Is a BMW M5 a Good First Car? Performance, Value, and Practicality

The BMW M5 stands as a benchmark in performance sedans, but its suitability as a first car sparks debate—where sportiness meets practicality, is it truly the right choice for new drivers?

The BMW M5 delivers exhilarating performance with its powerful engine, responsive handling, and advanced chassis systems. Its M variant offers 600+ horsepower, transforming everyday driving into a dynamic experience. For enthusiasts seeking thrill behind the wheel, the M5 delivers unmatched engagement—ideal for those who value driving pleasure above all.

Owning a BMW M5 comes with significant financial considerations. Higher purchase price, elevated insurance premiums, and premium maintenance costs impact long-term ownership. While BMW’s reliability has improved, depreciation rates are steep for luxury performance cars, making total cost of ownership a key factor for first-time buyers balancing passion and practicality.

Though engineered for sport, the M5 offers surprisingly practical features like spacious seating, refined ride comfort, and modern tech that supports daily use. However, its aggressive stance, high clearance, and firm suspension may feel unwieldy in city traffic or tight parking. For those prioritizing comfort and usability over raw performance, a more balanced executive sedan might better serve everyday needs.

The BMW M5 excels as a driver’s car with exceptional performance but presents notable challenges as a first car due to expense, maintenance, and usability trade-offs. For passionate enthusiasts willing to accept higher costs and care demands, it remains a thrilling choice. However, cautious buyers should weigh lifestyle needs—performance lovers may embrace it, while those prioritizing practicality might consider alternatives. Ultimately, is the M5 a good first car? It depends on what matters most to you.

The BMW M5 has not followed a similar path, though it is unfair to single out this one model, or even BMW. Every car company has made larger and heavier models over the last 30 years. The new BMW M5's plug-in hybrid powertrain makes 717 horsepower and 738 lb-ft of torque.

All-wheel drive and rear-axle steering are standard. 0-60 mph takes 3.4 seconds and the M5's top speed is. BMW The 2025 BMW M5 starts from $120,675 including a $1,175 destination charge.

The Touring wagon, which I'll review next week, costs $2,000 more. That sounds like a lot, and it is. From the exceptional performance of the E39 M5 to the problematic early years, we'll examine the best and worst BMW M5 years, so you can make an informed decision and hit the road with confidence.

But first, let's start with the models that will leave you stranded. A first drive review of the all-new 2025 BMW M5 sedan. The plug-in-hybrid powertrain piles on the pounds, but the M5 is still a hoot to drive.

We drive the 2025 BMW M5 sedan, discovering what its new hybrid V. BMW M5 buyer's guide with tips on driving, features, new vs CPO options, and ownership costs to help you choose the right M5 BMW confidently. After 4,000 miles with the 2025 BMW M5 G90, here's what we learned-its hybrid power, ride comfort, tech strengths, and real.

See our expert review on the 2025 BMW M5 and where it ranks among other midsize sport sedans. Research the ratings, prices, pictures, MPG and more. Read our full 2025 BMW M5 review for pros, cons, pricing, and expert insights.

Our editors test drive over 200 vehicles a year to help car shoppers pick the right vehicle for them.