docs / articles / Reddit's Dish Soap Alternatives: 10 Common & Effective Substitutes

Reddit's Dish Soap Alternatives: 10 Common & Effective Substitutes

Nicole Jul 17, 2026 2026-07-17 06:07:06

Finding a suitable alternative to dish soap can be a daunting task, but it's not impossible. With the rise of eco-friendly and natural cleaning products, the market has evolved to cater to various needs. Reddit, with its vast community of users, is a treasure trove of suggestions and recommendations. Let's explore some of the popular alternatives to dish soap suggested by Reddit users.

DIY Dish Soap That Cuts ALL Grease
DIY Dish Soap That Cuts ALL Grease

Before we delve into the alternatives, it's crucial to understand why someone might want to switch from conventional dish soap. Common reasons include allergies, sensitivity to certain chemicals, environmental concerns, or simply preferring a more natural product.

The dish on dish soap: Approved, So-So, Not Recommended brands!
The dish on dish soap: Approved, So-So, Not Recommended brands!

Natural and Eco-Friendly Alternatives

Many Reddit users swear by natural and eco-friendly alternatives. These options not only clean effectively but also align with a more sustainable lifestyle.

How to Make a Natural and Effective Dish Soap - Earth Friendly Tips
How to Make a Natural and Effective Dish Soap - Earth Friendly Tips

One popular suggestion is using vinegar and baking soda as a dish soap substitute. Vinegar is a natural disinfectant and deodorizer, while baking soda is a mild abrasive that helps remove stuck-on food. Simply apply baking soda to your dishes, spray with vinegar, and scrub. Rinse thoroughly afterwards.

Castile Soap

Ultimately, this has been the most affordable and effective dish soap for us and we love that it’s n
Ultimately, this has been the most affordable and effective dish soap for us and we love that it’s n

Originating from the Mediterranean, castile soap is a vegetable-based soap made from plants like olive, coconut, or palm. It's versatile, gentle, and biodegradable, making it an excellent dish soap alternative. Dilute it with water and use it just like you would with conventional dish soap.

Reddit users recommend Dr. Bronner's Sal Suds, a plant-based, biodegradable cleaner that's tough on grease yet gentle on hands and the environment. It's a popular choice among eco-conscious consumers.

Liquid Dish Soap Refills

Best Fragrance-Free Dish Soaps & Safe Brushes
Best Fragrance-Free Dish Soaps & Safe Brushes

While not as natural, liquid dish soap refills are a more eco-friendly option than buying new plastic bottles each time. They reduce plastic waste and are convenient to use. The dish soaps themselves can be made from ingredients like coconut, aloe vera, or olive oil.

Homemade Dish Soap Recipes

For those who prefer a more personalized touch, homemade dish soap recipes are abundant on Reddit. They allow you to control the ingredients and customize the product to your specific needs.

Non-Toxic Dish Soap + Detergents | GIRLS WHO EAT
Non-Toxic Dish Soap + Detergents | GIRLS WHO EAT

One user shared a simple recipe using Fels-Naptha soap bar, washing soda (arm & hammer super washing soda), and water. Grate the soap bar, mix with washing soda, and add water to make a paste. This homemade dish soap is tough on grease yet gentle on hands.

Liquid Soap Base

DIY Solid Dishwashing Soap: How to Make a DIY Solid Dish Soap for Green Living
DIY Solid Dishwashing Soap: How to Make a DIY Solid Dish Soap for Green Living
20 Frugal Ways to Use Dawn Dish Soap
20 Frugal Ways to Use Dawn Dish Soap
Homemade Dish Soap
Homemade Dish Soap
Top 4 Non-Toxic Dishwasher Detergents
Top 4 Non-Toxic Dishwasher Detergents
The Last Thing You Should Always Do With An Empty Bottle of Dish Soap
The Last Thing You Should Always Do With An Empty Bottle of Dish Soap
39K views · 3.9K reactions | A natural alternative to Goo Gone exists and it’s already in your kitchen 🌿 Baking soda + olive oil + lemon essential oil removes sticky residue completely. Skip the lemon if you have  | Life Curating
39K views · 3.9K reactions | A natural alternative to Goo Gone exists and it’s already in your kitchen 🌿 Baking soda + olive oil + lemon essential oil removes sticky residue completely. Skip the lemon if you have | Life Curating
What To Do With Your Soap Scraps
What To Do With Your Soap Scraps
Can You Use Dish Soap in a Dishwasher
Can You Use Dish Soap in a Dishwasher
50 Ways to Use Dawn Dish Soap In Your Life
50 Ways to Use Dawn Dish Soap In Your Life

Using a liquid soap base, you can create your own dish soap with added essential oils for fragrance and cleaning properties. Add one part liquid soap base to four parts hot water, mix well, then add fragrance oil and mix again until fully dissolved.

Reddit users recommend using gentle, natural ingredients like coconut oil, olive oil, or castile soap as the base, and essential oils like lemon, tea tree, or eucalyptus for their cleaning properties and pleasant scent.

Dishwasher Powders

Homemade dishwasher powders are another popular alternative, especially for those with dishwashers. A simple recipe involves mixing baking soda, borax, and citrus zest or powdered essential oils.

Borax acts as a water softener, helping to clean dishes better. The recipe can be tailored to your specific needs, such as adding more borax for harder water or more citrus for a fresher scent.

Reddit users caution that while these alternatives work well for many, everyone's cleaning needs and preferences are different. It's essential to experiment and find what works best for you. Always remember to test any new cleaning product on a small area first to ensure it doesn't damage your dishes or surfaces.

Exploring different dish soap alternatives can be a journey of discovery, leading you to more environmentally friendly and potentially more economical choices. The Reddit community has kindly shared their experiences and insights, allowing others to benefit from their wisdom. So embrace the exploration, and who knows? You might just find your new favorite cleaning product.