The Old Rugged Cross, a beloved Christian hymn, has been a source of comfort and inspiration for millions around the world. But who was the creative mind behind this timeless melody? This question has been a subject of debate among historians and music enthusiasts alike. Let's delve into the history of this iconic hymn and explore the various theories surrounding its authorship.

George Bennard: The Most Credible Claimant

George Bennard, an American evangelist and gospel songwriter, is widely regarded as the author of The Old Rugged Cross. Born in 1873, Bennard was a prolific songwriter, with over 2,000 songs to his credit. However, it was his 1913 composition, The Old Rugged Cross, that secured his place in musical history.
Bennard's claim to authorship is supported by several pieces of evidence. Firstly, he first performed the hymn in 1913, during a revival meeting in Michigan. Secondly, he included it in his 1915 songbook, "The Bible Song Book." Lastly, Bennard's daughter, Gladys, confirmed her father's authorship in a 1978 interview.

Other Claimants and Theories
Reverend Will L. Thompson

Reverend Will L. Thompson, a Baptist minister from Alabama, also laid claim to the hymn. He asserted that he wrote it in 1875, long before Bennard's 1913 performance. However, Thompson's claim lacks substantial evidence. He never published the hymn during his lifetime, and no manuscript or contemporary record supports his claim.
The African-American Spiritual Theory
Another theory suggests that The Old Rugged Cross is a reworked African-American spiritual. Some argue that Bennard, or another white songwriter, appropriated an existing spiritual melody and added new lyrics. However, this theory is not widely accepted due to the lack of a specific spiritual melody that matches The Old Rugged Cross.

Why The Old Rugged Cross Resonates
The Old Rugged Cross has stood the test of time, resonating with generations of Christians. Its enduring appeal can be attributed to its simple, yet profound, message of faith and perseverance. The hymn's melody, with its slow, steady rhythm, also contributes to its calming and reflective nature.
Moreover, the hymn's lyrics reflect the Christian belief in the power of the cross, a central tenet of the faith. The phrase "On a hill far away stood an old rugged cross, the emblem of suffering and shame," encapsulates the paradox of the cross - a symbol of both suffering and salvation.

Legacy and Influence
The Old Rugged Cross has been recorded by numerous artists, from Mahalia Jackson to Johnny Cash, testament to its enduring influence. It has been translated into many languages, ensuring its message reaches a global audience. The hymn's popularity has also inspired various adaptations, including a 1936 film of the same name.















In conclusion, while the authorship of The Old Rugged Cross remains a topic of debate, George Bennard's claim is the most credible. His hymn, with its powerful message and enduring melody, continues to inspire and comfort Christians around the world.