"Cheryl's Trolley Dilemma Answer: Solved!"

By Ashley

The Trolley Problem is a classic ethical dilemma that has puzzled philosophers, ethicists, and laypeople alike for decades. It presents a scenario where one must choose between two morally challenging options, with no clear right or wrong answer. Cheryl's Trolley Problem, a variation of this dilemma, adds an interesting twist that has sparked much debate. Let's delve into the problem, Cheryl's dilemma, and explore various answers and interpretations.

Understanding the Original Trolley Problem

Before we dive into Cheryl's variation, it's essential to understand the original Trolley Problem. Imagine you see a runaway trolley moving toward five tied-up (or otherwise incapacitated) people lying on the tracks. You are standing next to a lever. If you pull the lever, the trolley will be redirected towards a side track, saving the five people, but killing one person who is tied up on that track. The dilemma is: should you pull the lever, leading to one person's death, or do nothing and let five people die?

Introducing Cheryl's Trolley Problem

Now, let's introduce Cheryl's Trolley Problem. Imagine the same scenario, but this time, you are not standing next to a lever. Instead, you are standing on a footbridge that spans the tracks, and you have a heavy object with you. If you drop the object onto the track below, it will fall in front of the trolley and stop it, saving the five people. However, the object is so heavy that it will kill Cheryl, who is standing on the track below the bridge, and is unable to move out of the way. The dilemma now is: should you drop the object, killing Cheryl, or do nothing and let the five people die?

an image of a crowd of people standing in front of a bus that says, the and button trolley problem
an image of a crowd of people standing in front of a bus that says, the and button trolley problem

Key Differences

  • Agency and Intent: In the original problem, you have no direct causal role in the outcome if you choose to do nothing. In Cheryl's problem, dropping the object is a direct action that leads to Cheryl's death.
  • Personal Sacrifice: The original problem does not involve personal sacrifice. In Cheryl's problem, you must decide whether to sacrifice Cheryl's life to save others.

Answers and Interpretations

Utilitarian Perspective

The utilitarian perspective prioritizes the greatest good for the greatest number. From this viewpoint, one should drop the object to save the five people, even if it means sacrificing Cheryl's life. This answer is based on the principle of the lesser evil, as it results in the fewest number of deaths.

Deontological Perspective

Deontological ethics focuses on duties and rules, rather than consequences. From this perspective, it is wrong to drop the object because it would be using Cheryl as a means to an end, violating her inherent worth and dignity. Therefore, one should not drop the object, even if it means letting the five people die.

Cheryl's Perspective

Some argue that we should consider Cheryl's perspective. If Cheryl knew about the situation and could make a decision, she might choose to sacrifice herself to save the five people. However, this interpretation is not without controversy, as it assumes that Cheryl would make this decision, which we cannot know for certain.

a drawing of a bus driving down the road with people standing on it and one person walking
a drawing of a bus driving down the road with people standing on it and one person walking

Final Thoughts

Cheryl's Trolley Problem adds a layer of complexity to the original dilemma, forcing us to confront issues of personal sacrifice, intent, and agency. There is no clear-cut answer, and the best we can do is engage in thoughtful reflection and debate. Ultimately, the value of Cheryl's Trolley Problem lies not in finding a definitive answer, but in the moral exploration and growth it encourages.

a bus driving down the road with people standing on it and another car behind it
a bus driving down the road with people standing on it and another car behind it
Sacrificial trolley problem
Sacrificial trolley problem
a black and white photo with an image of a bus on the road that says, the anti - trolley problem doing nothing will create
a black and white photo with an image of a bus on the road that says, the anti - trolley problem doing nothing will create
a drawing of people walking on a road with a bus in the background that says, which track do you like yourself to?
a drawing of people walking on a road with a bus in the background that says, which track do you like yourself to?
mami tomoe trolley problem
mami tomoe trolley problem
Live, Laugh, Pull The Lever—22 Trolley Problem Memes
Live, Laugh, Pull The Lever—22 Trolley Problem Memes
a drawing of a bus driving down a road with people walking around it and the words, i have the best musical taste in this trolley problem
a drawing of a bus driving down a road with people walking around it and the words, i have the best musical taste in this trolley problem
a drawing of a bus driving down a road with the words hitchhikers written on it
a drawing of a bus driving down a road with the words hitchhikers written on it
loser girl issues
loser girl issues
a cartoon depicting a train with people on it and a man in the background saying, but if diver the trolley now that would be fun to all the people it's already killed
a cartoon depicting a train with people on it and a man in the background saying, but if diver the trolley now that would be fun to all the people it's already killed
an image of a cartoon depicting how to use the trolly problem as a tool
an image of a cartoon depicting how to use the trolly problem as a tool
a poster with an image of a bus on the road and a man walking across it
a poster with an image of a bus on the road and a man walking across it
The Original Trolley Problem
The Original Trolley Problem
Don't Bring Me Trolley Problems, Bring Me Trolley Solutions
Don't Bring Me Trolley Problems, Bring Me Trolley Solutions
a drawing of a bus driving on a track with a man standing next to it
a drawing of a bus driving on a track with a man standing next to it
the poem is written in black and white with an image of two people walking down a road
the poem is written in black and white with an image of two people walking down a road
the existential trolley problem
the existential trolley problem
a cartoon drawing of a bus on a road with the caption saying, sisypus trolly problem
a cartoon drawing of a bus on a road with the caption saying, sisypus trolly problem
The Trolley Problem
The Trolley Problem
an article about how to use the trouser's trolly problem on twitter
an article about how to use the trouser's trolly problem on twitter
Absurd Trolley Problems
Absurd Trolley Problems
trolley problem
trolley problem
an image of a bus driving down the road with people around it and one person walking away
an image of a bus driving down the road with people around it and one person walking away
a drawing of people walking across a snow covered field with a bus in the background
a drawing of people walking across a snow covered field with a bus in the background

Related Articles