Olivia Ideas

Aug 16, 2026 RAW
Article

Where Did "What in tarnation" Come From

The phrase "where did what in the sam hill come from" is an exclamation of puzzlement or disbelief that has been a part of American English for over a century. But where exactly did this unusual expression originate, and what does it mean?

THESE ARE ALL SAM'S QUOTES IM SOBBING
THESE ARE ALL SAM'S QUOTES IM SOBBING

To unravel the mystery behind this peculiar phrase, we need to delve into its historical context and explore various theories about its origins.

Video: Sam Hill Returns to Form in Les Orres - Pinkbike
Video: Sam Hill Returns to Form in Les Orres - Pinkbike

The Early Appearances of the Phrase

One of the earliest recorded instances of this phrase can be found in a 1916 issue of the Washington Post. In a column titled "The枚In and Out of the Washington," the author writes, " Where did what in the Sam Hill come from?" regarding a peculiar fashion trend. This suggests that the phrase was already in use and understood by the public by the early 20th century.

a man riding on the back of a bike down a dirt road next to trees
a man riding on the back of a bike down a dirt road next to trees

Around the same time, the phrase started to appear in other newspapers and magazines. For example, a 1919 issue of The Independent, a New York-based newspaper, features the phrase in a story about a baseball player's strange appearance on the field.

The Sam Hill Theory

Video: Behind the Scenes of Sam Hill's Historic EWS Title Win - Pinkbike
Video: Behind the Scenes of Sam Hill's Historic EWS Title Win - Pinkbike

One of the most popular theories about the origin of this phrase is that it's an exclamation related to Samuel "Sam" Hill, a 19th-century adventurer and civil engineer. Hill was known for his eccentricity and unconventional ideas, which some believe could have inspired the phrase. However, there's no concrete evidence to support this theory.

Moreover, Hill was not particularly well-known outside of the American Northwest, where he spent most of his life. It's unclear how his name would have gained widespread recognition and become associated with this phrase.

The Military Connection

No-Thrills Sam Hill Windrock Ripping - Video - Pinkbike
No-Thrills Sam Hill Windrock Ripping - Video - Pinkbike

Another theory suggests that the phrase originated in the military. Some believe that it was used by soldiers as a way to express disbelief or frustration. This explanation is backed by the fact that the phrase gained popularity during World War I, a time when military influence on popular culture was significant.

However, this theory also lacks concrete evidence. While it's certainly possible that soldiers used the phrase, there's no documented proof that they were the first to do so.

The Meaning Behind the Phrase

Windows + james Sunderland
Windows + james Sunderland

The meaning of "where did what in the sam hill come from" is quite straightforward. It's a way of expressing surprise or bewilderment in the face of something strange, unexpected, or inexplicable. The phrase essentially asks, "Where did this thing come from, and why is it so unusual or different?"

While the exact origin of the phrase might remain a mystery, its meaning and usage have been confirmed through its extensive use in American culture over the past century.

bonk
bonk
Spotted: Sam Hill's 27.5
Spotted: Sam Hill's 27.5
a man with his eyes closed and a dog's head in the middle of him
a man with his eyes closed and a dog's head in the middle of him
a collage of people making funny faces
a collage of people making funny faces
sammm
sammm
Sam
Sam
sam
sam

Usage in Pop Culture

The phrase has made its way into various aspects of popular culture. For instance, it was used in the title of a 2005 book by Art Buchwald, a humorist and journalist, who explored the origins of various idioms. The book is titled "How Much Is That Doggie in the Window? And Other Unexpected Anthems of American Life," which includes a chapter on the phrase in question.

Similarly, the phrase has been used in numerous movies, TV shows, and music lyrics, further cementing its place in American slang.

The Evolution of the Phrase

Over time, the phrase has evolved and adopted different variations. For example, some people might say "where in the sam hill" instead of "what in the sam hill." Others might use the more modern "where did this come from?" to express a similar sentiment.

Regardless of these variations, the core meaning of the phrase - expressing puzzlement or disbelief - remains the same.

In essence, the origins of "where did what in the sam hill come from" might remain shrouded in mystery, but its meaning and impact on American culture are undeniable. As we continue to use this phrase in our daily lives, we carry on a tradition that has been a part of our language for over a century.