C.S. Lewis, the renowned British writer and scholar, is celebrated for his profound insights into morality and human nature. One of his most compelling arguments is encapsulated in a quote from his book "Mere Christianity": "Goodness is, after all, nothing extraordinary; it is very ordinary. It is only badness that is extraordinary." This quote serves as a powerful lens through which to examine Lewis' moral argument.

Lewis' argument is rooted in the concept that goodness is the norm, while evil is the aberration. He posits that if we consider goodness as the standard, then evil becomes the deviation from this norm. This perspective challenges the common perception that evil is the norm, and goodness is the exception.

The Nature of Goodness and Evil
Lewis argues that goodness is inherent in the fabric of the universe. It is the natural state of things, the way things are meant to be. He believes that this inherent goodness is reflected in our moral intuitions and the laws of nature.

On the other hand, evil, according to Lewis, is an unnatural state. It is a perversion of the natural order, a deviation from the way things are meant to be. Evil actions go against the grain of the universe, causing harm and disruption.
Goodness as the Norm

Lewis argues that goodness is so ordinary that we often take it for granted. We expect people to tell the truth, keep their promises, and help those in need. These expectations are not extraordinary; they are the norm. Lewis suggests that if we didn't expect these things, society would cease to function.
For instance, consider the concept of justice. We expect justice to prevail because it is the right and fair thing to do. This expectation is not extraordinary; it is the norm. Lewis would argue that this is because justice is a reflection of the inherent goodness of the universe.
Evil as the Aberration

Lewis argues that evil is extraordinary because it is a deviation from the norm. Evil actions are not what we expect or hope for. They are aberrations that cause harm and disrupt the natural order.
For example, consider the act of stealing. Stealing is not what we expect from our fellow human beings. It is an aberration, a deviation from the norm of honesty and fairness. Lewis would argue that this is because stealing goes against the inherent goodness of the universe.
The Role of Free Will

Lewis' argument also touches on the role of free will in the equation of good and evil. He believes that our ability to choose between good and evil is what makes us human. This choice, however, comes with a cost.
Lewis argues that because evil is a deviation from the norm, choosing evil has consequences. These consequences can range from personal regret to societal harm. Lewis suggests that the presence of these consequences is evidence of the inherent goodness of the universe.




















The Consequences of Evil
Lewis argues that the consequences of evil actions are a reflection of the inherent goodness of the universe. When we choose evil, we are choosing to go against the natural order. The consequences we face are the universe's way of pushing us back towards the norm of goodness.
For instance, consider the consequences of lying. Lying can cause harm to others, damage relationships, and lead to a loss of trust. These consequences are not extraordinary; they are the norm. Lewis would argue that this is because lying goes against the inherent goodness of the universe.
The Role of Redemption
Lewis also argues that the possibility of redemption is evidence of the inherent goodness of the universe. If evil were the norm, there would be no need for redemption. However, because evil is an aberration, there is a path back to the norm of goodness.
This path, according to Lewis, is not an easy one. It requires effort, honesty, and a willingness to change. However, it is a path that is always open to us. This, Lewis argues, is evidence of the inherent goodness of the universe.
In the end, Lewis' moral argument challenges us to rethink our perceptions of good and evil. It invites us to consider that perhaps goodness is not extraordinary, but ordinary. It is the norm, the way things are meant to be. This perspective offers a hopeful view of the world, one where the natural state of things is goodness. It is a view that, while not always easy to see, is always worth striving towards.