Extended Warranty Car Reddit: Pros, Cons & Real-Life Experiences

Montreal Jul 09, 2026

Ever found yourself scrolling through Reddit, stumbled upon a thread about cars, and wondered about extended warranties? You're not alone. The car subreddits, particularly r/cars and r/askcarsales, are filled with discussions on these topics. Let's delve into the world of extended warranties, their pros, cons, and what Reddit users have to say about them.

Cars extended warranty
Cars extended warranty

Extended warranties, also known as vehicle service contracts, are plans that cover the cost of repairs or replacements for certain components of your car after the manufacturer's warranty expires. They're a hot topic on Reddit, with users sharing their experiences, asking for advice, and debating the value of these plans.

How to Find Reputable Reviews of Extended Car Warranties
How to Find Reputable Reviews of Extended Car Warranties

Understanding Extended Warranties

Before we dive into the Reddit discussions, let's understand what extended warranties are and what they cover.

Car Owner Reveals How People Can Get Out of Their Extended Car Warranties. – ‘It’s going to take that four grand off there.’
Car Owner Reveals How People Can Get Out of Their Extended Car Warranties. – ‘It’s going to take that four grand off there.’

Extended warranties typically cover major components like the engine, transmission, drivetrain, and sometimes even electrical systems. They can be purchased from the manufacturer, dealership, or third-party providers. However, they come at an additional cost, which is why they're a contentious topic among car owners.

Types of Extended Warranties

Understanding Extended Warranties: An Insider’s Guide  - Car Talk
Understanding Extended Warranties: An Insider’s Guide - Car Talk

There are two main types of extended warranties: exclusionary and inclusionary.

Exclusionary plans cover everything except what's specifically excluded, while inclusionary plans cover only what's specifically listed. Understanding these types is crucial as they can significantly impact what's covered under your plan.

Cost and Duration

How Much Does a Car Extended Warranty Cost?
How Much Does a Car Extended Warranty Cost?

The cost of an extended warranty varies depending on the vehicle's make, model, and mileage, as well as the duration and level of coverage. They can range from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars, with durations typically ranging from one to seven years or up to 125,000 miles.

Some plans may also require a deductible, which is the amount you pay out of pocket before the warranty coverage kicks in.

Reddit Discussions on Extended Warranties

Should You Buy Extended Warranty on Cars?
Should You Buy Extended Warranty on Cars?

Now that we've covered the basics let's see what Reddit users have to say about extended warranties.

One of the most common questions on Reddit is whether extended warranties are worth the cost. Users share their experiences, with some swearing by their warranties for saving them thousands in repair costs, while others argue that they're a waste of money.

Your Cars Extended Warranty Meme – What is It All About Plus Huge List
Your Cars Extended Warranty Meme – What is It All About Plus Huge List
5 reasons why every BMW driver needs Extended Warranty in 2022
5 reasons why every BMW driver needs Extended Warranty in 2022
Extended Warranty
Extended Warranty
The Benefits Of Investing In Automotive Extended Warranty Companies In 2023
The Benefits Of Investing In Automotive Extended Warranty Companies In 2023
two men standing next to each other in front of a row of parked cars on a parking lot
two men standing next to each other in front of a row of parked cars on a parking lot
How to Get the Best Price on an Extended Car Warranty | Edmunds
How to Get the Best Price on an Extended Car Warranty | Edmunds
5 Things you need to know about A Car Extended Warranty
5 Things you need to know about A Car Extended Warranty
CarBuyingTips.com Warns Consumers How to Avoid Used Car Extended Warranty Mailer Scams
CarBuyingTips.com Warns Consumers How to Avoid Used Car Extended Warranty Mailer Scams
Paid off car
Paid off car
Rental car company tries to charge customer $91 for extra day despite turning in car 10 minutes early: 'If I'm getting charged an extra day, I'm using it'
Rental car company tries to charge customer $91 for extra day despite turning in car 10 minutes early: 'If I'm getting charged an extra day, I'm using it'
the pricing sheet for an used car is shown in this screenshoter's image
the pricing sheet for an used car is shown in this screenshoter's image
Why Is Carvana APR So High? Inside Their Pricing Strategy
Why Is Carvana APR So High? Inside Their Pricing Strategy
Used Engine Warranty Claims: Why They Get Denied & How to Avoid It
Used Engine Warranty Claims: Why They Get Denied & How to Avoid It
Users complain that their Jeep displays endless pop-up ads every time they stop, and that they are constantly being pressured to sell extended warranties
Users complain that their Jeep displays endless pop-up ads every time they stop, and that they are constantly being pressured to sell extended warranties
swap done right
swap done right
'At this point I'm petty and angry': Rental company tries to charge guy for extra day, cue devastatingly dirty malicious compliance
'At this point I'm petty and angry': Rental company tries to charge guy for extra day, cue devastatingly dirty malicious compliance
Why stop at ‘limited’ when you can have a Lifetime Warranty?

Visit AutoCenters Nissan in Herculaneum today and check out our new Nissan lineup with Lifetime Warranty included. New Nissan, Marketplace Car Meme, Funny Car Warranty Memes
Why stop at ‘limited’ when you can have a Lifetime Warranty? Visit AutoCenters Nissan in Herculaneum today and check out our new Nissan lineup with Lifetime Warranty included. New Nissan, Marketplace Car Meme, Funny Car Warranty Memes
Testimonial
Testimonial
Rental Car Company Told This Customer She Needed To Take The Car In For An Oil Change. – ‘They insisted this was a normal practice.’
Rental Car Company Told This Customer She Needed To Take The Car In For An Oil Change. – ‘They insisted this was a normal practice.’

Pros of Extended Warranties

From the Reddit discussions, here are some pros of extended warranties:

  • Peace of mind: Knowing that you're covered in case of unexpected breakdowns can provide peace of mind, especially for high-mileage vehicles or those in harsh driving conditions.
  • Budgeting: Extended warranties can help you budget for repairs, as you'll know exactly what you'll pay in case of a breakdown.
  • Resale value: Some users argue that having an extended warranty can increase the resale value of their car.

Cons of Extended Warranties

Here are some cons of extended warranties, as discussed by Reddit users:

  • Cost: The upfront cost of an extended warranty can be high, and some users argue that it's better to save that money for future repairs.
  • Exclusions: Users often complain about exclusions in their warranties, such as wear and tear items or specific components.
  • Claim denials: Some users report difficulties in getting claims approved, leading to frustration and additional costs.

Tips from Reddit Users

Here are some tips from Reddit users when considering an extended warranty:

  • Read the fine print: Always thoroughly read the contract to understand what's covered and what's not.
  • Consider your driving habits: If you drive a lot or in harsh conditions, an extended warranty might be worth it.
  • Check your budget: Consider if you can afford the upfront cost and any deductibles.
  • Research the provider: Ensure the provider is reputable and has a good track record.

In the end, whether or not to get an extended warranty depends on your personal circumstances, driving habits, and budget. Reddit discussions can provide valuable insights, but they should not replace thorough research and careful consideration. So, the next time you're on Reddit, don't hesitate to join the conversation and share your thoughts on extended warranties. Who knows, you might help someone make an informed decision.