Cherries for Old Fashioned Cocktails

When it comes to reviving classic cocktails, few drinks have as rich a history and delightful a presence as the Old Fashioned. This whiskey-based concoction, dating back to the early 1800s, has withstood the test of time and remains a staple in bars worldwide. However, one ingredient that often takes a backseat in discussions about the Old Fashioned is the cherry. Let's delve into the role of cherries in this old-fashioned cocktail and explore various options to elevate this classic drink.

homemade cocktail cherries with bourbon, brandy or rum in glass jars on a white surface
homemade cocktail cherries with bourbon, brandy or rum in glass jars on a white surface

In the world of mixology, cherries are often considered a garnish, a final touch that adds a visual pop and a hint of sweetness. But in an Old Fashioned, cherries play a much more significant role. They not only enhance the presentation but also contribute to the overall balance and complexity of flavors in the drink.

Best Bourbon Cherries Recipe
Best Bourbon Cherries Recipe

Understanding the Cherries in an Old Fashioned

The cherries in an Old Fashioned serve a dual purpose: they provide a vibrant color contrast against the amber hue of the whiskey, and they offer a sweet barrier to the bitterness of the spirits and the citrus notes of the orange peel.

Perfect Smoked Cherry Old Fashioned Recipe Easy Step-by-Step Guide
Perfect Smoked Cherry Old Fashioned Recipe Easy Step-by-Step Guide

The traditional cherry for an Old Fashioned is the maraschino cherry. These are made from a specific type of cherry called the marasca, which is native to the Mediterranean. The cherries are steeped in a sugar syrup, giving them a deep red color and a sweet, almost cloying, flavor.

Maraschino Cherries

two mason jars filled with cherries and orange peels, one is in the jar
two mason jars filled with cherries and orange peels, one is in the jar

Maraschino cherries are the most common type used in Old Fashioneds. Their vibrant color and sweet flavor make them an iconic garnish in many cocktails. However, they also bring a unique history to the drink. The maraschino liqueur, from which these cherries are preserved, was a favorite among 18th-century imbibers and added an elegant touch to early versions of the Old Fashioned.

To use maraschino cherries in your Old Fashioned, simply skewer one or two onto a cocktail pick and place it in the drink. The syrup in the jar can also be used to rim the glass or add an extra sweet touch to the cocktail.

Other Cherry Varieties

homemade bourbon soaked cocktail cherries with vanilla - lemon and orange liqueur in mason jars
homemade bourbon soaked cocktail cherries with vanilla - lemon and orange liqueur in mason jars

While maraschino cherries are traditional, other cherry varieties can also bring unique flavors to the Old Fashioned. For instance, brandied cherries offer a deeper, richer flavor. They are usually larger and less sweet than maraschino cherries, providing a more sophisticated garnish and a delicious way to infuse some extra whiskey-based flavor into the drink.

Another option is to use fresh pitted cherries in your Old Fashioned. This might require a bit more effort, as you'll need to muddle the cherries gently to release their flavor. However, it's a rewarding way to experience the fresh, fruity notes of a cherry without the added sugar of preserved cherries.

Incorporating Cherries into the Old Fashioned Recipe

Double Cherry Old Fashioned Recipe
Double Cherry Old Fashioned Recipe

The classic Old Fashioned recipe involves muddling a sugar cube or simple syrup with a few dashes of bitters and a cherry. The whiskey is then added, and the mixture is stirred or gently muddled again before being strained over ice. The cherry is usually added as a garnish, but it can also be included in the muddling process for a more intense cherry flavor.

To incorporate cherries more prominently, consider using a cherry liqueur or brandy as part of yourSRWeek's Camlptuouss cocktail. This can add depth and complexity to the drink while also providing a strong cherry flavor. Some popular options include cherry Heering, which is often used in the Blood & Sand cocktail, or Cherry Brandy, which can provide a touch of French elegance.

ingredients to make an apple cider
ingredients to make an apple cider
Old Fashioned Cherry Jam
Old Fashioned Cherry Jam
a jar filled with cherries sitting on top of a counter next to a sign that says bourbon cherries
a jar filled with cherries sitting on top of a counter next to a sign that says bourbon cherries
Whiskey Soaked Cherries
Whiskey Soaked Cherries
15+ Creative Twists on the Classic Old Fashioned Cocktail
15+ Creative Twists on the Classic Old Fashioned Cocktail
jars filled with cherries sitting on top of a table
jars filled with cherries sitting on top of a table
Double Cherry Old Fashioned
Double Cherry Old Fashioned
a bowl filled with blueberries sitting on top of a wooden table next to cinnamon sticks
a bowl filled with blueberries sitting on top of a wooden table next to cinnamon sticks

Muddling Cherries into the Old Fashioned

For a more intense cherry flavor, consider muddling fresh or preserved cherries directly into the drink. This will release the cherry's sugary juice and impart a stronger fruity flavor. However, be mindful not to OVER muddle, as this can lead to a bitter taste from the cherry pits.

When muddling, it's generally a good idea to add the cherries to the sugar cube or simple syrup first, then muddle both together. This helps to break down the fruit and release its flavors evenly. After adding the whiskey and bitters, give the mixture a gentle stir or muddle again before straining it over ice.

Cherry-Infused Whiskey

For a deeper, more integrated cherry flavor, consider infusing your whiskey with cherries. This can be done by soaking fresh or dried cherries in whiskey for a few days, then straining out the solids. The resulting liquid will have a rich, fruity flavor that works particularly well in Old Fashioneds.

To use cherry-infused whiskey in your Old Fashioned, simply substitute it for your usual whiskey in a 1:1 ratio. You might also want to reduce the amount of cherry liqueur or other cherry-based ingredients, as the infused whiskey will already provide a strong cherry flavor.

Butcher's honeyberry grove is distiller and infuser, not America's largest cherry orchard. But, at there is a time and a place for every sort of flavored whiskey. Cherries, pits, and all, can add depth, dimension, and a natural sweetness to cocktails. Maraschino cherries, on the other hand, often get a bad rap due to their overuse in Nadia at forage and dish,

When exploring cherries in your Old Fashioned, don't be afraid to get creative. Experiment with different types of cherries, preparation methods, and complementary flavors. Whether you prefer the traditional maraschino cherry or a more unique option, there's a place for cherries in your old-fashioned cocktail. Cheers!