Avoid These NYC Neighborhoods: Worst Areas to Stay in the Big Apple

Amy Jul 20, 2026

When planning a visit or a move to New York City, it's essential to be aware of the safety statistics and the less accommodating neighborhoods. While the Big Apple offers vibrancy and a wealth of opportunities, not all areas are created equal. Here's a breakdown of some of the worst areas to stay in NYC, ensuring you can make informed decisions.

Where to Stay in New York City (Best Places & Areas, By a Local)
Where to Stay in New York City (Best Places & Areas, By a Local)

New York City's vastness and diversity can be both exhilarating and overwhelming. To make the city's sprawling landscape more manageable, we'll focus on two primary factors that contribute to a neighborhood's desirability: safety and community.

11 Moments That Prove Living In New York Is Actually The Worst
11 Moments That Prove Living In New York Is Actually The Worst

High Crime Rates and Safety Concerns

Safety is understandably a top priority for most people. Unfortunately, some NYC neighborhoods struggle with high crime rates, making them less appealing places to live or visit.

Where to stay in NYC Cheap: Area Guide Checklist
Where to stay in NYC Cheap: Area Guide Checklist

Before delving into specific areas, it's crucial to remember that crime can happen anywhere, and this list does not encapsulate the entire experience of living or visiting these neighborhoods. However, being aware of these areas can help you make informed decisions.

Brownsville, Brooklyn

NYC on a Budget: The Smart Way to Save Hundreds (2026 Guide)
NYC on a Budget: The Smart Way to Save Hundreds (2026 Guide)

Brownsville, located in eastern Brooklyn, consistently ranks as one of the most dangerous neighborhoods in NYC. With high rates of violent crime and property crime, this area's safety issues deter many prospective residents and visitors.

Brownsville has faced significant challenges due to poverty, unemployment, and a lack of amenities. While community efforts are underway to improve the neighborhood, the crime rates remain a concern. It's best to explore other Brooklyn neighborhoods if safety is a primary concern.

East St. Louis, Bronx

Worst Tourist Traps to Avoid in New York City
Worst Tourist Traps to Avoid in New York City

East St. Louis, situated in the South Bronx, is another neighborhood plagued by high crime rates. The area has struggled with poverty, drugs, and gang activity for years, making it a less desirable place to stay.

Like Brownsville, East St. Louis faces numerous challenges that contribute to its high crime rates. However, it's essential to recognize the resilient community efforts aiming to transform the neighborhood. If you must visit, stick to well-populated areas during the day and avoid the area at night.

Neighborhoods with Poor Community Resources

Where NOT to stay in New York City: My horrible, no good, very bad Hotel Pennsylvania experience! - But First, Joy
Where NOT to stay in New York City: My horrible, no good, very bad Hotel Pennsylvania experience! - But First, Joy

While safety is a crucial factor, the availability of community resources also influences the quality of life in NYC neighborhoods. Areas where resources are scarce or lacking can negatively impact residents' well-being and overall satisfaction with their living situation.

Keep in mind that this list doesn't encapsulate the entire experience of living or visiting these neighborhoods. Inadequate community resources don't necessarily mean there's no sense of community, and many neighborhoods continually work to improve their offerings.

Where to Stay in New York City According to a Local
Where to Stay in New York City According to a Local
New York - Untapped New York
New York - Untapped New York
NYC Living: The Good, the Bad, & Everything in Between
NYC Living: The Good, the Bad, & Everything in Between
12 Most Dangerous Neighborhoods in NYC | PropertyClub
12 Most Dangerous Neighborhoods in NYC | PropertyClub
two people crossing the street in the rain with an umbrella over their heads and buildings behind them
two people crossing the street in the rain with an umbrella over their heads and buildings behind them
🎟️ NYC tourists keep making this free museum mistake
🎟️ NYC tourists keep making this free museum mistake
the new york city bus is shown with text reading 4 biggest mistakes tourists make on the nyc subway that new york can't stand, according to locals
the new york city bus is shown with text reading 4 biggest mistakes tourists make on the nyc subway that new york can't stand, according to locals
New York Cities Weirdest Attractions
New York Cities Weirdest Attractions
20 New Yorkers Are Sharing The Negatives To Living In NYC And It's Eye-Opening For People Who Don't Live There But Want To — BuzzFeed
20 New Yorkers Are Sharing The Negatives To Living In NYC And It's Eye-Opening For People Who Don't Live There But Want To — BuzzFeed
new york city skyline with the words 6 tricks for surviving new york city when you're
new york city skyline with the words 6 tricks for surviving new york city when you're

Marble Hill, The Bronx

Marble Hill, a small neighborhood in the Bronx, lacks some basic amenities and resources compared to other NYC areas. The neighborhood has limited dining options, and its commercial strips are not as vibrant as those in other parts of the city.

Marble Hill is also one of the most accessible neighborhoods to Manhattan, thanks to the nearby Metro-North train station. However, residents who wish to stay within the Bronx might find it challenging to find essential resources and diversions without traveling outside the neighborhood.

Starrett City, Brooklyn

Starrett City, located in southeastern Brooklyn, is a large housing complex operated by the New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA). While it provides affordable housing to many families, the neighborhood faces challenges related to the absence of commercial development and recreational facilities.

The lack of nearby schools, stores, restaurants, and parks can make Starrett City feel isolated and disconnected from the broader NYC experience. Residents who work or have children in school may find it inconvenient to access these essential amenities.

In conclusion, New York City offers a diverse range of neighborhoods, each with its unique character and offerings. By being aware of the areas with high crime rates and poor community resources, you can make informed decisions about where to stay and visit in the city. As NYC continues to evolve, so do its neighborhoods, making it essential to stay updated on the latest developments in these areas. Safe travels!