2nd vs 3rd Outback: Battle of the Generations 3rd Gen Outback Shines? Top 3 Reasons

By Mississauga

When it comes to reliable, capable, and versatile SUVs, the Subaru Outback has consistently been a top contender. As we delve into the second and third generations of this popular vehicle, it becomes evident that each iteration brings significant improvements and unique features. This article aims to explore the key differences and similarities between the 2nd gen (2000-2007) and 3rd gen (2009-2017) Subaru Outback.

What Are The Best Years For The Subaru Outback
What Are The Best Years For The Subaru Outback

The Outback's charm lies in its seamless blend of car-like handling and SUV practicality. Both the 2nd and 3rd generations embody this philosophy, catering to an extensive range of driver preferences. However, the 3rd gen model introduces several enhancements that elevate the Outback experience.

Post pics of Your 2nd Gen Outback
Post pics of Your 2nd Gen Outback

Design and Build Quality

The 2nd gen Outback maintains the practical, boxy design that Subaru is known for. It offers ample space for passengers and cargo, making it an excellent choice for families or anyone seeking a versatile vehicle. However, the 3rd gen model introduces a more aerodynamic and refined design, with improvements in both aesthetics and functionality.

Lifting a Subaru Outback - Here are the advantages and disadvantages!
Lifting a Subaru Outback - Here are the advantages and disadvantages!

In terms of build quality, the 3rd gen Outback benefits from advancements in materials and engineering. It boasts increased rigidity, leading to improved handling, comfort, and safety.

Exterior Design

an suv with two kayaks on top is parked by the water
an suv with two kayaks on top is parked by the water

The 3rd gen model showcases a more streamlined and sporty exterior, with a revised front bumper and grille, as well as more sculpted wheel arches. The 2nd gen model, however, is more distinguishable as a traditionally boxy SUV, which some might prefer for its bold, utilitarian look.

The 3rd gen Outback also introduces new, more contemporary headlight and taillight designs, which feature larger, more prominent lights for improved visibility.

Interior Design and Comfort

An Off-Road 2020 Outback XT | Here's How You Can Build Yours
An Off-Road 2020 Outback XT | Here's How You Can Build Yours

The 3rd gen model provides a more premium feel in the cabin, thanks to improved materials and updated tech features. The interior layout is also more driver-focused, with a re-sculpted dashboard and improved ergonomics. In contrast, the 2nd gen model offers a more straightforward, utilitarian interior, which might be more appealing to those prioritizing functionality over frills.

Both generations offer spacious interiors, but the 3rd gen model introduces additional features such as available leather upholstery, a power-adjustable driver's seat, and a higher-quality premium audio system.

Performance and Capability

two different views of the same vehicle on each side of the image, one is blue and the other is green
two different views of the same vehicle on each side of the image, one is blue and the other is green

Under the hood, both the 2nd and 3rd gen Outbacks come equipped with Subaru's horizontally opposed (Boxer) engines, known for their low center of gravity, which enhances handling and stability. However, the 3rd gen model sees an improvement in power output and efficiency.

Subaru's Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive system comes standard across both generations, ensuring excellent traction and stability on diverse road conditions. Yet, the 3rd gen model improves upon this capability with its revised Continuously Variable Transmission (CVT), which offers smoother shifting and better performance.

Subaru Outback 2nd gen (1999-2004)
Subaru Outback 2nd gen (1999-2004)
200K-Mile Subaru Outback and Crosstrek Conquer Moab Trails to Prove You Don’t Need a Jeep
200K-Mile Subaru Outback and Crosstrek Conquer Moab Trails to Prove You Don’t Need a Jeep
Modified and Lifted Subaru Outback — Thirty Five Inch
Modified and Lifted Subaru Outback — Thirty Five Inch
Back in a 2nd gen... after 5 years! 01 H6 LL Bean
Back in a 2nd gen... after 5 years! 01 H6 LL Bean
Subaru Outback Vs. Forester | A Detailed Comparison!
Subaru Outback Vs. Forester | A Detailed Comparison!
4 Inch Lifted Subaru Outback Wilderness: The ADF Wildebeest
4 Inch Lifted Subaru Outback Wilderness: The ADF Wildebeest
an suv parked in front of a house with a police car on the back tire
an suv parked in front of a house with a police car on the back tire
Subaru Outback: 2 Strengths and 2 Weaknesses
Subaru Outback: 2 Strengths and 2 Weaknesses
Must-Read: The coolest Lifted Subaru Outback off-road project at Offroadium
Must-Read: The coolest Lifted Subaru Outback off-road project at Offroadium

Powertrain

The 2nd gen Outback is powered by a 2.5L H4 engine, generating around 165-175 horsepower, depending on the model year. The 3rd gen model, however, introduces a 2.5XT trim leveraging a more powerful 2.5L turbocharged H4 engine, pumping out 250 horsepower—an upgrade that significantly enhances acceleration and overall performance.

In terms of fuel efficiency, while the 2nd gen model is no slouch with an EPA-estimated 21-23 MPG city and 27-29 MPG highway, the 3rd gen model invests in improvements, boasting an EPA-estimated 25-26 MPG city and 30-33 MPG highway, depending on the trim level.

Capability and Handling

Both generations offer exceptional capability, thanks to Subaru's renowned symmetrical all-wheel-drive system. Yet, the 3rd gen model improves upon this with its revised CVT and an updated suspension, delivering more responsive handling and a more comfortable ride.

The 3rd gen Outback also introduces Subaru's X-MODE system, designed to enhance traction and control in challenging driving conditions, making light work of mud, snow, and gravel. While the 2nd gen model offers commendable capability, the added assistance provided by X-MODE in the 3rd gen model takes it to the next level.

Technology and Safety

The evolution in technology is perhaps the most marked difference between the 2nd and 3rd gen Outbacks. While the 2nd gen model offers an impressive range of features for its time, the 3rd gen model introduces advanced safety and convenience technologies that redefine the SUV experience.

Safety is notably prioritized in the 3rd gen Outback, thanks to Subaru's EyeSight Driver Assist Technology, which comes standard on all models. This suite of safety features includes adaptive cruise control, forward collision warning, lane keep assist, and lane change assist, among other advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS).

Infotainment and Connectivity

The 3rd gen Outback introduces an updated infotainment system with a larger, high-resolution touchscreen, compatible with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. This offers significant improvements in user experience and connectivity compared to the 2nd gen model's simpler, less intuitive system.

The 3rd gen model also introduces advanced voice recognition software, enabling advanced voice commands for a more seamless and intuitive driving experience.

Safety Features

The 3rd gen model, thanks to its EyeSight Driver Assist Technology, benefits from advanced safety features not available in the 2nd gen model. Moreover, the 3rd gen Outback received higher safety ratings from the IIHS and NHTSA, reflecting improvements in body structure, occupant protection, and crash avoidance technologies.

Ultimately, the choice between a 2nd gen and 3rd gen Subaru Outback depends on your priorities. If you value a more traditional, rugged design and straightforward features, the 2nd gen model might be your best bet. However, if you're seeking a more refined, tech-savvy SUV with advanced safety features and improved performance, the 3rd gen Outback is sure to impress. Regardless of your choice, you're bound to find a capable, practical, and engaging SUV that caters to your diverse needs.