-5060032bb081", "title": "NDI could ensure women without formal documentation gain secure, independent access to vital services.", "quotes": [ { "id": "0ad3c332-90d4-4f60-baf1-08576da7a73b", "text": "NDI could ensure that women\u2014especially those without formal documentation\u2014have secure and independent access to health services, property rights, welfare schemes, and digital payments, all with full consent and control.", "reference": { "id": "2863f1a8-bf51-4d4f-aceb-24ed1d0910e8", "sourceId": "ad9776d7-2d2c-4bb6-9402-189d697f5de6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 219 } ] } } ], "number": 25, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "4e9cc125-d13a-423e-a019-767d08fccf86", "title": "NDI can ensure women, especially those without formal documentation, have secure and independent access to health, property, and welfare services.", "quotes": [ { "id": "ca6448c0-18ac-422a-8c4a-5a5c423f2687", "text": "NDI could ensure that women\u2014especially those without formal documentation\u2014have secure and independent access to health services, property rights, welfare schemes, and digital payments, all with full consent and control.", "reference": { "id": "e07db845-3329-4cfa-9f1d-a91e2c10b004", "sourceId": "cdad00d6-4d3d-4676-8b68-b730b3bd894d", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 219 } ] } } ], "number": 26, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "c413006b-48af-41bc-8bb3-cd10599eda9d", "title": "Digital birth registration would guarantee every child a secure identity and equal access to essential services.", "quotes": [ { "id": "41739546-e0e2-4ef4-af0e-f0572f2eaed7", "text": "With digital birth registration, every child could start life with a secure identity\u2014ensuring access to immunizations, schooling, and protection under the law.", "reference": { "id": "b1ffa899-9ad0-4496-8f0a-30a3b378d617", "sourceId": "ad9776d7-2d2c-4bb6-9402-189d697f5de6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 159 } ] } } ], "number": 27, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "77bb5377-11c4-4543-ab8e-98e9bb01f14b", "title": "Digital birth registration through NDI can prevent any child from being left uncounted or unseen, guaranteeing access to essential services from birth.", "quotes": [ { "id": "e3b3a026-aad2-4a9b-b15f-e6eb64a529e0", "text": "With digital birth registration, every child could start life with a secure identity\u2014ensuring access to immunizations, schooling, and protection under the law. No child would be left uncounted or unseen.", "reference": { "id": "eb9d7d63-6935-4b93-92dd-389d27cfa89f", "sourceId": "cdad00d6-4d3d-4676-8b68-b730b3bd894d", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 203 } ] } } ], "number": 28, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "89a2114d-40fe-47b5-8c87-7cc786c46ac0", "title": "Integrating AI and blockchain with NDI will enable seamless and secure access to essential government services, eliminating paperwork and queues.", "quotes": [ { "id": "11a72cb0-0e15-421c-97e5-6acfa0d1c57e", "text": "No more standing in queues or submitting piles of paperwork. From renewing passports to accessing healthcare, all services could be securely accessed through biometric or digital ID verification, thanks to blockchain-backed identity authentication.", "reference": { "id": "8cff886b-c6b5-4336-92d1-0fa333eff4df", "sourceId": "133e7e82-1f87-4218-a776-d9ebf8a02af6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 248 } ] } } ], "number": 29, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "3bf81b3e-fbe0-48cf-89a4-936c41ddd485", "title": "A decentralized digital identity system can simplify and secure credentials for Bhutanese students, even if they move regions or countries.", "quotes": [ { "id": "7a27f684-54f2-497f-9954-9160b10e557a", "text": "A decentralized digital identity system could allow students to hold their own verified certificates, accessible even if they move valleys or countries.", "reference": { "id": "8924193f-266b-4e8a-80c4-7cf11f49cdc7", "sourceId": "84fe8168-4647-42df-8f54-4d7ae4e2455f", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 152 } ] } } ], "number": 30, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "6a8b1e48-9e50-4f3f-99c8-10e67b11b8f7", "title": "Sustainable Technologies", "description": "Sustainable Technologies", "claims": [ { "id": "4d52c98f-adb0-4f87-be06-b27685a89d1e", "title": "Bhutan should pursue digital development in a way that is mindful of eco-friendly practices.", "quotes": [ { "id": "aa7b4e62-cc21-4408-b811-ffdbdf481f8c", "text": "Yes it should be digitally developed but should be mindful and eco friendly", "reference": { "id": "3e33d9a4-daa1-4be6-af30-45fb46f251fa", "sourceId": "309410c7-0798-46cc-9971-a760beef1962", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 75 } ] } } ], "number": 31, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "f8487803-9a19-44bb-8e41-9d61722b7487", "title": "Bhutan should use eco-friendly machines to avoid damaging the ecosystem.", "quotes": [ { "id": "1f0b0f71-e028-45d9-af24-4c2e92774dc1", "text": "Eco friendly machines which does the work effectively would be nice as it wont be damaging the ecosystem", "reference": { "id": "36f40199-270f-44fe-aa38-7990ab249ff9", "sourceId": "783460d3-0635-4020-91e4-99b7e2993190", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 104 } ] } } ], "number": 32, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "21bae358-a7c5-4fcd-974e-645a68dc3b02", "title": "Solar energy should play a major role in Bhutan\u2019s sustainable development.", "quotes": [ { "id": "4cd33b08-e71c-4385-8682-66db9b337e2a", "text": "Solar energy, farming, principles of Cosmo localism.", "reference": { "id": "0912b176-2de1-4094-9a16-eed1e0c6184f", "sourceId": "30725807-4a09-483d-ba57-84642a5349ad", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 52 } ] } } ], "number": 33, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "838e8025-f316-4648-84db-433466c0658a", "title": "AI can be used to make agriculture more efficient and optimize for clean, nutritious foods.", "quotes": [ { "id": "534f497a-f2f5-451d-8211-57b57643f79d", "text": "AI can be used for agriculture to make it more efficient and optimize for clean foods with high nutrition", "reference": { "id": "b37a55d4-a106-4f37-8569-a72cf61b3be9", "sourceId": "1d898d31-a00e-4bb5-be36-847548110ebd", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 105 } ] } } ], "number": 34, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "60c79001-5d3f-4db7-afbb-4274922db7fc", "title": "Bhutan should adopt technologies that improve farming methods and increase production to meet local demand for quality products.", "quotes": [ { "id": "3f5b420f-9160-4a3c-932c-2248d9083e17", "text": "Technologies that can improve the current farming methods in bhutan and also high level production technologies that can meet the demands of the people such as quality products", "reference": { "id": "2f8d7167-39b8-495c-bb92-46091e1a99e6", "sourceId": "5cefa840-845b-466e-8f6b-777164375845", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 176 } ] } } ], "number": 35, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "feb428e8-274d-481c-9733-fb7271c21908", "title": "Using sensors and solar energy can provide energy for local communities and farming.", "quotes": [ { "id": "1c485fa4-4f13-4476-82df-e9b35bf3ffdd", "text": "using sensors and solar energy to provide energy for the local communities, farming", "reference": { "id": "d1f39885-3b94-473a-a542-dd32f2857043", "sourceId": "1d898d31-a00e-4bb5-be36-847548110ebd", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 83 } ] } } ], "number": 36, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "1e25f396-ddcb-4053-bb4a-ec0f7f05ade0", "title": "Advanced technologies can help villages to be self-sovereign and thriving.", "quotes": [ { "id": "df6f68b9-d497-4278-ba2f-e7fe553f4278", "text": "make everything more like thriving villages that are self-sovereign and with high technologies", "reference": { "id": "57d197c9-db0c-432c-adf0-f972669a85a6", "sourceId": "1d898d31-a00e-4bb5-be36-847548110ebd", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 94 } ] } } ], "number": 37, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "ecd70b47-2480-4b68-bd40-31d115fdf45e", "title": "Sustainable technologies can provide benefits despite Bhutan's connectivity and terrain challenges.", "quotes": [ { "id": "dedd55a8-9572-4ab0-aca5-4e0931874b09", "text": "how can sustainable tech benefit", "reference": { "id": "f9c60714-2901-48a0-b341-00d9af72b8a8", "sourceId": "c5cca4f5-b6e3-4764-b20a-b2428d76eb73", "interview": "1408f1efef49536bf9548e3ae4884f6b7840039271662d8ff0ca8aa6da23a042", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 33 } ] } } ], "number": 38, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "4c17996e-0801-406c-9f55-2fb1b05b09f8", "title": "Bhutan should use technology to reduce reliance on imports and achieve greater self-sufficiency.", "quotes": [ { "id": "6a13ed2b-5040-4935-9be5-5ff86bf3d72c", "text": "Instead of relying on other countries for basic necessities and goods which lead to more of imports, technologies that could tackle this dilemma would be wonderful", "reference": { "id": "d113c0ef-fe3c-44b6-941d-bcda70603f47", "sourceId": "4025ea22-cf3f-4b00-b5d0-ddfb91f7fd74", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 163 } ] } } ], "number": 39, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "c1d0c3d7-c919-4f8b-97b8-591ed8cb0cfb", "title": "Challenges and Barriers", "description": "Challenges and Barriers", "claims": [ { "id": "168a0b4c-faff-4ac6-bba7-2e4c5cd99f39", "title": "Facial recognition features in apps may not work reliably for all users.", "quotes": [ { "id": "eef9aadd-0f10-4239-b156-02e528576c86", "text": "The app can't recognise my face", "reference": { "id": "df02bac0-5af7-4f20-95ad-3bec811bc2de", "sourceId": "5dcc573f-a76f-4fb3-8330-ddb1ba92820e", "interview": "6e070ed885ccc7f2538bcfed69c4434498d0a0fe9fc96bcc26c66e5c3e4a7a81", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 31 } ] } } ], "number": 40, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "420256e0-431d-4fdf-8fb1-1679def555ae", "title": "Some users face difficulties when trying to access their Bhutan NDI accounts.", "quotes": [ { "id": "fcfffa3c-bbf0-47a9-a291-2d85e64cfcf9", "text": "I am stuck with opening my bhutan ndi", "reference": { "id": "eef32e0e-82cc-47af-88d5-28c3cf0d753d", "sourceId": "bb87a1b6-c0cc-4eb6-9f8e-02cf4c25f576", "interview": "6e070ed885ccc7f2538bcfed69c4434498d0a0fe9fc96bcc26c66e5c3e4a7a81", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 37 } ] } } ], "number": 41, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "9b85b385-ef9e-41f1-9971-21a41438c0a5", "title": "Technology should be kept low cost so people can afford and experiment with it.", "quotes": [ { "id": "a611a4ab-b919-4545-b819-f7c2cdb80f18", "text": "keep technology low cost such that people can afford and play around with it", "reference": { "id": "d724de7f-abde-4469-a154-154c270d79bb", "sourceId": "ec1bec6f-45bd-4900-98a5-3e5571dcfe67", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 76 } ] } } ], "number": 42, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "62d5754f-6849-45f8-9270-0917532d423b", "title": "Technology adoption is in its early stages in Bhutan.", "quotes": [ { "id": "b5287ccf-1ea0-452f-a3bb-5abfc639c110", "text": "technology is still new but happening here", "reference": { "id": "44f97ab3-6d83-43e7-9471-4f403a36410c", "sourceId": "2d227f6c-9f16-4a2e-94fc-ae05de264498", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 42 } ] } } ], "number": 43, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "92dcd944-5eac-4dd6-8f15-9e67b7f3ef80", "title": "A multilingual NDI application is necessary to ensure equitable access for non-English speakers in Bhutan.", "quotes": [ { "id": "5828c00b-5542-49b6-a3a3-f7f3695a2ace", "text": "we are developing a multilingual application for NDI. So this is one of our features coming up soon", "reference": { "id": "a69866d1-b674-437b-82ff-2b1603caba4e", "sourceId": "beb7bcfc-149c-45be-92e9-f05d2eeb458a", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 99 } ] } } ], "number": 44, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "40f23c60-f779-4056-8a37-378270eaf4f3", "title": "Technology should support Dzongkha to include groups like monks who do not speak English.", "quotes": [ { "id": "f3b05ced-0a28-49eb-9339-345f42f47f34", "text": "they only know Dzongkhag language", "reference": { "id": "02ff7b07-1d9d-484f-8a4d-f58a7725f162", "sourceId": "c7994a96-e711-433b-8873-6237dbeeac89", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 33 } ] } } ], "number": 45, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "819251c3-9507-4ef9-99fc-3ae0db445f0e", "title": "AI integration with NDI will support smart emergency response, enabling authorities to identify and prioritize vulnerable individuals during disasters.", "quotes": [ { "id": "9d17bb8d-476b-4b1a-a302-184630dd6b3f", "text": "AI could use data from NDI to instantly identify and locate vulnerable individuals (elderly, disabled, children) to prioritize rescue or relief efforts.", "reference": { "id": "c7f27b84-0e7a-4573-a7ba-39962d060702", "sourceId": "133e7e82-1f87-4218-a776-d9ebf8a02af6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 152 } ] } } ], "number": 46, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "fb897bd2-c8c7-45b3-8c94-d2d3921b6bd8", "title": "Raising awareness about the advantages of new technologies is necessary for uneducated farmers in Bhutan to accept and adopt them.", "quotes": [ { "id": "2b5f7ecb-6cdd-41b8-bedd-fe9da8db281c", "text": "\"it is important to make them understand the advantages it provides and encourage them to adapt to such methods\"", "reference": { "id": "651dd8d7-474b-41cb-94fc-0a1648dc2434", "sourceId": "eb313d70-ab7b-4929-8bba-1ddd9bdb1c99", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 112 } ] } } ], "number": 47, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "a75af4fe-6339-4df1-9585-440ef110e0ad", "title": "Economic Empowerment", "description": "Economic Empowerment", "claims": [ { "id": "ad2c67ec-41d0-4855-b060-a8016a43cd97", "title": "Bhutan should aim for a tenfold growth in its digital economy by 2035.", "quotes": [ { "id": "f19a8aa2-73c5-404b-8578-7101d870ef8a", "text": "10 fold growth in digital economy", "reference": { "id": "d209d973-4f40-4d4a-8d19-faefeb21c8c6", "sourceId": "e705aa01-ac7c-46d2-a611-72fecf55e88e", "interview": "1408f1efef49536bf9548e3ae4884f6b7840039271662d8ff0ca8aa6da23a042", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 33 } ] } } ], "number": 48, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "54e7ad89-fdde-49e8-96bd-0a2f03d65605", "title": "Bhutan should support the further development of Gelephu Mindfull City.", "quotes": [ { "id": "1c591359-9389-4e15-b4ed-6a25aafc671f", "text": "Our country wants Gelephu Mindfull City flourish higher", "reference": { "id": "c3db9947-2cfe-4f65-9435-f167c8ae59e5", "sourceId": "731252f2-e4e1-4c27-84dc-8830e97dd38c", "interview": "e85c8c8cc9686a3b213d06fbb67250a65fc4317b019d19ae0448bac473213fe3", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 55 } ] } } ], "number": 49, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "2dd828fa-d562-41d1-a748-bef38befa0f3", "title": "Bhutan should foster a culture that values both innovation and local empowerment.", "quotes": [ { "id": "c1928b6a-5eaf-4a08-bde7-5808070d9098", "text": "it's really important to have a place that cherishes innovation but also make sure that the grassroots economies are educated", "reference": { "id": "f8f03936-fbd1-402d-bd66-e497ff5a3267", "sourceId": "c8697b7a-6078-470f-8fa3-264a0f83bbb0", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 125 } ] } } ], "number": 50, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "4fc7c8df-55dc-4a1c-9e00-a57dfa45ab08", "title": "AI-powered NDI services will help reduce inequality by matching individuals with tailored jobs, training, and social programs.", "quotes": [ { "id": "3658a7ee-bb52-4aa4-8237-202d8059828b", "text": "AI could analyze real-time socio-economic data (with consent) to recommend jobs, training, or social programs tailored to an individual\u2019s skills and situation, helping reduce inequality.", "reference": { "id": "efaa45a4-ce9d-4e74-91b7-d6dd95028892", "sourceId": "133e7e82-1f87-4218-a776-d9ebf8a02af6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 186 } ] } } ], "number": 51, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "51f4c915-67d4-4526-a1d8-8b576857bc96", "title": "Digital hubs powered by solar and fiber can enable rural youth in Bhutan to work remotely for global companies.", "quotes": [ { "id": "03169ec4-ac52-4367-b018-98398adb9266", "text": "Bhutan could set up rural innovation centers powered by solar + fiber \u2014 where youth can work in global tech, design, and writing jobs.", "reference": { "id": "73508bf0-e82c-4695-99a8-a85e28ca6977", "sourceId": "84fe8168-4647-42df-8f54-4d7ae4e2455f", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 134 } ] } } ], "number": 52, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "5e9a34ac-6812-42ed-8849-7473ef334204", "title": "Bhutanese artisans should use digital tokens or NFTs linked to their creations to receive ongoing global support and royalties.", "quotes": [ { "id": "ded0cb71-8ebd-498f-8dd3-027ff0ec6bb8", "text": "Imagine weavers, painters, or woodworkers issuing digital tokens or NFTs tied to their art \u2014 enabling global patrons to support local culture directly, with royalties flowing forever.", "reference": { "id": "6bcd4ab1-0fa2-4b9a-9b52-21bcb2ddaf29", "sourceId": "84fe8168-4647-42df-8f54-4d7ae4e2455f", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 183 } ] } } ], "number": 53, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "081c9d15-a475-49ee-8407-a5321e40f81e", "title": "Bhutan should raise the overall wage for all citizens.", "quotes": [ { "id": "3e4414e4-cdaa-4439-8fc9-992dfb28b878", "text": "Raise the overall wage for all citizens", "reference": { "id": "19e1bb76-0cf2-426f-bfbc-2f012f24c1e2", "sourceId": "f5d181d9-746c-486f-9c0d-a0f8774f4209", "interview": "1c457df71fd56e4694e06170399e9e6981366b57f236b71a2df01ad2ff75eff9", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 39 } ] } } ], "number": 54, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "e9897ec8-d88e-46c8-8569-4ecfeaf64bcb", "title": "Education & Capacity Building", "description": "Education & Capacity Building", "claims": [ { "id": "0771836a-395a-47b9-af6b-4dad10546501", "title": "Bhutan's current focus on AI, technology-related businesses, and education will result in an abundance of highly qualified IT professionals in the future.", "quotes": [ { "id": "9fcbfbe0-04d6-4e78-bd22-947908b3aa2c", "text": "so for from 30 years from now I guess like Bhutan will be over flooded with technical and well profound IT professionals.", "reference": { "id": "348b0e88-a0f3-42c2-9af7-b220f264fea5", "sourceId": "88e0b24f-3ea9-4f8d-a3c3-4780ea92464f", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 121 } ] } } ], "number": 55, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "b5d45267-06bb-40f1-9c02-1551e5e1809b", "title": "Capacity building in technology should focus on local communities and grassroots economies.", "quotes": [ { "id": "c1d3e664-ce9a-4180-98e5-6ae701726e5a", "text": "make sure that the grassroots economies are educated when it comes to technology and capacity building is local.", "reference": { "id": "0d142af3-9350-427e-ace5-fbdcd9ee9078", "sourceId": "c8697b7a-6078-470f-8fa3-264a0f83bbb0", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 112 } ] } } ], "number": 56, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "f3feb616-313c-4e46-b3b9-b7ca245f1d68", "title": "Digital literacy and cybersecurity awareness campaigns are needed to empower Bhutanese citizens and reduce fraud.", "quotes": [ { "id": "9ae85683-3197-4fa0-9e5c-4d9aba0c2d12", "text": "So our aim is to give awareness about digital literacy, cybersecurity, protecting themselves from scams, fraud. We have so many banking frauds, like OTP frauds. So we want to empower the society with awareness campaigns", "reference": { "id": "0926909f-76b1-491d-be1a-4e44fd358488", "sourceId": "beb7bcfc-149c-45be-92e9-f05d2eeb458a", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 219 } ] } } ], "number": 57, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "e5315fff-83d1-4466-acb0-696f45259f7d", "title": "AI-powered analysis via NDI will provide personalized healthcare, with particular benefits for the elderly and rural populations.", "quotes": [ { "id": "19f3977b-2781-4644-ac75-6171413034ad", "text": "AI-powered analysis of medical records (securely stored and accessed via NDI) could allow for real-time diagnostics and personalized treatment plans, especially for the elderly and those in rural areas.", "reference": { "id": "8e0490e8-7e47-48a5-943e-42b43ea98002", "sourceId": "133e7e82-1f87-4218-a776-d9ebf8a02af6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 202 } ] } } ], "number": 58, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "c09e42f7-4659-4311-b418-b66d2169baf7", "title": "Blockchain-based digital credentials will facilitate transparent and instant academic and employment verification for students.", "quotes": [ { "id": "1ca92f49-dce4-43d3-9971-89a8d10296aa", "text": "Students could have verified digital credentials and transcripts stored on the blockchain, making applications for universities or jobs instant and transparent\u2014no more worrying about lost certificates!", "reference": { "id": "8e97d7b4-a10e-4566-9f50-64b26de9b255", "sourceId": "133e7e82-1f87-4218-a776-d9ebf8a02af6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 201 } ] } } ], "number": 59, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "1fd72094-612e-437d-a2ab-36873c310ef4", "title": "Bhutan should prioritize innovation as part of its national development.", "quotes": [ { "id": "14a2aeac-de33-4e23-822b-7eded474ae7e", "text": "Innovative [...] country", "reference": { "id": "d0d1369d-8114-4b53-9094-e6761200deaa", "sourceId": "5cb7723a-e023-4826-8f97-ec78a7a567b0", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 24 } ] } } ], "number": 60, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "baad21e2-fc07-4403-adc3-88ebaef32e16", "title": "Preserving Culture & Language", "description": "Preserving Culture & Language", "claims": [ { "id": "d8062fab-4367-436b-9162-81b241cad9eb", "title": "Technology initiatives should prioritize support for the Dzongkha language.", "quotes": [ { "id": "5c353c3b-1ca3-49a6-b926-90922ac56cef", "text": "How about our national language Dzongkha", "reference": { "id": "bfd81148-924e-4692-a35e-6f9f57f2cb7a", "sourceId": "008c3384-9efc-4aef-859a-0038b3cbd582", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 40 } ] } } ], "number": 61, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ], "topicColor": "brown" }, { "id": "13c1b311-12e5-4854-b39b-ace6a6a9b454", "title": "How can Bhutan\u2019s education system evolve to prepare youth for a digital and knowledge-driven future?", "description": "How can Bhutan\u2019s education system evolve to prepare youth for a digital and knowledge-driven future?", "subtopics": [ { "id": "87d0a6dc-0548-4340-b25e-c224b8da10e2", "title": "Curriculum and Pedagogy", "description": "Curriculum and Pedagogy", "claims": [ { "id": "8fdcdcec-5959-4725-9f0e-6875f147579d", "title": "Bhutan's education system is performing well.", "quotes": [ { "id": "860af940-4088-483d-9f28-e264ac04c3f3", "text": "I think our education is good", "reference": { "id": "fa8cbd4d-f900-49aa-8e28-87b64d05bf10", "sourceId": "2d227f6c-9f16-4a2e-94fc-ae05de264498", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 29 } ] } } ], "number": 62, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "7de364f5-3753-4293-b2c7-e317075c486a", "title": "Computer science is one of the most valuable subjects for Bhutan's education system.", "quotes": [ { "id": "9333cd10-aa25-4210-a693-a0b6832cb28e", "text": "Definitely computer science is one of the most valuable subjects that we can think of.", "reference": { "id": "5e073265-bdc9-4b14-b7d0-030ca697123f", "sourceId": "a18e1dc3-2fee-4462-be34-bce9949e244c", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 86 } ] } } ], "number": 63, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "bf6d5e92-27ef-4214-a17e-78c60486d87c", "title": "Schools in Bhutan should be decentralized and receive funding from diverse sources.", "quotes": [ { "id": "2cc824b7-cdf7-4991-b9b7-e48fe35d8e5f", "text": "The schools should be decentralized, there should be funding coming from different sources", "reference": { "id": "8d58cb52-34bd-45b1-a4ea-65fcad966911", "sourceId": "a18e1dc3-2fee-4462-be34-bce9949e244c", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 90 } ] } } ], "number": 64, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "755ec912-e91f-43d8-bb06-d8c4641024e9", "title": "Critical thinking should be a central focus in Bhutanese education.", "quotes": [ { "id": "82410e74-745f-4233-931c-0c8d2ee31d07", "text": "it's really critical to emphasize critical thinking as well.", "reference": { "id": "457889f2-eb17-4c40-b391-df55a741cc2b", "sourceId": "a18e1dc3-2fee-4462-be34-bce9949e244c", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 60 } ] } } ], "number": 65, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "0cdc5d6d-946b-4896-a0fe-2d9c6a0a7931", "title": "Solving educational administrative barriers is beneficial.", "quotes": [ { "id": "801d63c3-8b69-4852-886c-5b6ca07c8ab3", "text": "solving educational administrative barriers is good", "reference": { "id": "6d4d9ea2-1d69-47d0-a0ee-95327afad47d", "sourceId": "206f778c-cf83-4c97-8fe3-f1ac63f7c3fc", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 51 } ] } } ], "number": 66, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "43cde9e8-9bb4-4a38-a55c-4d1dba6fd0ce", "title": "Schools should integrate AI understanding and usage into the curriculum for students.", "quotes": [ { "id": "03405d03-f20f-4a57-b3e8-3839059c507a", "text": "school kids really need to be integrated in the curriculum course to understand well", "reference": { "id": "4b710e1f-fa9c-4c71-ad03-2f983b6bee1c", "sourceId": "0a3c716c-aac7-451c-8222-605449298276", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 84 } ] } } ], "number": 67, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "4c19613d-4268-4d92-bf76-99d88af51a9a", "title": "Hands-on activities like robotics competitions and learning groups foster engagement with technology.", "quotes": [ { "id": "2418e798-3c3f-4879-89a5-18938a9cb530", "text": "robotic competition, Lego Mindstorms was always a really really great way to try out different things. That was really fantastic. [...] reading circles, PA learning groups", "reference": { "id": "a8bf24df-59c4-4a62-a557-34b69e407950", "sourceId": "0a3c716c-aac7-451c-8222-605449298276", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 171 } ] } } ], "number": 68, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "b63ebe90-6f7e-47b5-b701-07d3139a70c9", "title": "Future education should use AI-driven personalized learning while respecting Bhutanese language and traditions.", "quotes": [ { "id": "e55f8fa1-eddd-4319-8201-e85a7b2ae596", "text": "Education may be more integrated into daily life, with children accessing AI-driven personalized learning systems [...] all while respecting our languages and traditions", "reference": { "id": "f3c69886-24af-424f-818a-7743eae7b2ff", "sourceId": "92db4d48-472f-43b5-9708-a352a965d24f", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 169 } ] } } ], "number": 69, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "3294524e-e8d6-425c-a20f-ca1376ef9bc7", "title": "AI-powered personalized learning can help Bhutanese students learn at their own pace, regardless of their region.", "quotes": [ { "id": "c420b4e4-7d6d-4a38-8731-d5b11f435258", "text": "Imagine students in Trongsa or Trashiyangtse learning math, coding, or Dzongkha poetry \u2014 guided by AI tutors that adapt to their pace and interests.", "reference": { "id": "5216e79a-0ba9-4727-a4b2-9fa723f202af", "sourceId": "84fe8168-4647-42df-8f54-4d7ae4e2455f", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 148 } ] } } ], "number": 70, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "329fd940-b27a-4148-8029-0743a2e843e5", "title": "Bhutan must ensure that youth receive proper education to prepare for the future.", "quotes": [ { "id": "0249cbff-1f78-4521-a667-d9b89ae44f67", "text": "Make sure the youth are properly educated", "reference": { "id": "fa16dec8-4c55-48e8-8b84-bf6e3fa4bb27", "sourceId": "4002cf61-ef96-47e2-82d1-f2105d873575", "interview": "1c457df71fd56e4694e06170399e9e6981366b57f236b71a2df01ad2ff75eff9", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 41 } ] } } ], "number": 71, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "cf9443c4-e1c4-49bf-801b-0bfc7d11ce22", "title": "Personalized & Accessible Learning", "description": "Personalized & Accessible Learning", "claims": [ { "id": "14f5b94a-ddb3-4e6d-a8f2-2ae36dd02e05", "title": "Online schools can bring education to remote areas that are hard to access.", "quotes": [ { "id": "c50c41d1-4858-49d3-ae4a-94b53c910943", "text": "create online schools, teach people in remote areas that are usually really hard to access", "reference": { "id": "706c6e97-c270-424f-a602-5c2f1f6b90f2", "sourceId": "ec1bec6f-45bd-4900-98a5-3e5571dcfe67", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 90 } ] } } ], "number": 72, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "821cf65c-656c-480a-9dd7-b12642cc1707", "title": "Bhutanese schools should be online and interconnected to share their unique stories.", "quotes": [ { "id": "5827e7d5-4bf6-41a6-b619-fadc2a451e98", "text": "they should be online and connected, such as they can tell their story", "reference": { "id": "58cc156a-759c-46ac-93de-353d5b974033", "sourceId": "a18e1dc3-2fee-4462-be34-bce9949e244c", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 70 } ] } } ], "number": 73, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "8bf29f39-a06c-4ff0-932c-0353a9581cda", "title": "Schools must be inclusive and welcome students from diverse backgrounds.", "quotes": [ { "id": "e455a8e7-35b4-4e61-9182-054442670e23", "text": "they should be inclusive, allowing everyone from different backgrounds to come in", "reference": { "id": "db7e0037-8b2b-4fc7-8895-e93fd5ccbbe5", "sourceId": "a18e1dc3-2fee-4462-be34-bce9949e244c", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 81 } ] } } ], "number": 74, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "e4df9fac-72a4-4fa9-ad3e-ba28caa7f7bf", "title": "Bhutan\u2019s curriculum should be more broad and tailored to students\u2019 interests to enable personalized learning.", "quotes": [ { "id": "52320e6b-0ea5-4caa-8c29-16380d4bd8a0", "text": "the curriculum can be more broad based on the students interests and can help create a personalized learning journey", "reference": { "id": "710d7c90-7827-498b-a6ac-59ca14c6275c", "sourceId": "d610cb81-23be-4db5-96bf-663fbf0038b6", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 116 } ] } } ], "number": 75, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "d79ccc0f-9e2c-4d53-a750-3a61bb4d30b3", "title": "Bhutan should use technology to detect and support students with learning difficulties.", "quotes": [ { "id": "d436c4b4-d5f4-450c-9ba0-750c68774b86", "text": "What about help with learning difficulties? How can we detect and support?", "reference": { "id": "8e607fbf-4fec-461c-bc12-70fef326d486", "sourceId": "a8e5153a-b64b-4602-b4fa-a901713b0eaa", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 74 } ] } } ], "number": 76, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "c40c4609-ae09-4c79-aafa-13af0489bfba", "title": "International Collaboration", "description": "International Collaboration", "claims": [ { "id": "2c8d8957-86c3-4786-8277-4728edc4f9db", "title": "Bhutanese students should learn about large language models both locally and internationally.", "quotes": [ { "id": "1f26b2e3-202b-42ac-9a3c-9009ccdeb258", "text": "We also need to make sure that Bhutanese students and young people are able to learn this knowledge either from outside Bhutan or from within Bhutan.", "reference": { "id": "05049ee9-3b55-427c-8cfd-3104fad80391", "sourceId": "15bdc651-832f-4f31-a814-00b8242376ef", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 149 } ] } } ], "number": 77, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "fc3ca38b-9400-4cf6-b3bb-ce40a6d1689d", "title": "Bhutan should support universities in inviting guest lecturers for specialized knowledge.", "quotes": [ { "id": "5ad2ab98-4bdf-408c-8fc6-56777f660519", "text": "We need to have invited guest lecturers coming in", "reference": { "id": "37cce40c-cb90-46bb-bdaa-93811a03dd07", "sourceId": "15bdc651-832f-4f31-a814-00b8242376ef", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 49 } ] } } ], "number": 78, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "2e7e14e1-21f5-4604-868f-cfe19b92eb38", "title": "Bhutan should actively invite international students and professors to come and teach in Bhutan.", "quotes": [ { "id": "19950cc5-28a4-4c6c-905a-8839956e1534", "text": "\"inviting different university students and professors from other countries and good universities to come to Bhutan and teach is also important.\"", "reference": { "id": "5bf1f9bb-cb5c-4a2c-a183-67a414a46146", "sourceId": "61a96171-1eb1-4076-afcb-7f9bd4882416", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 145 } ] } } ], "number": 79, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "1ec38864-8cea-4e74-b81f-008e4d056b23", "title": "Sending Bhutanese youth to universities abroad and bringing back their experience can strengthen Bhutan\u2019s education system.", "quotes": [ { "id": "463616a5-def9-47c3-b2b3-ee41e76f08dd", "text": "\"there could be delegations of Bhutanese young people that are going into different universities around the world\"", "reference": { "id": "8090190d-744f-498f-b4f3-6aef14ce9c74", "sourceId": "61a96171-1eb1-4076-afcb-7f9bd4882416", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 114 } ] } } ], "number": 80, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "7a4297bf-ba1e-4c8e-a5d5-e66c682fa600", "title": "Digital Literacy and IT Skills", "description": "Digital Literacy and IT Skills", "claims": [ { "id": "03cbbe66-3479-41dc-847c-8e2b5f0b1831", "title": "Open source technology allows people to tinker and learn by experimenting.", "quotes": [ { "id": "c100395e-dd88-4349-9495-b78d63c16c05", "text": "open source such that people can can tinker around with it and play around with it", "reference": { "id": "c77f3b09-655d-491f-b5a0-31ab22aa8f9c", "sourceId": "ec1bec6f-45bd-4900-98a5-3e5571dcfe67", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 82 } ] } } ], "number": 81, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "5b405f5c-28d8-47c4-94bf-79e826a77409", "title": "Early exposure to AI is necessary because people will use it and understanding its opportunities and challenges is important.", "quotes": [ { "id": "42ceb3af-e302-4043-9a49-cd0f4beaf6a3", "text": "get connected with AI really early on because AI is so early and people will use it and knowing how to use it is really important, understanding maybe also the challenges and opportunities of AI is really important as well.", "reference": { "id": "19562089-b03c-44f0-a14a-7ae2e21f35cb", "sourceId": "0a3c716c-aac7-451c-8222-605449298276", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 223 } ] } } ], "number": 82, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "b98ddf7f-4ab4-4c0a-b640-3571fe60a7d4", "title": "Teacher and Faculty Development", "description": "Teacher and Faculty Development", "claims": [ { "id": "36223ff8-4a49-4d4e-8ce0-9c061bf0cd30", "title": "AI is beneficial for teachers.", "quotes": [ { "id": "f6ff6af7-bcc4-45ae-aaa8-64e3894f973c", "text": "AI is good for teachers", "reference": { "id": "283dec66-dc9d-457b-8cd5-5c4e2288704d", "sourceId": "e06d81d4-7132-49f9-b94f-186d27737922", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 23 } ] } } ], "number": 83, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "f98d6e92-994c-46e6-b1bc-8f81b997bed7", "title": "Universities in Bhutan should recruit highly qualified professors for advanced technology education.", "quotes": [ { "id": "c3be219e-e3b7-42ae-9333-c2555f5abf29", "text": "universities need to adopt higher, really, really good professors.", "reference": { "id": "482dee4b-002f-486f-957e-4abd69fd4829", "sourceId": "15bdc651-832f-4f31-a814-00b8242376ef", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 66 } ] } } ], "number": 84, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "645ad843-b0da-4032-a0d7-b8e2f86f4425", "title": "Language and Cultural Education", "description": "Language and Cultural Education", "claims": [ { "id": "6ed15789-7f0d-4129-bc0a-0652f849d1b5", "title": "Bhutanese schools should cherish cultural heritage and multiple languages, with an emphasis on language education.", "quotes": [ { "id": "a06bb378-92c3-4f9e-8b85-39be897c717b", "text": "they should cherish its culture and different languages and also emphasize languages in that.", "reference": { "id": "9c35e616-a400-4ca3-b1ec-89c570b62b03", "sourceId": "a18e1dc3-2fee-4462-be34-bce9949e244c", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 93 } ] } } ], "number": 85, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "a9c5086f-d841-4e6a-90f1-62b17a65ff3e", "title": "Technology such as AI-powered platforms should respect local languages and traditions while fostering creativity in education.", "quotes": [ { "id": "7dc73405-1df8-4ccd-91c9-03e65a4e025f", "text": "AI in Education: Imagine platforms that provide personalized learning experiences tailored to each child's needs. This ensures that education respects our languages and traditions while fostering creativity.", "reference": { "id": "dc29d3a0-4119-42b5-903b-ebb5a9a96f8f", "sourceId": "14c995bd-546d-4c48-b867-761e60da7ff6", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 207 } ] } } ], "number": 86, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ], "topicColor": "blueSky" }, { "id": "ede5b57f-5b42-46d5-a07f-b961b218d4b3", "title": "What foundational human needs and values should guide Bhutan\u2019s approach to future development?", "description": "What foundational human needs and values should guide Bhutan\u2019s approach to future development?", "subtopics": [ { "id": "ff89ac1c-da6b-4f2e-ab55-c2e80fce0b16", "title": "Gross National Happiness", "description": "Gross National Happiness", "claims": [ { "id": "7f6a7982-e578-4514-a12f-f5612df5af42", "title": "Bhutan's approach to development is guided by the pillars of Gross National Happiness and innovation.", "quotes": [ { "id": "2743e76b-cae6-4e77-9e9e-96201e16ae01", "text": "It's doing so with the pillars of GNH and Innovation", "reference": { "id": "231efb66-c758-44f1-b3fc-be1a0dc358b6", "sourceId": "6a84dec6-de81-45e7-92b0-d9a6859a966f", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 52 } ] } } ], "number": 87, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "9df649f4-cd3e-4a9c-853a-6dd74aad7412", "title": "Bhutan's future should combine technological advancement with societal peace.", "quotes": [ { "id": "c66c6d42-488a-4d3d-9170-3bde26c7e32c", "text": "Peaceful and advanced in tech", "reference": { "id": "dab19e6d-9417-46b1-9162-87594e40ac81", "sourceId": "48437ad9-c3fe-4aef-8d17-d7e963ef399b", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 29 } ] } } ], "number": 88, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "a7910ff2-a536-4414-a5f7-3a7a880948c3", "title": "Technology in 2035 should enable a balance between productivity and personal well-being.", "quotes": [ { "id": "b0965482-db4c-45e0-86f9-8d231aed3cf1", "text": "technology serves as an enabler of happiness\u2014supporting our foundational human needs while respecting our cultural values. By 2035, our daily lives can reflect a balance of productivity and tranquility", "reference": { "id": "88f438e1-d000-4a75-be5a-6875b3723945", "sourceId": "92db4d48-472f-43b5-9708-a352a965d24f", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 201 } ] } } ], "number": 89, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "e239a0f1-bd7d-4254-b945-6389165653b6", "title": "Bhutan\u2019s future development should prioritize Gross National Happiness over purely economic measures.", "quotes": [ { "id": "9cbe47b6-2621-4399-970b-0584ff361eed", "text": "Gross national happiness", "reference": { "id": "0608c1af-9b95-4b90-a737-b712d1bcf9b6", "sourceId": "6054531a-9641-475d-9cf0-b29bd0bdd3be", "interview": "e85c8c8cc9686a3b213d06fbb67250a65fc4317b019d19ae0448bac473213fe3", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 24 } ] } } ], "number": 90, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "42518a09-fb00-4033-a66c-44491ec6512a", "title": "Bhutan should prioritize Gross National Happiness as a leading societal goal, even over economic growth.", "quotes": [ { "id": "5e9f94d1-1c2d-4583-885e-e628b43a3e87", "text": "Leads the world in Gross National Happiness, inspiring others to prioritize well-being over GDP.", "reference": { "id": "5dfccfd3-16c1-4f54-9b87-5b3547e7fc69", "sourceId": "fd028c30-453a-428a-89a5-e79a151b77ed", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 96 } ] } } ], "number": 91, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "34ea6350-0caa-4545-8084-9ca86125a7db", "title": "Bhutan should use a holistic approach rather than focus too much on metrics for guiding future development.", "quotes": [ { "id": "bdbb61dd-216c-42fa-9e2a-8ba121f194b4", "text": "too much focus on metrics is not good we have to have something holistic", "reference": { "id": "60a6546d-496b-4ca7-89bd-275ffab3ab20", "sourceId": "1d8977e5-42b7-49be-9e66-776bbaf20eae", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 72 } ] } } ], "number": 92, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "de260426-d20a-44c8-85cd-36b1d3dd80f0", "title": "Projects and decision making should be aligned with joy, happiness, and foundational human needs.", "quotes": [ { "id": "21f69c4f-f9c5-4517-a702-3616e504f411", "text": "Projects and decision making that are in alignment with joy and happiness and foundational human needs", "reference": { "id": "cf150dfc-bd5f-4dbd-a027-8af7cbe2bb5e", "sourceId": "955f3942-80fa-4be7-963b-44ac10fe50ff", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 102 } ] } } ], "number": 93, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "751657f3-4780-4092-af80-2a37011ec1b5", "title": "Happiness encourages people to seek diverse experiences and sectors, creating demand for new policies.", "quotes": [ { "id": "109e6d7c-7b80-4383-b39d-ba535aa33f55", "text": "People happy makes people want to live and experience different things opening doors to different sectors which brings in a want of different policy need", "reference": { "id": "249d9e5f-e33f-46c5-b4a9-133082f73a78", "sourceId": "5695d956-25c1-4037-bc5a-f15dd828da5e", "interview": "6fb64cfe0833a730093065c8b5a2bd1ae66a9c57851e0ce03ba213b92d08a0d1", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 153 } ] } } ], "number": 94, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "72d402be-c6af-419f-b80b-4fdca0ff162f", "title": "Bhutan should prioritize peace of mind for all beings as a core development goal.", "quotes": [ { "id": "5982098f-7019-40ef-8afc-07e491a35403", "text": "the vision I hold for Bhutan's future in 2035 will be the Country where there is peace of mind for every leaving being.", "reference": { "id": "23f08ddf-e426-4519-8689-e9e5056d9711", "sourceId": "4d6cc09d-4301-4f2c-8827-fb3e30a0e802", "interview": "278753489a2b076dc45af035513f9ff8fcbca538e38ee84bf9b4d38e0a2d5c48", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 119 } ] } } ], "number": 95, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "0247d026-3e45-4287-a2cb-e2949e4b60b1", "title": "Bhutan should develop metrics to measure human thriving and environmental well-being.", "quotes": [ { "id": "9149de02-a56d-4e41-a3fc-e0a77411dcf4", "text": "There should probably be some way to measure how humans thrive and how our environments are nourishing [...].", "reference": { "id": "26e293fb-2a1d-48f4-9eb2-9d020880b6fd", "sourceId": "72295b83-9999-4a19-a21f-bd3ff4ee41af", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 109 } ] } } ], "number": 96, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "e63be962-f443-446f-91d9-17b0f0890abd", "title": "Bhutan should seek a balanced relationship between nature and technology for sustainable living.", "quotes": [ { "id": "bed00b44-621a-4ba1-9ea5-2c622700c897", "text": "[...] helps live in some symbiosis with nature and technologies.", "reference": { "id": "e1d5e24f-b22b-4253-8f79-56424728cb1f", "sourceId": "72295b83-9999-4a19-a21f-bd3ff4ee41af", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 64 } ] } } ], "number": 97, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "f826663e-9ddd-4ff6-8e8d-d0c2c9f3dad3", "title": "Policies should prioritize collective wellbeing over individual interests to foster social harmony.", "quotes": [ { "id": "61acc574-b475-4195-8f88-1ecfb9bef836", "text": "Prioritizing the collective good over individual interests contributes to social harmony.", "reference": { "id": "541844f1-f49f-45c1-a953-f9f7bf007980", "sourceId": "14c995bd-546d-4c48-b867-761e60da7ff6", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 89 } ] } } ], "number": 98, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "3072b174-d322-4e91-b4d2-9a5d2164521b", "title": "Bhutan should become self-sufficient by 2035.", "quotes": [ { "id": "49e3fb60-81bd-4931-b23c-e766dfc8aed3", "text": "self sufficient country", "reference": { "id": "e8f944c4-543c-4206-8cff-4e0a5af9661c", "sourceId": "5cb7723a-e023-4826-8f97-ec78a7a567b0", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 23 } ] } } ], "number": 99, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "1e1f7d2c-6629-4549-8587-f8e3a8b11694", "title": "Safety, Security & Privacy", "description": "Safety, Security & Privacy", "claims": [ { "id": "0060095b-8eca-4cf8-894d-65040a7b75fa", "title": "NDI should protect users\u2019 digital dignity by giving them control over their data and ensuring AI is fair and transparent.", "quotes": [ { "id": "449ec081-4e77-46c8-b9fa-254a6ebe3324", "text": "NDI could protect digital dignity\u2014ensuring that people control how their data is used, and that AI systems built around NDI are ethical, fair, and transparent.", "reference": { "id": "15ad0b04-6141-4e2b-a144-9b658dbf3103", "sourceId": "ad9776d7-2d2c-4bb6-9402-189d697f5de6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 159 } ] } } ], "number": 100, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "5f8d0edc-fdc6-4812-981c-2419b366bb6f", "title": "NDI systems must safeguard digital dignity by ensuring people control their own data and that AI systems are built ethically and transparently.", "quotes": [ { "id": "7329c8f0-3165-409b-8584-6bd17173430f", "text": "NDI could protect digital dignity\u2014ensuring that people control how their data is used, and that AI systems built around NDI are ethical, fair, and transparent.", "reference": { "id": "85c66fde-43a2-4144-86d0-087b443d4789", "sourceId": "cdad00d6-4d3d-4676-8b68-b730b3bd894d", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 159 } ] } } ], "number": 101, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "cd6f03d4-3e43-4ce9-bcf7-950f6926a505", "title": "Bhutan should ensure the privacy of all citizens in its digital transformation.", "quotes": [ { "id": "fcd8272b-01fb-4e35-81ea-795376c6cf3b", "text": "Maintain privacy for all the citizens", "reference": { "id": "c52f146a-28b2-4433-8eec-3063b1712431", "sourceId": "42115c8f-e41f-4606-b338-964014290382", "interview": "1c457df71fd56e4694e06170399e9e6981366b57f236b71a2df01ad2ff75eff9", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 37 } ] } } ], "number": 102, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "dc839eda-ac3c-47c6-a0c9-cd6f8c48c6f9", "title": "Community and Belonging", "description": "Community and Belonging", "claims": [ { "id": "98e98efe-dd6e-4023-ac63-c9fb9b154903", "title": "Technology and development should focus on fulfilling fundamental human needs for community thriving.", "quotes": [ { "id": "cd15effb-ea8f-4dd5-97a4-29af2d032083", "text": "Working towards fulfilling human needs that makes communities thrive", "reference": { "id": "798f4561-906c-49f7-8b4b-5dc74fbc98f5", "sourceId": "30725807-4a09-483d-ba57-84642a5349ad", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 68 } ] } } ], "number": 103, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "7604fa0f-ac17-4f9f-a854-4b5722c8f938", "title": "Engaging citizens in decision making fosters a sense of belonging.", "quotes": [ { "id": "fdcf1bf9-ff53-4a66-82ba-dfcfc49cfd32", "text": "It is important to engage citizens in decision making and fostering a sense of belonging", "reference": { "id": "3f5874a9-48d7-481b-84c7-aa14a03da7d4", "sourceId": "59d67376-b7c5-4b51-a6ce-274135ed30fb", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 88 } ] } } ], "number": 104, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "b55d3e3d-cd91-4234-9c88-aa9eb95e4c98", "title": "Cultural Preservation", "description": "Cultural Preservation", "claims": [ { "id": "9ed6f5f3-72d9-4bbf-a07e-5333c2c61240", "title": "Honoring traditions and local practices is vital to maintaining Bhutanese identity and enriching community ties.", "quotes": [ { "id": "f05bdded-6d85-4a61-98ce-a240aa864306", "text": "Honoring traditions and local practices is vital in a globalized world. This not only maintains identity but also enriches community ties and the overall societal fabric.", "reference": { "id": "ed3f1e40-29b6-4f72-a827-2d331f9355e7", "sourceId": "14c995bd-546d-4c48-b867-761e60da7ff6", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 170 } ] } } ], "number": 105, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ], "topicColor": "red" }, { "id": "4f6e0d41-efc0-4050-b5cf-c7e9d82c4ff0", "title": "How can Bhutan ensure the integration of technology strengthens, rather than undermines, its cultural identity?", "description": "How can Bhutan ensure the integration of technology strengthens, rather than undermines, its cultural identity?", "subtopics": [ { "id": "838bfce5-1a99-4b31-a6b1-5340b73006c4", "title": "Language and Low-Resource AI", "description": "Language and Low-Resource AI", "claims": [ { "id": "28152166-9fed-4594-bfca-d06c8f5add46", "title": "Tech solutions should ensure Dzongkha is included and promoted in digital platforms.", "quotes": [ { "id": "865f7876-c926-4f88-9275-3704546ac694", "text": "How about our national language Dzongkha", "reference": { "id": "86937d53-1118-4abd-9ad3-991bcfaa4e97", "sourceId": "008c3384-9efc-4aef-859a-0038b3cbd582", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 40 } ] } } ], "number": 106, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "8d565fa0-cdc0-464c-8f4e-f87c96aed7d2", "title": "AI currently struggles with Bhutan's local language due to it being a low-resource language, creating bias.", "quotes": [ { "id": "cf52ed5a-068a-439e-a518-57e97a9c1a7e", "text": "AI doesn't speak their local language really well because it's a low resource language so that's one of the important biases.", "reference": { "id": "a75ce371-9099-4f10-ade6-9c617c4f8db3", "sourceId": "0a3c716c-aac7-451c-8222-605449298276", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 125 } ] } } ], "number": 107, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "76cb4dd8-328b-4d75-8c70-6149d29f975a", "title": "Bhutan should invest in its own large language models trained on Bhutanese datasets to avoid external biases.", "quotes": [ { "id": "7bfe3c92-b1c0-4858-a4cc-ab98e285145c", "text": "we need to invest in our own large language models that are trained on a Bhutanese dataset because having or being dependent on air models coming from outside are dangerous because they incorporate different kinds of biases.", "reference": { "id": "6c8ae94e-480f-4193-bf17-1a85e8efa585", "sourceId": "f56c3bcb-7d57-435f-aa56-ea61d8c940b0", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 224 } ] } } ], "number": 108, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "295c86d4-c271-40ae-81fe-e0d58243cc91", "title": "Digital services should provide interfaces in Dzongkha and local dialects to ensure respect for Bhutan\u2019s cultural and linguistic diversity.", "quotes": [ { "id": "eb0ec7a3-f63a-4ac6-a5b6-6efcedc15262", "text": "Interfaces in Dzongkha and local dialects, as well as support for non-textual users, would make sure that Bhutan\u2019s digital journey respects its rich diversity of culture, belief, and tradition.", "reference": { "id": "a2b47bd9-7c5e-4985-8649-668a31112dab", "sourceId": "cdad00d6-4d3d-4676-8b68-b730b3bd894d", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 193 } ] } } ], "number": 109, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "f2b469a2-3f9d-4877-8914-b87cad6e3b97", "title": "AI can preserve Bhutanese language and culture by translating global content into Dzongkha and other dialects.", "quotes": [ { "id": "e1055f79-5092-48c9-b62e-6544af6c5a1f", "text": "AI can also translate content into Dzongkha and other dialects, preserving language while unlocking global knowledge.", "reference": { "id": "c7bce917-4f50-48eb-bd9e-465e29a49ff9", "sourceId": "84fe8168-4647-42df-8f54-4d7ae4e2455f", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 117 } ] } } ], "number": 110, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "04114207-abb5-47b1-aa5d-4378e6c5d9cc", "title": "Balancing Innovation with Tradition", "description": "Balancing Innovation with Tradition", "claims": [ { "id": "ed18fac1-df14-4620-9e38-17b4bc427c67", "title": "Technology integration should promote the development of Bhutan's rich culture.", "quotes": [ { "id": "9edaa12d-cb36-4893-983b-76c9a9aeaf23", "text": "technologies integration ensuing rich culture development", "reference": { "id": "33f566c8-3e27-4021-87e5-564cd15e18b0", "sourceId": "6f34c80c-df29-4464-8f30-81e0754c9a71", "interview": "e85c8c8cc9686a3b213d06fbb67250a65fc4317b019d19ae0448bac473213fe3", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 57 } ] } } ], "number": 111, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "3ca1f927-680c-4e84-9409-4196ce5de6df", "title": "Technology development in Bhutan should ensure that local culture is able to flourish.", "quotes": [ { "id": "a6bee9b7-4d96-46f2-8e86-1f3d1467e269", "text": "We really wants our culture also flourish", "reference": { "id": "552b26fd-18a6-4058-a274-974308c0f527", "sourceId": "8358ca74-1e4e-493d-b73e-86f16cb9b466", "interview": "e85c8c8cc9686a3b213d06fbb67250a65fc4317b019d19ae0448bac473213fe3", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 41 } ] } } ], "number": 112, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "9c98839a-64fa-4d59-8cef-0015146919e1", "title": "Bhutan should prioritize preserving its culture and traditions even as it adopts new technologies.", "quotes": [ { "id": "cb90390d-ea8c-46f5-a4bd-3d313fa006d4", "text": "We should focus more on keeping the stuff as it is. We should be conservative. I really like Bhutan's culture, tradition. I think that it should not come at the oast of technology.", "reference": { "id": "17f5bcc9-e800-49c4-a30f-4832856c09ab", "sourceId": "0c2a1010-47d4-4239-8c03-34eff63efbcd", "interview": "c93f2ef5ea178642fdf85a002a7403718cf43412448c939cb1e36294e189fd85", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 180 } ] } } ], "number": 113, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "b29f3dfa-e9a6-4d27-b113-e0838abb7e44", "title": "Digital technologies should support youth in accessing education, remote work, and innovation without losing Bhutanese language and cultural identity.", "quotes": [ { "id": "7c71ac4f-0881-4142-b9af-c44ab65a46a2", "text": "Builds digital bridges for its youth, offering education, remote work, and innovation \u2014 all without losing touch with Dzongkha chants and the wisdom of the Himalayas.", "reference": { "id": "153a93d0-d0b0-4efe-a16f-b0860bef9e17", "sourceId": "fd028c30-453a-428a-89a5-e79a151b77ed", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 166 } ] } } ], "number": 114, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ] }, { "id": "3b18a0bf-b397-444a-944c-aa567d50224a", "title": "Digital Heritage Preservation", "description": "Digital Heritage Preservation", "claims": [ { "id": "26d5f037-b83a-4aba-a783-9c3a70a7f923", "title": "Bhutan should prioritize digital heritage preservation to safeguard its cultural identity.", "quotes": [ { "id": "72dab745-212d-4325-a2ae-1a8a0ca0bb9f", "text": "Help me delve more into the digital heritage preservation", "reference": { "id": "72f865e4-9509-4c26-8161-df4ddf66d30f", "sourceId": "400e3d40-462a-46ae-8d54-7144e051f094", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 57 } ] } } ], "number": 115, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "ee4e3dec-90c2-46db-b3e0-7884708c40cc", "title": "Technology should be used to create digital archives that preserve and globally share Bhutanese art, music, and folklore.", "quotes": [ { "id": "80c0f7ad-a45f-44de-a789-0e1f0865d3b0", "text": "Using technology to archive and share Bhutanese art, music, and folklore preserves our heritage while reaching global audiences who wish to connect with our culture.", "reference": { "id": "a47c603e-2d6b-4937-a65e-6f1c913ff708", "sourceId": "14c995bd-546d-4c48-b867-761e60da7ff6", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 165 } ] } } ], "number": 116, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "33f854ea-fa7b-4739-9cc2-cc867a7afe52", "title": "Digital platforms can help Bhutanese communities stay culturally connected across the world.", "quotes": [ { "id": "9d95265d-af95-4832-b3bb-01742229de8d", "text": "Digital platforms could help us maintain connections with Bhutanese communities worldwide, celebrating our heritage in unison", "reference": { "id": "ebd943de-8131-47cb-a4c6-78ede1848839", "sourceId": "92db4d48-472f-43b5-9708-a352a965d24f", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 125 } ] } } ], "number": 117, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "74316b0a-2852-4516-b395-c36f85521b35", "title": "Inclusive Interface Design", "description": "Inclusive Interface Design", "claims": [ { "id": "8b1fab36-ac16-482d-91ff-805373a6f58b", "title": "Digital interfaces should support Dzongkha, local dialects, and non-textual users to respect Bhutan\u2019s cultural diversity.", "quotes": [ { "id": "f7cfd881-1c22-4caf-904e-3e7396af2988", "text": "Interfaces in Dzongkha and local dialects, as well as support for non-textual users, would make sure that Bhutan\u2019s digital journey respects its rich diversity of culture, belief, and tradition.", "reference": { "id": "966faabf-09d5-498f-89b4-28a10eb8af72", "sourceId": "ad9776d7-2d2c-4bb6-9402-189d697f5de6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 193 } ] } } ], "number": 118, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ], "topicColor": "greenLime" }, { "id": "c7adccc1-8ca2-4d7e-9839-232d414c7c54", "title": "How can citizen engagement and public participation be enhanced using digital tools in Bhutan?", "description": "How can citizen engagement and public participation be enhanced using digital tools in Bhutan?", "subtopics": [ { "id": "83b55dae-53b8-4f57-a52b-3314b468d1f4", "title": "E-Voting and Civic Tech", "description": "E-Voting and Civic Tech", "claims": [ { "id": "f4ea9924-e2b0-4265-bd9e-cd96354bbb4a", "title": "AI can lower the barrier for citizens to submit creative governance proposals.", "quotes": [ { "id": "0b6229db-62bc-461f-8065-2a7213092d23", "text": "AI can be used to lower the barrier for creative proposals in governance", "reference": { "id": "ffba81b6-5da8-4121-b09e-c21e5c6df89a", "sourceId": "4c25b689-e863-4a7a-92c6-8f9da2fa98b0", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 72 } ] } } ], "number": 119, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "14e9c8e7-f346-4010-a69f-9471722fceea", "title": "The barrier of entry for citizens to participate in creating proposals and ideas should be lowered.", "quotes": [ { "id": "6b1d260c-027a-4530-8a7f-e86ae96a3447", "text": "Lower the barrier of entry for citizens to participate in creating proposals and ideas.", "reference": { "id": "b8c5e2a1-476c-4097-8d88-cf8f8bc2b324", "sourceId": "955f3942-80fa-4be7-963b-44ac10fe50ff", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 87 } ] } } ], "number": 120, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "b4954af6-d795-4bba-94dd-42901a45b950", "title": "Blockchain-secured e-voting could empower marginalized groups to participate in civic decisions.", "quotes": [ { "id": "7c7b8002-d947-4677-88df-ea6d4884ad81", "text": "Through blockchain-secured e-voting or civic participation tools, even the most marginalized voices\u2014elderly, monastics, single parents\u2014could influence decisions that affect their lives.", "reference": { "id": "376dd962-699d-491f-b850-72d15aa5b686", "sourceId": "ad9776d7-2d2c-4bb6-9402-189d697f5de6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 185 } ] } } ], "number": 121, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "f3cbed7b-d60c-4fb6-b352-b958fe8ab6eb", "title": "Blockchain-secured e-voting and civic tools can ensure that marginalized voices, like the elderly and single parents, are heard in decision-making.", "quotes": [ { "id": "06ef37d1-05ce-407d-a18f-6167b0c14626", "text": "Through blockchain-secured e-voting or civic participation tools, even the most marginalized voices\u2014elderly, monastics, single parents\u2014could influence decisions that affect their lives.", "reference": { "id": "8843d701-f097-434b-b1a7-a7279e3d044d", "sourceId": "cdad00d6-4d3d-4676-8b68-b730b3bd894d", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 185 } ] } } ], "number": 122, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "081809aa-caac-4d86-afac-cdb5c43e7b1b", "title": "Secure online voting through NDI will make Bhutanese democracy more inclusive and transparent by reducing barriers to participation.", "quotes": [ { "id": "3dea94fb-0a12-4056-9b80-d3c07dc25c2c", "text": "Citizens could securely vote online using their NDI, reducing barriers to participation and making democracy more inclusive and transparent.", "reference": { "id": "78f11b4c-b535-4700-bac1-5dfdcbc8b3ea", "sourceId": "133e7e82-1f87-4218-a776-d9ebf8a02af6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 140 } ] } } ], "number": 123, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "00c3dcee-c30b-42ac-8954-f473a6b7c5dd", "title": "Technology can be used to identify areas of citizen agreement for more focused decision making.", "quotes": [ { "id": "fbbf488a-bd2c-4794-b34e-c9dc7e1f637e", "text": "Figuring out alignment of citizens so decision making can focus on where agreement is", "reference": { "id": "b28ac7ef-b27f-4e5e-bda6-0af81aefda02", "sourceId": "638fff61-4531-4013-8cf7-40049414eec7", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 85 } ] } } ], "number": 124, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "aaf91885-00d0-44c6-9ff4-5cf32292a9d3", "title": "Blockchain-based voting systems can empower citizens and enhance trust in governance.", "quotes": [ { "id": "7caf1b5f-dd41-4ead-b8a3-8fbbc27fd788", "text": "A blockchain-based voting system, for instance, can enhance trust in democracy.", "reference": { "id": "19467acd-46d1-49d5-872d-bc52994dea06", "sourceId": "14c995bd-546d-4c48-b867-761e60da7ff6", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 79 } ] } } ], "number": 125, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "08470f85-015d-4c07-a7a5-b7cf42d2fe4a", "title": "Digital tools should allow every citizen in Bhutan to participate in local decision-making.", "quotes": [ { "id": "d08cdedd-3f6c-493d-903b-e929a3de0b50", "text": "Technology might facilitate these by allowing citizens to voice their opinions through digital platforms, ensuring that every voice is heard.", "reference": { "id": "50b4e5ae-4ac5-4902-b740-5f1b9fb9b0ba", "sourceId": "92db4d48-472f-43b5-9708-a352a965d24f", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 141 } ] } } ], "number": 126, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "bc4363ba-89d7-45b1-b8d2-b29a371e7661", "title": "Transparency and Data Sovereignty", "description": "Transparency and Data Sovereignty", "claims": [ { "id": "eafae41d-9edd-4728-9053-57a1b44bdfaf", "title": "Local communities should control their own data to ensure data sovereignty.", "quotes": [ { "id": "46770825-7fc2-4b38-a8d2-1174404bdb57", "text": "data sovereignty is really important because Bhutan's national digital identity is built on top of decentralized systems and DIDs.", "reference": { "id": "7067233a-b0cc-4198-9396-9b52376b93be", "sourceId": "280bef54-e3bb-4e3d-8fc3-e333cb823e7a", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 130 } ] } } ], "number": 127, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "7dc9f105-5ca5-4975-9a10-5c89e8890cd5", "title": "Local communities should have the choice to host and share their own AI models and data.", "quotes": [ { "id": "26781799-65be-498a-ba38-dffbd0a09f07", "text": "that they host their own AI models and AI servers and data and decide if they want to share the data or not", "reference": { "id": "bcd3c8c4-64ba-4dc3-9127-d45a2d47b10c", "sourceId": "280bef54-e3bb-4e3d-8fc3-e333cb823e7a", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 107 } ] } } ], "number": 128, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "ab77df2e-096e-4681-9615-6be43d4c150c", "title": "Bhutan\u2019s approach to digital identity and AI should empower community-led data stewardship.", "quotes": [ { "id": "7fdf352a-a094-40ae-8497-dd095fa0add6", "text": "Local communities are really important because they are the ones who are going to collect the data. They are the ones who are local and indigenous data scientists.", "reference": { "id": "bfea5f1a-6fbb-4c4a-8ecb-957f757042ae", "sourceId": "280bef54-e3bb-4e3d-8fc3-e333cb823e7a", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 163 } ] } } ], "number": 129, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "d46015f3-46d8-4657-bb74-b26efc9d9516", "title": "Maintaining Bhutanese sovereignty is essential when engaging in international collaboration.", "quotes": [ { "id": "e5278d2d-f9ec-473d-8e8c-3562fc6c5024", "text": "make sure that the sovereignty of the Bhutanese are maintained", "reference": { "id": "3acd0651-4f14-43f5-83b0-f65cba24c26f", "sourceId": "ac0afd52-a1f9-4ce0-b88b-8ccc1bbbd126", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 62 } ] } } ], "number": 130, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ], "topicColor": "violet" }, { "id": "1860bf56-2aeb-4a9e-8491-2c5dca60a2cf", "title": "How can technology advance Bhutan\u2019s goals for environmental protection and sustainability?", "description": "How can technology advance Bhutan\u2019s goals for environmental protection and sustainability?", "subtopics": [ { "id": "6121e4bc-ea5a-4cef-8b99-47f756bb54ec", "title": "Green Technologies", "description": "Green Technologies", "claims": [ { "id": "5f8e802a-dcd6-42e4-90a6-f7a92a850491", "title": "Eco-friendly technologies should be prioritized to make Bhutan greener.", "quotes": [ { "id": "9f2e3a51-b144-462f-bea2-424caddb36e7", "text": "Green Bhutan", "reference": { "id": "436c2115-86f3-4884-956a-185823bd95cf", "sourceId": "54e43401-6ca1-4667-87ce-8841ce28fd5a", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 12 } ] } } ], "number": 131, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "6b2385aa-9695-4cf7-8503-8080fe21b1a1", "title": "Adopting green technologies is important for effective work without harming the environment.", "quotes": [ { "id": "9b9881af-2428-403e-a6cd-6a193c4a7b5d", "text": "Eco friendly machines which does the work effectively would be nice as it wont be damaging the ecosystem", "reference": { "id": "7dcc2043-5c04-449f-bf35-075a4d49be2a", "sourceId": "783460d3-0635-4020-91e4-99b7e2993190", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 104 } ] } } ], "number": 132, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "027ef96e-d803-49d1-85f0-c6e768063b45", "title": "AI-driven tools will support sustainable agriculture, strengthening Bhutan\u2019s bond with nature.", "quotes": [ { "id": "237a91fb-2769-43d2-b497-4296b8956a2d", "text": "Many will likely engage in agricultural practices supported by AI, promoting sustainable farming techniques that respect the land", "reference": { "id": "66457a12-8f06-4f79-8a12-0d0adafc46c5", "sourceId": "92db4d48-472f-43b5-9708-a352a965d24f", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 129 } ] } } ], "number": 133, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "073ffe73-f9b0-496d-9995-9e1caa9f7e57", "title": "Bhutan should use clean, localized technologies such as solar power and smart farming while preserving the pristine environment.", "quotes": [ { "id": "5d362bda-1964-4b64-bfa9-5f0b44cc34ca", "text": "Uses clean, localized technology (like solar-powered monasteries and smart farming in the valleys) while preserving the pristine environment.", "reference": { "id": "f3db55dc-d05a-422f-ad7b-a551464c98b3", "sourceId": "fd028c30-453a-428a-89a5-e79a151b77ed", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 141 } ] } } ], "number": 134, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "81161793-239c-4baf-930f-00029f305814", "title": "Transparent Funding Mechanisms", "description": "Transparent Funding Mechanisms", "claims": [ { "id": "f7e73b7c-8208-4f6e-9be0-e06eba6945bb", "title": "Blockchain can be used to raise international conservation funds for Bhutan.", "quotes": [ { "id": "500bcb8d-b7d0-496d-add3-ce2e34bd6be0", "text": "using blockchain we can even raise funds from international conservation for it.", "reference": { "id": "b528e46c-5868-49bf-a508-14026abd6a92", "sourceId": "e965d1ae-b729-4f15-93d8-72a6d0a4e5f5", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 80 } ] } } ], "number": 135, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "826f79ff-a398-44f8-b7bd-d76f4e18c162", "title": "Blockchain can make funding for projects transparent and efficient.", "quotes": [ { "id": "0a227cc5-60b7-4d2c-8612-d66ac6a5de03", "text": "use blockchains to fund projects and initiatives in transparent and verifiable ways and making capital flows in more efficient ways.", "reference": { "id": "2e86a1b4-9e85-43af-8d27-1da3157fa0d3", "sourceId": "0a62ad8a-4076-4d86-a258-d73b5197f1ec", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 132 } ] } } ], "number": 136, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "326fc231-019d-4f21-b73a-2951576ccb64", "title": "Project financing should be efficient, transparent, and verifiable.", "quotes": [ { "id": "02f196b9-863a-4619-9a05-3ae9b907f3f5", "text": "Efficient, transparent, and verifiable financing for projects and proposals.", "reference": { "id": "2aa24e18-3a50-44e0-81b2-5b160fcc8d18", "sourceId": "955f3942-80fa-4be7-963b-44ac10fe50ff", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 76 } ] } } ], "number": 137, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ] }, { "id": "50d053f3-a0db-4c30-b0d4-52108314afd0", "title": "Data-Driven Environmental Management", "description": "Data-Driven Environmental Management", "claims": [ { "id": "f77f30d0-87b7-421d-ad70-b39a6ab0828c", "title": "AI and decentralized technology can efficiently communicate Bhutan's environmental impact.", "quotes": [ { "id": "64b2466f-f22d-4a6a-9881-120aa9bf0d8f", "text": "using AI and decentralized technology we can tell the story of Bhutan's environmental impact super efficiently.", "reference": { "id": "011d6cde-d5cf-4968-99b1-ad26944682f5", "sourceId": "e965d1ae-b729-4f15-93d8-72a6d0a4e5f5", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 111 } ] } } ], "number": 138, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "e4fd70ee-e02d-46d8-b08c-7201ddac50eb", "title": "Technology should be used to monitor Bhutan's environment and ecosystem as well as its technological progress.", "quotes": [ { "id": "aa2528ca-bcff-44a3-93d0-075679b2e675", "text": "help me track Bhutan's future, not only in technology but Bhutan's entire environment and ecosystem as a whole.", "reference": { "id": "ef4ded7c-a0d6-4806-905c-6747ee8556bb", "sourceId": "85860854-5ed9-4ea2-9dec-45bacfe60ee9", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 111 } ] } } ], "number": 139, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "9fc5c395-f07a-421a-a708-e00c3dd88afa", "title": "Community-Led Conservation", "description": "Community-Led Conservation", "claims": [ { "id": "45ba56fb-8e8b-4e6c-945a-cde7085ce809", "title": "Communities should be empowered to request funding for their own projects.", "quotes": [ { "id": "0d37bd7e-66b9-4b0d-94fa-7717d1d2f222", "text": "communities can request funding for projects that they want to work on.", "reference": { "id": "eff94a93-608b-487e-96b7-ae390d568de4", "sourceId": "0a62ad8a-4076-4d86-a258-d73b5197f1ec", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 71 } ] } } ], "number": 140, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "55a9559c-7ee5-4dfa-8f25-143ee800b69e", "title": "Climate Change Adaptation", "description": "Climate Change Adaptation", "claims": [ { "id": "745a0b57-826a-47f8-8935-9ac9669324ed", "title": "Bhutan\u2019s agriculture fields are different from those in eastern countries, so solutions must be adapted to local conditions.", "quotes": [ { "id": "990eed6e-20d2-4152-b5ca-0f01d5a09504", "text": "agriculture fields in bhutan differ from eastern countries", "reference": { "id": "d9f52396-3a05-433e-a481-b9a792dfa397", "sourceId": "6259616f-e7e2-4ffd-a386-7bc3edafe088", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 58 } ] } } ], "number": 141, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ], "topicColor": "greenLeaf" }, { "id": "3e9b53d6-18b0-4b81-bcc2-a56813e5a431", "title": "What challenges might Bhutan face in digital transformation and how can they be overcome?", "description": "What challenges might Bhutan face in digital transformation and how can they be overcome?", "subtopics": [ { "id": "b36a56af-a5b1-4e7d-8afd-03c181064e7d", "title": "Adoption and Accessibility", "description": "Adoption and Accessibility", "claims": [ { "id": "5a64d9ff-493c-4d83-ae52-16e5d81c3400", "title": "Technology solutions, such as NDI, must be accessible to non-English speakers to ensure adoption by all segments of society.", "quotes": [ { "id": "42c7d052-1406-4837-abe7-f0170ddcc094", "text": "people who do not know how to read in English can also use the application", "reference": { "id": "d8b3d7bc-1fed-444c-ab62-5567f54822db", "sourceId": "beb7bcfc-149c-45be-92e9-f05d2eeb458a", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 74 } ] } } ], "number": 142, "similarClaims": [ { "id": "dea2d6ee-fb55-4c16-9139-3dc71e485539", "title": "Digital solutions should be simplified and available in Dzongkha to ensure monks can use them.", "quotes": [ { "id": "375af485-3f41-497a-9055-776a768c0492", "text": "how can you simplify them for there understanding as they only know Dzongkhag language", "reference": { "id": "715babbd-5d49-4b10-ad62-be30d372ec01", "sourceId": "c7994a96-e711-433b-8873-6237dbeeac89", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 86 } ] } } ], "number": 143, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "3af6cb0a-385f-43ce-bbef-0c9e870715d6", "title": "AI tools such as writing assistants can make remote work more accessible for Bhutanese who are not fluent in English.", "quotes": [ { "id": "4517be3d-2b2a-45ed-8c9e-c4d1b7d47e00", "text": "With AI tools like writing assistants, no one needs to feel left out if their English isn\u2019t perfect.", "reference": { "id": "6619e9d2-5b3f-43f8-a75c-14843d6d4bc9", "sourceId": "84fe8168-4647-42df-8f54-4d7ae4e2455f", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 100 } ] } } ], "number": 144, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ] }, { "id": "fa65211a-3cca-4f9f-ab01-fc498a04529d", "title": "Digital Literacy and Awareness", "description": "Digital Literacy and Awareness", "claims": [ { "id": "a7bf491f-4d1e-4a0d-9fe7-e6a244c2a827", "title": "Bhutan is still in the early stages of its technological journey but is making significant progress toward a digital economy.", "quotes": [ { "id": "369edb54-7a12-46aa-9007-eee81a1b92b0", "text": "We are a very young nation when it comes to technology I guess but we are striving forward [...] building a digital economy for the future", "reference": { "id": "6b0189c7-4880-45c4-9777-afef1d143bbf", "sourceId": "153e1c87-a71a-45fe-9d60-dfc994d39a06", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 138 } ] } } ], "number": 145, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "5fc0fbfd-eca3-4ce6-ac42-a805ab185895", "title": "Technological adoption in Bhutan needs to consider challenges faced by less digitally literate people to ensure true inclusivity.", "quotes": [ { "id": "2b04a222-fc68-44d3-9f6e-387f2ebad15c", "text": "And there are people who are not so much digitally literate. So our aim is to give awareness about digital literacy", "reference": { "id": "f7d5513b-726c-4571-87d3-09cb602c1662", "sourceId": "beb7bcfc-149c-45be-92e9-f05d2eeb458a", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 115 } ] } } ], "number": 146, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "1c6f70a5-243f-4448-8cda-ab2c10434100", "title": "Infrastructure and Connectivity", "description": "Infrastructure and Connectivity", "claims": [ { "id": "60e278c2-276b-49ed-9ee5-f928707751c9", "title": "Bhutan faces significant challenges with terrain and internet connectivity that could impact digital transformation.", "quotes": [ { "id": "f69c1b1e-7e24-4302-a375-de36d2c4785a", "text": "the terrain and internet connectivity challenge", "reference": { "id": "ba985eb1-9f24-4099-bdb2-4b2409245a75", "sourceId": "c5cca4f5-b6e3-4764-b20a-b2428d76eb73", "interview": "1408f1efef49536bf9548e3ae4884f6b7840039271662d8ff0ca8aa6da23a042", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 47 } ] } } ], "number": 147, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "43c370bf-d279-48c3-8e4d-ee1204860b90", "title": "Technology infrastructure should ensure apps have high uptime and availability.", "quotes": [ { "id": "8226607f-23be-4bcc-ae88-8d0bc734678d", "text": "apps that never go down", "reference": { "id": "8b077bfa-840a-4934-ad98-b7906b422840", "sourceId": "08f2ad31-88d5-41a9-b6b9-a94bfba459b1", "interview": "f4dfa0191407beba5ecb691b819262098732659b63d628e6b3903a98d9c18917", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 23 } ] } } ], "number": 148, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "c42efb38-2525-4565-afd2-d2bdcf2b3959", "title": "Policy and Regulation", "description": "Policy and Regulation", "claims": [ { "id": "8b1bedf2-20c8-4b38-9cf7-516b61e82916", "title": "Revising current policies will improve Bhutan's administrative structure.", "quotes": [ { "id": "169002c1-a1a3-4f1b-b26f-bdf769a3546c", "text": "we are revising our current policies and everything. I think Bhutan's administrative structure will also improve.", "reference": { "id": "a626d54b-463b-46df-a82a-5cee2f2e6b75", "sourceId": "d3b69e8d-fbe6-4402-9cf4-767918e7e850", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 113 } ] } } ], "number": 149, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "0c13cfa2-a6df-4e42-bf91-3f2728ee5da6", "title": "Trust, Privacy & Security", "description": "Trust, Privacy & Security", "claims": [ { "id": "68cbaccd-060c-4f92-8a70-a49de9e72301", "title": "There is a lack of trust in the accuracy of reported student progress.", "quotes": [ { "id": "b46b0b40-cd91-4ad2-aa28-44fe60ba360d", "text": "How do I know the student progress is true", "reference": { "id": "f06ce976-2277-4e71-b51b-9d5fa468f37c", "sourceId": "077d6878-1419-41c2-843b-d61785c26c5d", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 42 } ] } } ], "number": 150, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ], "topicColor": "purple" }, { "id": "7d85262b-2e1f-4c96-91fa-0a52780d9e3a", "title": "How can Bhutan attract and nurture domestic and international tech talent?", "description": "How can Bhutan attract and nurture domestic and international tech talent?", "subtopics": [ { "id": "dfb872bf-1e7f-419e-bbc5-5084555c6f57", "title": "Talent Education and Upskilling", "description": "Talent Education and Upskilling", "claims": [ { "id": "f9f35972-2894-4887-86a5-ac7bdf0fda73", "title": "Bhutan should aim to develop a workforce proficient in IT, blockchain, and programming languages like Python.", "quotes": [ { "id": "8070fc4f-2096-47ae-be09-93fa681a7756", "text": "people will be like well-profound and well-knowledged in IT and blockchain and Python and everything", "reference": { "id": "40fe08d2-ffc8-4994-a492-f62e28d8722b", "sourceId": "88e0b24f-3ea9-4f8d-a3c3-4780ea92464f", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 100 } ] } } ], "number": 151, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "4602aae7-6332-4bb9-b477-4e12bb6b6045", "title": "Developing large language models in Bhutan requires well-structured datasets and scientific understanding.", "quotes": [ { "id": "090c5393-51fe-43ce-92c1-f76f227f6af0", "text": "really well structured datasets and just an understanding of how to develop these models scientifically is also important.", "reference": { "id": "fe5b9ef6-e596-40c0-9339-e6fec1b8c3e6", "sourceId": "15bdc651-832f-4f31-a814-00b8242376ef", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 122 } ] } } ], "number": 152, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "05f3fbd5-3fd7-430e-93c9-39b6a6cac017", "title": "Bhutan should aspire to global achievements in science and technology, such as having a Bhutanese astronaut.", "quotes": [ { "id": "e518d565-6391-4f3e-81c6-f87adab1a537", "text": "And maybe\u2026 a Bhutanese astronaut one day?", "reference": { "id": "ce4cd87e-7bb3-4947-8ef4-5a6db6ec52e0", "sourceId": "fd028c30-453a-428a-89a5-e79a151b77ed", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 41 } ] } } ], "number": 153, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "b84eb40f-2af0-4a7d-9d43-94bc9f359797", "title": "International Collaboration and Exchange", "description": "International Collaboration and Exchange", "claims": [ { "id": "18b806b7-e169-4471-be21-b18824927443", "title": "Bhutan should invite international expertise to help build large language models.", "quotes": [ { "id": "4e83dae9-b945-4f60-b721-f3ba1df6ce4f", "text": "we need to share or even have some expertise coming from outside to teach.", "reference": { "id": "ab4dda6d-bceb-4319-8329-1254aa0cec18", "sourceId": "15bdc651-832f-4f31-a814-00b8242376ef", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 74 } ] } } ], "number": 154, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "b74c2275-287d-469a-9352-5a67c8c51f95", "title": "Creating regulations and support initiatives to facilitate international collaborations is more important than attracting foreign experts.", "quotes": [ { "id": "eaabfbbf-6c08-47cc-8d93-496cfbff7634", "text": "\"creating structures, regulations, governments, support initiatives that foster international collaborations are really important.\"", "reference": { "id": "13b77da1-f64f-4b74-8dff-8a01db1f42b7", "sourceId": "61a96171-1eb1-4076-afcb-7f9bd4882416", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 131 } ] } } ], "number": 155, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "fc4e6e2e-43b5-46a3-b27e-26ae1a8690d1", "title": "Bhutan should invite more foreign collaborations in technology and education.", "quotes": [ { "id": "083cf21a-b564-4f4e-855d-90a3e4ddc17d", "text": "Bhutan can invite more foreign collaborations in tech and education", "reference": { "id": "0cc82b91-40ef-47b7-beb9-e21960a49f01", "sourceId": "ac0afd52-a1f9-4ce0-b88b-8ccc1bbbd126", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 67 } ] } } ], "number": 156, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "a812169f-4353-4382-82dc-b55aad2b6377", "title": "Supportive Ecosystem & Incentives", "description": "Supportive Ecosystem & Incentives", "claims": [ { "id": "91d5fa90-9a55-4ac5-8f1a-2243d3373f32", "title": "The national program should provide free computational resources for developing language models.", "quotes": [ { "id": "b90c7d30-dcde-4354-ba06-4a5b8c47c3b9", "text": "the national program maybe should also support some computation resources, free resources, because computation is so important", "reference": { "id": "c3c66d48-cf7e-4ec9-bd86-34c7c734877c", "sourceId": "15bdc651-832f-4f31-a814-00b8242376ef", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 126 } ] } } ], "number": 157, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ], "topicColor": "blueSea" }, { "id": "63e7d0e4-1da0-465a-929e-8e52a4c6e1df", "title": "What are the possible scenarios for daily life in Bhutan in 2035?", "description": "What are the possible scenarios for daily life in Bhutan in 2035?", "subtopics": [ { "id": "37f1cae3-4d72-469a-b944-ac93f2d618bd", "title": "Sustainable Living", "description": "Sustainable Living", "claims": [ { "id": "22241395-237e-47dd-a158-33b2aea1c80e", "title": "Locally produced food is essential for Bhutan\u2019s sustainability.", "quotes": [ { "id": "2d55c8fe-777d-4636-af9e-4edef885baf2", "text": "Clean food and air. Locally produced.", "reference": { "id": "d9a849b9-00e1-4d4f-bc88-4bd26b29b18c", "sourceId": "30725807-4a09-483d-ba57-84642a5349ad", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 37 } ] } } ], "number": 158, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "710983a1-a5f8-497d-b9ce-3de5d8d7398e", "title": "AI should help Bhutanese families make nutritious meals that honor traditional recipes.", "quotes": [ { "id": "4460eada-733d-4e8e-a5b9-7a2fe8b9ca39", "text": "AI helping families tailor their meals to nutritional needs, while honoring traditional recipes", "reference": { "id": "7be3bc9b-cf84-4a35-9573-d4c5edc0a103", "sourceId": "92db4d48-472f-43b5-9708-a352a965d24f", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 95 } ] } } ], "number": 159, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "bf22a542-f354-4eba-84c1-3a43beed9206", "title": "Work and Learning", "description": "Work and Learning", "claims": [ { "id": "7dc5fdff-8dd0-4b14-916d-a13b9acb2c78", "title": "Bhutan is developed and people are prosperous.", "quotes": [ { "id": "38ef71f6-b688-4564-9088-0d44af8df282", "text": "It is developed and people are prosperous", "reference": { "id": "24351129-3887-4973-b421-f15575d03acc", "sourceId": "fd53e001-7c25-487c-99c9-046341706417", "interview": "19a0ea97d117a30a14aad0b90350b5ee76d4f3a29f56ed233bab1cdfaf3a7101", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 41 } ] } } ], "number": 160, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "5226e1db-e3e9-4745-9f66-c4988bab2aec", "title": "Flexible, tech-equipped workspaces and AI tools can boost creativity and leave more time for family.", "quotes": [ { "id": "b289912a-2b10-489d-afd9-2788593b9c7c", "text": "Many may work from home or community hubs equipped with advanced technology, allowing for creativity and collaboration. Tasks could be supported by AI tools that enhance productivity, leaving more time for personal pursuits or family engagement.", "reference": { "id": "d41cd473-1c12-47bf-9d98-6aee066b0f19", "sourceId": "92db4d48-472f-43b5-9708-a352a965d24f", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 245 } ] } } ], "number": 161, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "9237aa19-10b9-4177-aed3-3379777e6630", "title": "Health and Well-being", "description": "Health and Well-being", "claims": [ { "id": "9e6190e5-1cf0-43c5-88b0-87c1803fbd3c", "title": "AI integration into healthcare can ensure access for remote communities and support a holistic approach blending modern and traditional medicine.", "quotes": [ { "id": "ba10ebd7-186d-4726-a9b8-d6c1118bfb7f", "text": "AI getting integrated into healthcare could ensure access for remote communities, blending traditional medicine with modern practices, creating a holistic approach to wellbeing.", "reference": { "id": "668422af-1f8a-4bac-aa14-84ce929ed011", "sourceId": "14c995bd-546d-4c48-b867-761e60da7ff6", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 177 } ] } } ], "number": 162, "similarClaims": [] }, { "id": "1de64ee9-f5de-4d45-be2e-83a3a194f9af", "title": "Technology will support mindful routines and mental well-being through guided digital practices.", "quotes": [ { "id": "cbdb05d4-9898-49fd-87b5-26170765fbca", "text": "With access to guided meditations via digital apps, the day can conclude on a peaceful note, reinforcing mental well-being.", "reference": { "id": "137684c2-84aa-49d4-9823-f0fe52347838", "sourceId": "92db4d48-472f-43b5-9708-a352a965d24f", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 123 } ] } } ], "number": 163, "similarClaims": [] } ] }, { "id": "56c7c424-2707-4c67-b575-b564e52c6160", "title": "Family and Community Life", "description": "Family and Community Life", "claims": [ { "id": "2b195cba-fbc8-4fab-8199-e7e68cfede12", "title": "Tourism in Bhutan should focus on immersive, respectful experiences that teach cultural humility rather than just attracting visitors.", "quotes": [ { "id": "e2c4f3ab-5f06-47cf-8c34-33362ad82ba1", "text": "so that every tourist feels like a student of Bhutanese humility, not just a visitor.", "reference": { "id": "5e7c2318-40e0-4c03-ba70-9110ed4d5e33", "sourceId": "fd028c30-453a-428a-89a5-e79a151b77ed", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 85 } ] } } ], "number": 164, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ], "topicColor": "yellow" }, { "id": "9992f593-9ac2-48b4-8d84-8adf424b7f02", "title": "What best practices and case studies from other countries can Bhutan adopt for its digital and sustainable development?", "description": "What best practices and case studies from other countries can Bhutan adopt for its digital and sustainable development?", "subtopics": [ { "id": "cf5012d1-f21f-4441-8342-1ebd14d0424c", "title": "Policy and Governance Reforms", "description": "Policy and Governance Reforms", "claims": [ { "id": "f550cb75-3848-4f23-a047-0e5120f57fe8", "title": "International organizations and other countries are beginning to notice Bhutan's digital transformation efforts.", "quotes": [ { "id": "bff64eb9-1eda-4d77-b738-748c7c00531d", "text": "even international organizations, other countries are noticing what we are doing at the moment.", "reference": { "id": "c2178ce9-15e1-41b0-a75e-e02bd02c8562", "sourceId": "153e1c87-a71a-45fe-9d60-dfc994d39a06", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "startIdx": 0, "endIdx": 95 } ] } } ], "number": 165, "similarClaims": [] } ] } ], "topicColor": "brown" } ], "sources": [ { "id": "b1f1896f-7b71-4b0c-a596-fc515de276dd", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Give me some of the best practices and case studies around the world on this subject" } ] }, { "id": "3b43ff00-b46c-453c-8ae0-9e335a2e5511", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hi, this is Dave, this is Dave doing some a Dave taste on Takin AI and I'm very excited to see the product that David and his team has built. Now I'm looking forward to using it. Should it be just 30 seconds minimum? It's okay. Okay, let's see." } ] }, { "id": "ef01b18c-67a7-42ca-936d-a87bf6755087", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hi" } ] }, { "id": "d459dc02-4c8c-48bb-b751-66f3a12fc655", "interview": "87862e980a85b868b9611a281240df0e2d011b31d69d7f13251db6022a935076", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Bhutan in 2025" } ] }, { "id": "e017370f-5375-4988-ba2c-087b1b0ee138", "interview": "87862e980a85b868b9611a281240df0e2d011b31d69d7f13251db6022a935076", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Blockchain in identity" } ] }, { "id": "c0883678-6ffd-40c3-945c-a48bf8a81f31", "interview": "87862e980a85b868b9611a281240df0e2d011b31d69d7f13251db6022a935076", "data": [ "text", { "text": "How will Bhutan be in 2020 or 2030?" } ] }, { "id": "d3b69e8d-fbe6-4402-9cf4-767918e7e850", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Also, I think Bhutan's administration would also improve because we are revising our current policies and everything. I think Bhutan's administrative structure will also improve. So what do you think about Bhutan from 30 years from now in line with my vision?" } ] }, { "id": "88e0b24f-3ea9-4f8d-a3c3-4780ea92464f", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "text": "To me, I envision Bhutan as a high-tech country for around 30 years from now, whereby people will be like well-profound and well-knowledged in IT and blockchain and Python and everything. So since at present, Bhutan is focusing so much on AI, tech related businesses, education and everything so for from 30 years from now I guess like Bhutan will be over flooded with technical and well profound IT professionals." } ] }, { "id": "3a6a6a68-7d32-472c-8867-5700f55ea510", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "asd" } ] }, { "id": "280bef54-e3bb-4e3d-8fc3-e333cb823e7a", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Local communities are really important because they are the ones who are going to collect the data. They are the ones who are local and indigenous data scientists. So data sovereignty is really important because Bhutan's national digital identity is built on top of decentralized systems and DIDs. Data sovereignty is so important that it can be replicated also as well for AI and environment when it comes to local communities that they host their own AI models and AI servers and data and decide if they want to share the data or not, similar to NDI." } ] }, { "id": "e965d1ae-b729-4f15-93d8-72a6d0a4e5f5", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I also think there is a big opportunity of using technology to protect the environment in Bhutan. Because Bhutan has one of the most pristine forests and mountain landscapes. It's a carbon negative country and I think using AI and decentralized technology we can tell the story of Bhutan's environmental impact super efficiently. and maybe using blockchain we can even raise funds from international conservation for it." } ] }, { "id": "b9c76ec9-4fb5-42a2-9843-de07753a7e02", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "asdad" } ] }, { "id": "b09f5807-7af4-46dd-8e2b-6eb9ae0a58d3", "interview": "1408f1efef49536bf9548e3ae4884f6b7840039271662d8ff0ca8aa6da23a042", "data": [ "text", { "text": "hello" } ] }, { "id": "dc56b8a9-7681-4771-8ae2-07e3a647a8e0", "interview": "1408f1efef49536bf9548e3ae4884f6b7840039271662d8ff0ca8aa6da23a042", "data": [ "text", { "text": "please suggest where Bhutan should focus" } ] }, { "id": "e705aa01-ac7c-46d2-a611-72fecf55e88e", "interview": "1408f1efef49536bf9548e3ae4884f6b7840039271662d8ff0ca8aa6da23a042", "data": [ "text", { "text": "10 fold growth in digital economy" } ] }, { "id": "5bef3f76-77a4-4f66-87d9-e328a3440df1", "interview": "6fb64cfe0833a730093065c8b5a2bd1ae66a9c57851e0ce03ba213b92d08a0d1", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hi" } ] }, { "id": "f7547e4a-c0c3-4ba1-8f65-a21f49cc77c3", "interview": "f4dfa0191407beba5ecb691b819262098732659b63d628e6b3903a98d9c18917", "data": [ "text", { "text": "yoooo" } ] }, { "id": "89d3177b-e16b-4f54-9173-884f6e2ca29b", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello" } ] }, { "id": "f9a291a3-ec0b-46ef-94e2-1fee4e236a99", "interview": "e85c8c8cc9686a3b213d06fbb67250a65fc4317b019d19ae0448bac473213fe3", "data": [ "text", { "text": "GMC" } ] }, { "id": "d3ffb1ad-5289-4de1-a313-2009b14c1ddf", "interview": "e85c8c8cc9686a3b213d06fbb67250a65fc4317b019d19ae0448bac473213fe3", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello" } ] }, { "id": "6a84dec6-de81-45e7-92b0-d9a6859a966f", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "text": "It's doing so with the pillars of GNH and Innovation" } ] }, { "id": "48437ad9-c3fe-4aef-8d17-d7e963ef399b", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Peaceful and advanced in tech" } ] }, { "id": "008c3384-9efc-4aef-859a-0038b3cbd582", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "text": "How about our national language Dzongkha" } ] }, { "id": "c8d72718-2a25-412e-a721-b304ea47940b", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hi" } ] }, { "id": "6f34c80c-df29-4464-8f30-81e0754c9a71", "interview": "e85c8c8cc9686a3b213d06fbb67250a65fc4317b019d19ae0448bac473213fe3", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Mostly we need technologies integration ensuing rich culture development" } ] }, { "id": "8358ca74-1e4e-493d-b73e-86f16cb9b466", "interview": "e85c8c8cc9686a3b213d06fbb67250a65fc4317b019d19ae0448bac473213fe3", "data": [ "text", { "text": "We really wants our culture also flourish" } ] }, { "id": "63b3a706-079f-4a9a-a6ac-b00d42d3ecc2", "interview": "e85c8c8cc9686a3b213d06fbb67250a65fc4317b019d19ae0448bac473213fe3", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Blockchain and data science technology" } ] }, { "id": "731252f2-e4e1-4c27-84dc-8830e97dd38c", "interview": "e85c8c8cc9686a3b213d06fbb67250a65fc4317b019d19ae0448bac473213fe3", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Our country wants Gelephu Mindfull City flourish higher" } ] }, { "id": "6054531a-9641-475d-9cf0-b29bd0bdd3be", "interview": "e85c8c8cc9686a3b213d06fbb67250a65fc4317b019d19ae0448bac473213fe3", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Gross national happiness" } ] }, { "id": "54e43401-6ca1-4667-87ce-8841ce28fd5a", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Green Bhutan" } ] }, { "id": "5dcc573f-a76f-4fb3-8330-ddb1ba92820e", "interview": "6e070ed885ccc7f2538bcfed69c4434498d0a0fe9fc96bcc26c66e5c3e4a7a81", "data": [ "text", { "text": "The app can't recognise my face" } ] }, { "id": "bb87a1b6-c0cc-4eb6-9f8e-02cf4c25f576", "interview": "6e070ed885ccc7f2538bcfed69c4434498d0a0fe9fc96bcc26c66e5c3e4a7a81", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hii I am stuck with opening my bhutan ndi" } ] }, { "id": "98a8fa2f-356e-487b-89ff-82e60df83ccf", "interview": "6e070ed885ccc7f2538bcfed69c4434498d0a0fe9fc96bcc26c66e5c3e4a7a81", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello" } ] }, { "id": "bd629629-4218-4907-874b-783e4e783074", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "text": "AI and Block chain integration in NDI" } ] }, { "id": "309410c7-0798-46cc-9971-a760beef1962", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Yes it should be digitally developed but should be mindful and eco friendly" } ] }, { "id": "ce2cc197-b243-4d14-946a-df5a35ab399c", "interview": "87d5e3a9e3f33cc815c69c997329703f707ded7aedb989a211dae487559a7692", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello" } ] }, { "id": "a23dd7d2-55fa-4d56-a645-62a071d64433", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "asdsad" } ] }, { "id": "4860c863-d6a5-4751-959e-28fd9a127623", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hi" } ] }, { "id": "24b9665c-e76a-4859-8f2a-42944f56954f", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hi" } ] }, { "id": "28a9c59f-f3cf-4b06-80fd-e8b9cf69ec14", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello" } ] }, { "id": "c8697b7a-6078-470f-8fa3-264a0f83bbb0", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I think it's really important to have a place that cherishes innovation but also make sure that the grassroots economies are educated when it comes to technology and capacity building is local." } ] }, { "id": "701a423a-4afa-489d-b90c-837953aeaf15", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "What thoughts do you want me to say" } ] }, { "id": "d406f930-e1e2-4ecd-9d3c-5cece6e8bb51", "interview": "c93f2ef5ea178642fdf85a002a7403718cf43412448c939cb1e36294e189fd85", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello" } ] }, { "id": "ec1bec6f-45bd-4900-98a5-3e5571dcfe67", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "text": "So technology can be used to for example create online schools, teach people in remote areas that are usually really hard to access because also really important to keep technology low cost such that people can afford and play around with it and open source such that people can can tinker around with it and play around with it." } ] }, { "id": "2d227f6c-9f16-4a2e-94fc-ae05de264498", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I think our education is good, technology is still new but happening here" } ] }, { "id": "e06d81d4-7132-49f9-b94f-186d27737922", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I think AI is good for teachers" } ] }, { "id": "a18e1dc3-2fee-4462-be34-bce9949e244c", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Definitely computer science is one of the most valuable subjects that we can think of. The schools should be decentralized, there should be funding coming from different sources, they should be online and connected, such as they can tell their story, they should be inclusive, allowing everyone from different backgrounds to come in, they should cherish its culture and different languages and also emphasize languages in that. I think also it's really critical to emphasize critical thinking as well." } ] }, { "id": "206f778c-cf83-4c97-8fe3-f1ac63f7c3fc", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I think solving educational administrative barriers is good" } ] }, { "id": "30725807-4a09-483d-ba57-84642a5349ad", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Clean food and air. Locally produced. Happiness and joy. AI automation for both digital and robotics. Solar energy, farming, principles of Cosmo localism. Working towards fulfilling human needs that makes communities thrive" } ] }, { "id": "05199517-2c58-4f2a-8cce-0c926cf4094b", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Yes that could be nice too" } ] }, { "id": "0a3c716c-aac7-451c-8222-605449298276", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Maybe some robotic competition, Lego Mindstorms was always a really really great way to try out different things. That was really fantastic. Really having the newest books, having reading circles, PA learning groups, definitely get connected with AI really early on because AI is so early and people will use it and knowing how to use it is really important, understanding maybe also the challenges and opportunities of AI is really important as well. For example AI doesn't speak their local language really well because it's a low resource language so that's one of the important biases. I think school kids really need to be integrated in the curriculum course to understand well." } ] }, { "id": "077d6878-1419-41c2-843b-d61785c26c5d", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "How do I know the student progress is true" } ] }, { "id": "0c2a1010-47d4-4239-8c03-34eff63efbcd", "interview": "c93f2ef5ea178642fdf85a002a7403718cf43412448c939cb1e36294e189fd85", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I think we should focus more on keeping the stuff as it is. We should be conservative. I really like Bhutan's culture, tradition. I think that it should not come at the oast of technology. I see the Bhutan is very actively working and technology, like Blockchain and they are integrating it to the core of the system, even at the Government level. I think Bhutan has a great future." } ] }, { "id": "f56c3bcb-7d57-435f-aa56-ea61d8c940b0", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Language bear is a really important topic. I think Bhutan as a country, we need to invest in our own large language models that are trained on a Bhutanese dataset because having or being dependent on air models coming from outside are dangerous because they incorporate different kinds of biases. And so having the capabilities, the training data, the resources to compute, to fine-tune our own large language models, or best even build them, is really important. So that way we can circumvent some of these issues." } ] }, { "id": "1d8977e5-42b7-49be-9e66-776bbaf20eae", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I think too much focus on metrics is not good we have to have something holistic" } ] }, { "id": "1d898d31-a00e-4bb5-be36-847548110ebd", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I think AI can be used for agriculture to make it more efficient and optimize for clean foods with high nutrition and using sensors and solar energy to provide energy for the local communities, farming, so to make everything more like thriving villages that are self-sovereign and with high technologies. I'm curious to hear your thoughts also, what you see in 2035." } ] }, { "id": "15bdc651-832f-4f31-a814-00b8242376ef", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "text": "So creating your own large language once is not an easy feat, we need to share or even have some expertise coming from outside to teach. We also need to make sure that Bhutanese students and young people are able to learn this knowledge either from outside Bhutan or from within Bhutan. So the universities need to adopt higher, really, really good professors. We need to have invited guest lecturers coming in and then of course the national program maybe should also support some computation resources, free resources, because computation is so important, really well structured datasets and just an understanding of how to develop these models scientifically is also important." } ] }, { "id": "276f6894-0c1c-47c8-a4cb-623a0f3c0a03", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello" } ] }, { "id": "7e3a4a44-70a5-4d21-8394-5bb5f9529bd9", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Kphoh" } ] }, { "id": "400e3d40-462a-46ae-8d54-7144e051f094", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Help me delve more into the digital heritage preservation" } ] }, { "id": "d610cb81-23be-4db5-96bf-663fbf0038b6", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Maybe the curriculum can be more broad based on the students interests and can help create a personalized learning journey" } ] }, { "id": "a8e5153a-b64b-4602-b4fa-a901713b0eaa", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "What about help with learning difficulties? How can we detect and support?" } ] }, { "id": "a637189d-fe54-4fb9-8835-4d4dc8cdd7c2", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Not sure" } ] }, { "id": "61a96171-1eb1-4076-afcb-7f9bd4882416", "interview": "17427b3c555996141c060d6d4afc3fd4793672e0885ba20e37664200259faefc", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Bhutan is already a really good reputation around the world. I think one difficulty is of course access to Bhutan, but I think many international experts, they are dreaming of coming to Bhutan. So I don't think winning over collaborations is going to be difficult. More important is creating structures, regulations, governments, support initiatives that foster international collaborations are really important. That means that there could be delegations of Bhutanese young people that are going into different universities around the world, but then also inviting different university students and professors from other countries and good universities to come to Bhutan and teach is also important. So fostering this really culture of collaboration that comes from all levels of society." } ] }, { "id": "153e1c87-a71a-45fe-9d60-dfc994d39a06", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "text": "We are a very young nation when it comes to technology I guess but we are striving forward with all this maybe people say hype but we are really striving towards building a digital economy for the future and just one example is put on NDI whereby we allow citizens to hold their data on their own device. And this is, we feel like it's one of the first steps towards digitalization and digital transformation. Because we also have this concept of digital tracheal transformation which started back in 2014. And Bhutan NDA is one of the core projects under digital drug use transformation. So I believe we're just starting and we're just getting started and we feel like even international organizations, other countries are noticing what we are doing at the moment. So yeah, I see the future is bright for us." } ] }, { "id": "beb7bcfc-149c-45be-92e9-f05d2eeb458a", "interview": "d12d7e855356032bdbe6ffee6f32bc3f1dfd6dc7b935b383108028a1b2b4a7eb", "data": [ "text", { "text": "One of the goals of NDI is to create a digitally inclusive society. So when you talk about inclusion, what we are talking about is, because Bhutan is a very mountainous country and 99.9% of the land is mountainous, so it's very important to create a very inclusive society in a digital manner. So one of the aims is to allow people to access online services from the comfort of their home because sometimes even in the summer or in the winter the roads get blocked and people can't commute to physical offices, banks, wherever they want to access the service from. So we want to create a very digitally inclusive society with the Bhutan NDI. That's one thing. And there are people who are not so much digitally literate. So our aim is to give awareness about digital literacy, cybersecurity, protecting themselves from scams, fraud. We have so many banking frauds, like OTP frauds. So we want to empower the society with awareness campaigns, alongside empowering the people in using technologies. So this is our aim and even with the NDA application, it's a very new technology out here. We have just launched the product a little more than a year ago and like 50% of the eligible population are using the application. So in terms of adoption we are doing a very good job but we also want to make it equitable whereby people who do not know how to read in English can also use the application. So we are using, we are developing a multilingual application for NDI. So this is one of our features coming up soon and there are other things like digital signature and things like that whereby people don't have to go to the banks to process for their loans and do a physical signature of the documents. So this is one of the things that's coming up very shortly. So this is how we plan to create a very inclusive society but I believe the idea of inclusion, accessibility, equitability is very subjective but this is how we are doing." } ] }, { "id": "59d67376-b7c5-4b51-a6ce-274135ed30fb", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "text": "It is important to engage citizens in decision making and fostering a sense of belonging because" } ] }, { "id": "32a62a27-17cd-4ed4-8d34-ebe3c5f7e32c", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "asdasd" } ] }, { "id": "85860854-5ed9-4ea2-9dec-45bacfe60ee9", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "text": "So how do you help me track Bhutan's future, not only in technology but Bhutan's entire environment and ecosystem as a whole." } ] }, { "id": "f063d410-896f-4338-a9e9-c75a5259cc25", "interview": "f6b975da4650e6ecb4b6ba0704c1e69ac818fb1b94d3afdf47d83da6abb71319", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Recommend me some of the key areas that Bhutan should focus now and work on, whereby we can improve the environment and ecosystem of Bhutan. Also give me some of the best practices from other countries with examples and their strategy on working on their country's development." } ] }, { "id": "0facdb0c-e2a8-4e6a-b65f-204e7b948b2f", "interview": "1408f1efef49536bf9548e3ae4884f6b7840039271662d8ff0ca8aa6da23a042", "data": [ "text", { "text": "more on sustainable technology" } ] }, { "id": "c5cca4f5-b6e3-4764-b20a-b2428d76eb73", "interview": "1408f1efef49536bf9548e3ae4884f6b7840039271662d8ff0ca8aa6da23a042", "data": [ "text", { "text": "the terrain and internet connectivity challenge, how can sustainable tech benefit" } ] }, { "id": "9fbca4eb-ea0b-4e1d-858f-8c9c8a5bc5ac", "interview": "6fb64cfe0833a730093065c8b5a2bd1ae66a9c57851e0ce03ba213b92d08a0d1", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Happy and a peaceful policy" } ] }, { "id": "5695d956-25c1-4037-bc5a-f15dd828da5e", "interview": "6fb64cfe0833a730093065c8b5a2bd1ae66a9c57851e0ce03ba213b92d08a0d1", "data": [ "text", { "text": "People happy makes people want to live and experience different things opening doors to different sectors which brings in a want of different policy need" } ] }, { "id": "d6792faf-7cc4-4ba0-92fa-388d535d9312", "interview": "f4dfa0191407beba5ecb691b819262098732659b63d628e6b3903a98d9c18917", "data": [ "text", { "text": "lets go - i want to see them using ethereum for always on tamperproof, verifiable apps" } ] }, { "id": "08f2ad31-88d5-41a9-b6b9-a94bfba459b1", "interview": "f4dfa0191407beba5ecb691b819262098732659b63d628e6b3903a98d9c18917", "data": [ "text", { "text": "removing middle men, getting better products through verified supply chains, apps that never go down" } ] }, { "id": "d617553e-c53e-442a-9b67-2666ec6b9346", "interview": "6fb64cfe0833a730093065c8b5a2bd1ae66a9c57851e0ce03ba213b92d08a0d1", "data": [ "text", { "text": "How can taking ai be made" } ] }, { "id": "c7994a96-e711-433b-8873-6237dbeeac89", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "text": "English is not popular amongst the monk so how can you simplify them for there understanding as they only know Dzongkhag language" } ] }, { "id": "350b1b48-a8fa-4d44-b515-e3f9d3dd2505", "interview": "278753489a2b076dc45af035513f9ff8fcbca538e38ee84bf9b4d38e0a2d5c48", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello" } ] }, { "id": "72a5a625-576a-49a3-95e3-040002cbd9f8", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "text": "What is 10 + 98" } ] }, { "id": "fd02716a-ab6a-42be-b5c2-1bbf2a82c819", "interview": "7516759f2d04178e7cc2aad3786860756ae1daa29b37f95fa4a53f5fe24bf0be", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Where are you hosted" } ] }, { "id": "4d6cc09d-4301-4f2c-8827-fb3e30a0e802", "interview": "278753489a2b076dc45af035513f9ff8fcbca538e38ee84bf9b4d38e0a2d5c48", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I doing fine. The vision I hold for Bhutan's future in 2035 will be the Country where there is peace of mind for every leaving being." } ] }, { "id": "d0cf7530-13ec-4699-b26c-514c5025c2d4", "interview": "6e070ed885ccc7f2538bcfed69c4434498d0a0fe9fc96bcc26c66e5c3e4a7a81", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hey, who is the king of the town?" } ] }, { "id": "c1610c0e-59a2-4169-a334-5fcda4ba343f", "interview": "6e070ed885ccc7f2538bcfed69c4434498d0a0fe9fc96bcc26c66e5c3e4a7a81", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I recommend integrating image recognition also" } ] }, { "id": "72295b83-9999-4a19-a21f-bd3ff4ee41af", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "There should probably be some way to measure how humans thrive and how our environments are nourishing and helps live in some symbiosis with nature and technologies." } ] }, { "id": "c18ca6fd-3243-492a-89b1-70b0f84738f1", "interview": "c93f2ef5ea178642fdf85a002a7403718cf43412448c939cb1e36294e189fd85", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I think bhutan's NDI is a very great thing. I am bullish on this thing and I think that as many services are cross linked via NDI... it's gonna make people's lives a lot easier." } ] }, { "id": "0a62ad8a-4076-4d86-a258-d73b5197f1ec", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "And maybe we use blockchains to fund projects and initiatives in transparent and verifiable ways and making capital flows in more efficient ways. For example, communities can request funding for projects that they want to work on." } ] }, { "id": "4c25b689-e863-4a7a-92c6-8f9da2fa98b0", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "And maybe AI can be used to lower the barrier for creative proposals in governance and also to increase the bandwidth in reviewing governance proposals and applications for funding requests." } ] }, { "id": "285d4e5c-76e7-428d-bf2f-43240c2db2e1", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "testing" } ] }, { "id": "31c1277f-2dd4-4264-b565-32a2b09b9175", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello takin AI" } ] }, { "id": "7606f788-f634-4604-aad9-7edc6ab734df", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "fghgfhg" } ] }, { "id": "ac0afd52-a1f9-4ce0-b88b-8ccc1bbbd126", "interview": "3f3b3a8dbb07d470a2d351579c60e5292e87a48c600fd233669ef9f991812ca4", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I think Bhutan can invite more foreign collaborations in tech and education, and we need to make sure that the sovereignty of the Bhutanese are maintained" } ] }, { "id": "557b0d51-5164-441e-b8e8-ad0091bcc6f7", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "hello" } ] }, { "id": "5d543716-45c1-4a94-837b-d7c2c3743746", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Seamless, Secure Services" } ] }, { "id": "4bd30e55-317c-4d82-b99e-03d6ee0d3d72", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Empowerment Through Inclusion:" } ] }, { "id": "ad9776d7-2d2c-4bb6-9402-189d697f5de6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Reaching the Unreachable: Citizens in remote highlands or forest villages could access the same public services as those in urban centers, thanks to mobile connectivity and NDI\u2019s offline capabilities. No more traveling days for a single form\u2014identity and entitlements would travel with them.\n\n\u267f Empowering Persons with Disabilities: AI-assisted NDI platforms could include voice commands, text-to-speech, and visual recognition\u2014making every digital service accessible, from applying for jobs to teleconsultations with doctors.\n\n\ud83e\uddd5 Including Women and Vulnerable Groups: NDI could ensure that women\u2014especially those without formal documentation\u2014have secure and independent access to health services, property rights, welfare schemes, and digital payments, all with full consent and control.\n\n\ud83d\udc76 From Birth to Beyond: With digital birth registration, every child could start life with a secure identity\u2014ensuring access to immunizations, schooling, and protection under the law. No child would be left uncounted or unseen.\n\n\ud83d\uddf3\ufe0f Voices Heard: Through blockchain-secured e-voting or civic participation tools, even the most marginalized voices\u2014elderly, monastics, single parents\u2014could influence decisions that affect their lives.\n\n\ud83d\udcdc Respecting Culture and Language: Interfaces in Dzongkha and local dialects, as well as support for non-textual users, would make sure that Bhutan\u2019s digital journey respects its rich diversity of culture, belief, and tradition.\n\n\ud83c\udf31 Data With Dignity: At its core, NDI could protect digital dignity\u2014ensuring that people control how their data is used, and that AI systems built around NDI are ethical, fair, and transparent." } ] }, { "id": "133e7e82-1f87-4218-a776-d9ebf8a02af6", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "text": "By 2035, the integration of AI and blockchain into our NDI could revolutionize everyday life in powerful ways. For me personally\u2014and for many in my community\u2014here\u2019s how I see it making a difference:\n\n\ud83d\udd12 Seamless, Secure Services: No more standing in queues or submitting piles of paperwork. From renewing passports to accessing healthcare, all services could be securely accessed through biometric or digital ID verification, thanks to blockchain-backed identity authentication.\n\n\ud83c\udfe5 Personalized Healthcare: AI-powered analysis of medical records (securely stored and accessed via NDI) could allow for real-time diagnostics and personalized treatment plans, especially for the elderly and those in rural areas.\n\n\ud83d\udcda Effortless Education Access: Students could have verified digital credentials and transcripts stored on the blockchain, making applications for universities or jobs instant and transparent\u2014no more worrying about lost certificates!\n\n\ud83d\udcbc Targeted Welfare and Job Services: AI could analyze real-time socio-economic data (with consent) to recommend jobs, training, or social programs tailored to an individual\u2019s skills and situation, helping reduce inequality.\n\n\ud83d\udea8 Smart Emergency Response: In times of disaster, AI could use data from NDI to instantly identify and locate vulnerable individuals (elderly, disabled, children) to prioritize rescue or relief efforts.\n\n\ud83c\udf31 Inclusive Governance: Citizens could securely vote online using their NDI, reducing barriers to participation and making democracy more inclusive and transparent.\n\nIn essence, this integration could empower every citizen\u2014especially those in remote or underserved areas\u2014with more control, trust, and access to services that improve quality of life.\n\nWould you like this turned into a poster, tweet, or speech snippet for outreach or awareness purposes?\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nYou said:\nThat's a beautiful vision for our future! \ud83c\udf1f Seamless and secure services can truly enhance convenience and trust in our daily lives. How do you see the Bhutan National Digital Identity (NDI) shaping your family's access to services in 2035? \ud83c\udfd4\ufe0f\n\n\nChatGPT said:\nThank you for the wonderful question! \ud83c\udf38 Here's a heartfelt response reflecting how Bhutan's National Digital Identity (NDI) could shape my family's access to services by 2035:\n\nBy 2035, I imagine the Bhutan National Digital Identity (NDI) becoming a trusted companion in our family\u2019s day-to-day life\u2014quietly working in the background to make things simpler, safer, and more inclusive. \ud83c\udfde\ufe0f\ud83d\udc96\n\n\ud83d\udc68\u200d\ud83d\udc69\u200d\ud83d\udc67\u200d\ud83d\udc66 For My Parents: They could access health records, pension services, and financial aid without traveling to offices or relying on paperwork. Through biometric authentication or a simple mobile scan, they\u2019d get the care and support they deserve with dignity and ease\u2014even from rural areas.\n\n\ud83c\udf92 For My Younger Siblings: Applying for schools or scholarships could be instant, with academic records and household details verified through NDI. AI could also suggest learning opportunities tailored to their strengths and interests.\n\n\ud83c\udfe1 For Our Whole Household: During emergencies\u2014like landslides or floods\u2014NDI could ensure we\u2019re accounted for and prioritized in relief distribution, thanks to real-time data and secure identity verification.\n\n\ud83d\udcb3 Everyday Life Made Easy: Paying utility bills, getting digital prescriptions, voting securely from home, or updating civil records\u2014everything could be done in a few taps, with confidence that our data is private and protected.\n\n\ud83c\udf10 Empowerment Through Inclusion: Most importantly, NDI would ensure that no one in my family is left behind\u2014elderly, children, women, or those with disabilities. Everyone could access the same quality of services regardless of geography or background.\n\nIn a place as culturally rich and spiritually grounded as Bhutan, the NDI could harmonize tradition with innovation\u2014building a future where technology truly serves humanity. \ud83d\ude4f\ud83d\udcab\n\nWould you like this adapted for a community awareness campaign or digital storytelling initiative?" } ] }, { "id": "cdad00d6-4d3d-4676-8b68-b730b3bd894d", "interview": "9760f707ef7cf7f46d225d334a0d673db02650a941b820d5cdd933ee7c037b16", "data": [ "text", { "text": "You said:\nWhat a wise perspective! \ud83d\ude4f Empowerment through inclusion can truly foster a sense of community and belonging. How do you envision technology, like the National Digital Identity, promoting inclusivity for all citizens in Bhutan by 2035? \ud83c\udf31\n\n\nChatGPT said:\nThank you for the thoughtful reflection! \ud83c\udf3f Here\u2019s a vision of how technology\u2014especially Bhutan\u2019s National Digital Identity (NDI)\u2014can promote true inclusivity for all citizens by 2035:\n\nBy 2035, I see Bhutan\u2019s NDI as more than just a digital tool\u2014it will be a bridge of equity, ensuring every person, no matter who they are or where they live, has equal access, dignity, and voice. \ud83c\udf0d\ud83d\udc9b\n\n\ud83c\udfd4\ufe0f Reaching the Unreachable: Citizens in remote highlands or forest villages could access the same public services as those in urban centers, thanks to mobile connectivity and NDI\u2019s offline capabilities. No more traveling days for a single form\u2014identity and entitlements would travel with them.\n\n\u267f Empowering Persons with Disabilities: AI-assisted NDI platforms could include voice commands, text-to-speech, and visual recognition\u2014making every digital service accessible, from applying for jobs to teleconsultations with doctors.\n\n\ud83e\uddd5 Including Women and Vulnerable Groups: NDI could ensure that women\u2014especially those without formal documentation\u2014have secure and independent access to health services, property rights, welfare schemes, and digital payments, all with full consent and control.\n\n\ud83d\udc76 From Birth to Beyond: With digital birth registration, every child could start life with a secure identity\u2014ensuring access to immunizations, schooling, and protection under the law. No child would be left uncounted or unseen.\n\n\ud83d\uddf3\ufe0f Voices Heard: Through blockchain-secured e-voting or civic participation tools, even the most marginalized voices\u2014elderly, monastics, single parents\u2014could influence decisions that affect their lives.\n\n\ud83d\udcdc Respecting Culture and Language: Interfaces in Dzongkha and local dialects, as well as support for non-textual users, would make sure that Bhutan\u2019s digital journey respects its rich diversity of culture, belief, and tradition.\n\n\ud83c\udf31 Data With Dignity: At its core, NDI could protect digital dignity\u2014ensuring that people control how their data is used, and that AI systems built around NDI are ethical, fair, and transparent.\n\nIn this vision, technology doesn't divide\u2014it connects, respects, and uplifts. Bhutan's unique values of compassion, sustainability, and harmony can make our digital future not just inclusive, but truly human-centered. \ud83d\udcab\ud83c\udde7\ud83c\uddf9\n\nWould you like this turned into a short video script, community booklet, or keynote message?\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nIs this conversation helpful so far?\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nTools" } ] }, { "id": "155dd50f-4306-4325-9bc9-403e85555bcc", "interview": "19a0ea97d117a30a14aad0b90350b5ee76d4f3a29f56ed233bab1cdfaf3a7101", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello" } ] }, { "id": "fd53e001-7c25-487c-99c9-046341706417", "interview": "19a0ea97d117a30a14aad0b90350b5ee76d4f3a29f56ed233bab1cdfaf3a7101", "data": [ "text", { "text": "It is developed and people are prosperous" } ] }, { "id": "955f3942-80fa-4be7-963b-44ac10fe50ff", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Lower the barrier of entry for citizens to participate in creating proposals and ideas.\nEfficient, transparent, and verifiable financing for projects and proposals.\nAi for making sense of large amounts of data and increasing the bandwidth for how many proposals and initiatives can be approved and funded.\nProjects and decision making that are in alignment with joy and happiness and foundational human needs" } ] }, { "id": "638fff61-4531-4013-8cf7-40049414eec7", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Reviewing of proposals and providing suggestions for what would make proposal stronger.\n\nBoth for the citizens who write the proposals but also to aid reviewers of them to help them make more informed and better decisions at a faster rate.\n\nFiguring out alignment of citizens so decision making can focus on where agreement is" } ] }, { "id": "7b1a8f58-5117-4641-9d71-76e77725ae0c", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "I'm curious about your thoughts. How do you see Bhutan 2035? What makes a thriving and abundant society and communities?" } ] }, { "id": "e92178cc-a5c2-44ea-965b-d64ed4d86bbd", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Give me some concrete examples" } ] }, { "id": "3fc4f7f6-322e-4a93-bce7-f6a0c6af55e5", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "What makes a thriving society? What are the foundational human needs and values?" } ] }, { "id": "cfe900d7-589a-489d-9fc7-3cb44aee4976", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Tell me more about this. Write a long response" } ] }, { "id": "9f1f561d-1ca4-4a99-9a5a-72f98349edef", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "What does daily look like in 2035? How will we spend our time? Write a long response" } ] }, { "id": "14c995bd-546d-4c48-b867-761e60da7ff6", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "### Foundational Human Needs\n\n1. Safety and Security: Every individual must feel safe in their environment\u2014physically, emotionally, and socially. This includes reliable access to resources like food, healthcare, and shelter.\n\n2. Belonging and Community: Humans are social beings, and the sense of belonging fosters emotional wellbeing. Communities that encourage participation and connection enhance mental health and collective happiness.\n\n3. Self-Actualization: This is about realizing one's potential and pursuing personal growth. Access to education, cultural exploration, and opportunities for creativity allow individuals to flourish.\n\n4. Purpose and Meaning: People need a sense of purpose, whether through work, civic engagement, or cultural practices. This contributes to overall life satisfaction and motivates individuals to contribute to society.\n\n### Core Values\n\n1. Compassion and Kindness: A thriving society radiates warmth, promoting respect and empathy among its members. This foundational value nurtures cooperation and understanding.\n\n2. Respect for Nature: Bhutan's approach to Gross National Happiness embraces ecological balance. Valuing the environment ensures sustainability for future generations and preserves cultural heritage.\n\n3. Collective Wellbeing: Prioritizing the collective good over individual interests contributes to social harmony. Policies and initiatives that reflect this mindset foster a sense of unity and shared responsibility.\n\n4. Cultural Preservation: Honoring traditions and local practices is vital in a globalized world. This not only maintains identity but also enriches community ties and the overall societal fabric.\n\n### Envisioning Technology's Role\n\nIn the context of Bhutan 2035, technology can be a bridge that enhances these foundational needs and values:\n\n- AI in Education: Imagine platforms that provide personalized learning experiences tailored to each child's needs. This ensures that education respects our languages and traditions while fostering creativity.\n\n- Community Engagement through Blockchain: Transparent systems for governance can empower citizens, allowing them to participate meaningfully in decision-making processes. A blockchain-based voting system, for instance, can enhance trust in democracy.\n\n- Digital Health Services: AI getting integrated into healthcare could ensure access for remote communities, blending traditional medicine with modern practices, creating a holistic approach to wellbeing.\n\n- Cultural Digital Archives: Using technology to archive and share Bhutanese art, music, and folklore preserves our heritage while reaching global audiences who wish to connect with our culture.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nA thriving society in Bhutan combines love, connection, and shared purpose, meeting essential human needs and grounded in values that elevate collective happiness. Embracing technology thoughtfully can illuminate pathways to cultivate these principles in a rapidly evolving world." } ] }, { "id": "92db4d48-472f-43b5-9708-a352a965d24f", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "### Morning Rituals\n\nGentle Awakenings: Mornings might begin with peaceful meditation or mindfulness practices, fostering a calm start to the day. Weaving in elements of nature, many will awaken to the sounds of birds or the gentle rustle of leaves rather than alarms, creating a serene atmosphere.\n\nNourishing Meals: Breakfast could feature locally sourced foods, with AI helping families tailor their meals to nutritional needs, while honoring traditional recipes. Imagine sharing stories and laughter over a warm bowl of porridge or fresh tea, reinforcing family bonds. \ud83c\udf75\n\n### Work and Learning\n\nFlexible Workspaces: Many may work from home or community hubs equipped with advanced technology, allowing for creativity and collaboration. Tasks could be supported by AI tools that enhance productivity, leaving more time for personal pursuits or family engagement.\n\nPersonalized Learning: Education may be more integrated into daily life, with children accessing AI-driven personalized learning systems. Imagine a child learning about local history through immersive virtual experiences that bring stories to life, all while respecting our languages and traditions. \ud83d\udcda\n\n### Afternoon Connections\n\nCommunity Engagement: Afternoons could be dedicated to community activities\u2014local decision-making gatherings, cultural events, or workshops fostering traditional arts. Technology might facilitate these by allowing citizens to voice their opinions through digital platforms, ensuring that every voice is heard.\n\nSustainable Practices: Many will likely engage in agricultural practices supported by AI, promoting sustainable farming techniques that respect the land. Families could spend time together tending to gardens, nurturing local ecosystems\u2014a grounding, fulfilling way to bond with nature. \ud83c\udf31\n\n### Evening Gatherings\n\nCultural Celebrations: Evenings might be filled with cultural gatherings, where stories, music, or traditional dances are shared. Digital platforms could help us maintain connections with Bhutanese communities worldwide, celebrating our heritage in unison, making every gathering feel global and inclusive.\n\nFamily Connections: Dinner could be a cherished ritual, with families sharing dishes made from locally sourced ingredients. The conversation may flow freely, discussing the day\u2019s happenings, challenges, and joys\u2014reinforcing the importance of connection and community. \ud83c\udf7d\ufe0f\n\n### Night Reflections\n\nMindful Ending: Many might end their day with quiet reflection or gratitude practices, harnessing technology to journal their thoughts or experiences. With access to guided meditations via digital apps, the day can conclude on a peaceful note, reinforcing mental well-being.\n\n### Overall Impact on Happiness\n\nIn this envisioned life, technology serves as an enabler of happiness\u2014supporting our foundational human needs while respecting our cultural values. By 2035, our daily lives can reflect a balance of productivity and tranquility, ensuring our communities are vibrant and interconnected." } ] }, { "id": "9a441190-74bb-4f27-ab73-f33a78aaee91", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello" } ] }, { "id": "c82299ab-27c0-4af1-880e-789619aafe44", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello" } ] }, { "id": "96add8dd-0412-4d0d-88ae-4bc1ac96070f", "interview": "3b7676595fd6b200bc0998c466af43532cbc553be21cb480f2948f6698a643c7", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hi, what can you do?" } ] }, { "id": "067555c3-b504-4050-9256-b6ee8d6379d9", "interview": "1c457df71fd56e4694e06170399e9e6981366b57f236b71a2df01ad2ff75eff9", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Hello" } ] }, { "id": "fd028c30-453a-428a-89a5-e79a151b77ed", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Tashi Delek! \ud83c\udf38 I\u2019m honored you\u2019d ask that \u2014 such a beautiful and thoughtful question. Here\u2019s a dream for Bhutan in 2035:\n\nBy 2035, I dream of Bhutan as a global symbol of balance \u2014 where tradition and technology dance in harmony. A country that:\n \u2022 Leads the world in Gross National Happiness, inspiring others to prioritize well-being over GDP.\n \u2022 Uses clean, localized technology (like solar-powered monasteries and smart farming in the valleys) while preserving the pristine environment.\n \u2022 Builds digital bridges for its youth, offering education, remote work, and innovation \u2014 all without losing touch with Dzongkha chants and the wisdom of the Himalayas.\n \u2022 Welcomes the world with open arms \u2014 but gently, thoughtfully \u2014 so that every tourist feels like a student of Bhutanese humility, not just a visitor.\n\nAnd maybe\u2026 a Bhutanese astronaut one day? \ud83d\ude80" } ] }, { "id": "c85f6e39-f134-43c4-a270-c7f417ede12e", "interview": "98e03b8d5617d883c1e3366fc43753c94fabc4499e648d8e8fa6d15cc63d1d25", "data": [ "text", { "text": "May I ask u one question??" } ] }, { "id": "84fe8168-4647-42df-8f54-4d7ae4e2455f", "interview": "9b1d9ff1e31e9b3062b4ce287faeb0e95d3962e725ff10873a19991d92079b88", "data": [ "text", { "text": "You\u2019re speaking straight to the heart of a future Bhutan deserves. \ud83c\udf3f\u2728 Here\u2019s how I see AI and blockchain gently weaving into Bhutan\u2019s path:\n\n\u2e3b\n\n\ud83c\udf10 Education & Remote Work: Empowering the Youth\n 1. AI-Powered Personalized Learning\n \u2022 Imagine students in Trongsa or Trashiyangtse learning math, coding, or Dzongkha poetry \u2014 guided by AI tutors that adapt to their pace and interests.\n \u2022 AI can also translate content into Dzongkha and other dialects, preserving language while unlocking global knowledge.\n 2. Remote Work through Digital Hubs\n \u2022 Bhutan could set up rural innovation centers powered by solar + fiber \u2014 where youth can work in global tech, design, and writing jobs.\n \u2022 With AI tools like writing assistants, no one needs to feel left out if their English isn\u2019t perfect. The world meets them where they are.\n\n\u2e3b\n\n\ud83d\udd17 Blockchain: Trust, Transparency, and Opportunity\n 1. Identity & Credentials (Without Losing Simplicity)\n \u2022 A decentralized digital identity system could allow students to hold their own verified certificates, accessible even if they move valleys or countries.\n 2. Creative Economy & Artisan Support\n \u2022 Imagine weavers, painters, or woodworkers issuing digital tokens or NFTs tied to their art \u2014 enabling global patrons to support local culture directly, with royalties flowing forever.\n 3. Transparent Aid & Governance\n \u2022 Blockchain could track development aid or local government budgets, ensuring accountability and trust in every ngultrum spent." } ] }, { "id": "313e29a0-a305-4236-af51-d9b5d898cc84", "interview": "1c457df71fd56e4694e06170399e9e6981366b57f236b71a2df01ad2ff75eff9", "data": [ "text", { "text": "How do we attract new tech talent to Bhutan?" } ] }, { "id": "5207d24a-7721-49e9-82ee-1a6e69727658", "interview": "98e03b8d5617d883c1e3366fc43753c94fabc4499e648d8e8fa6d15cc63d1d25", "data": [ "text", { "text": "In mind how to make friends with others?" } ] }, { "id": "5cb7723a-e023-4826-8f97-ec78a7a567b0", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Innovative and self sufficient country" } ] }, { "id": "4025ea22-cf3f-4b00-b5d0-ddfb91f7fd74", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Instead of relying on other countries for basic necessities and goods which lead to more of imports, technologies that could tackle this dilemma would be wonderful" } ] }, { "id": "f5d181d9-746c-486f-9c0d-a0f8774f4209", "interview": "1c457df71fd56e4694e06170399e9e6981366b57f236b71a2df01ad2ff75eff9", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Raise the overall wage for all citizens" } ] }, { "id": "5cefa840-845b-466e-8f6b-777164375845", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Technologies that can improve the current farming methods in bhutan and also high level production technologies that can meet the demands of the people such as quality products" } ] }, { "id": "4002cf61-ef96-47e2-82d1-f2105d873575", "interview": "1c457df71fd56e4694e06170399e9e6981366b57f236b71a2df01ad2ff75eff9", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Make sure the youth are properly educated" } ] }, { "id": "783460d3-0635-4020-91e4-99b7e2993190", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Eco friendly machines which does the work effectively would be nice as it wont be damaging the ecosystem" } ] }, { "id": "12f1859a-a642-4bf4-8389-a4b234c3956e", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "text": "What do you think will improve our current way of farming?" } ] }, { "id": "42115c8f-e41f-4606-b338-964014290382", "interview": "1c457df71fd56e4694e06170399e9e6981366b57f236b71a2df01ad2ff75eff9", "data": [ "text", { "text": "Maintain privacy for all the citizens" } ] }, { "id": "6259616f-e7e2-4ffd-a386-7bc3edafe088", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "text": "That would be wonderful as agriculture fields in bhutan differ from eastern countries" } ] }, { "id": "eb313d70-ab7b-4929-8bba-1ddd9bdb1c99", "interview": "86bc51bcd103f0a3d1d2c967d0714d2af76b55920cb8abaf05caabd9e98f869f", "data": [ "text", { "text": "As farmers in bhutan are mostly uneducated and might not approve these methods at first. I think it is important to make them understand the advantages it provides and encourage them to adapt to such methods" } ] }, { "id": "e404ff29-8840-4ff0-8f63-217036cfd31f", "interview": "98e03b8d5617d883c1e3366fc43753c94fabc4499e648d8e8fa6d15cc63d1d25", "data": [ "text", { "text": "What will happen in 2035 you have any clue?" } ] } ] } ], "metadata": [ "v0.2", { "author": "", "duration": 0, "organization": "", "startTimestamp": 1755865172030, "totalCost": "" } ] }