Best Paper Mario Games Ranked: A Comprehensive List

The whimsical Paper Mario series, a beloved franchise within the Mario universe, has-treated us to a delightful blend of RPG elements, humor, and creative gameplay. If you're new to the series or just want to revisit the best, you might be wondering which games are must-plays. Here's an in-depth ranking of mainline Paper Mario games, focusing on their storytelling, gameplay, and overall impact. Let's dive in!

Quiz: How well can you remember the Paper Mario series?
Quiz: How well can you remember the Paper Mario series?

Before we start, note that each game offers a unique experience, and the 'best' one can depend on personal preferences. With that said, let's rank them based on a mix of critical reception, popularity, and overall impact.

paper mario: the origami king – Whole Heartily
paper mario: the origami king – Whole Heartily

1. Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door (2004)

The Thousand-Year Door, often considered the peak of the series, masterfully blends humor, engaging storytelling, and innovative gameplay. It's a fantastic sequel that improves upon the original in almost every way.

Ranking Every Paper Mario Game, From Worst to Best - The Escapist
Ranking Every Paper Mario Game, From Worst to Best - The Escapist

Its engaging narrative, filled with twists and turns, keeps players hooked until the very end. Plus, the introduction of partner mechanics adds depth to combat and encourages exploration.

Creative Battle System

paper mario the marvelous game is shown in this image
paper mario the marvelous game is shown in this image

The Thousand-Year Door's battle system, a creative evolution from the first game, involves collecting BP (Battle Points) to initiate actions. It adds a layer of strategy and breaks up the stale turn-based combat of traditional RPGs.

Moreover, partner attacks add a dynamic element. Each partner has unique abilities that can turn the tide of battle, making you think strategically about when and who to use.

alternately Beloved Storyline and Characters

Paper Mario (2000)
Paper Mario (2000)

The game's humor and wit are unmatched, showcased beautifully through its memorable dialogue and characters. Admittedly, some jokes may not land for everyone, but the game's heart and charm are undeniable.

From the ever-chattering Goombella to the goats Brick and Yoshi, each character brings a unique energy to the table. The relationships Mario forms with them give the storyline depth and emotional resonance.

2. Paper Mario (2000)

Paper Mario 64/TTYD is THE GOAT
Paper Mario 64/TTYD is THE GOAT

The Nintendo 64 classic that started it all, the original Paper Mario, delivers a charming adventure that introduced us to the series' unique aesthetic and witty humor. It set the foundation for the entire franchise, making it an essential play.

Its standard turn-based RPG combat, while simple compared to later entries, is still engaging. The paper world design and innovative use of environment interaction make it stand out even today.

New Paper Mario Secret Unveiled Over 10 Years After 3DS Release
New Paper Mario Secret Unveiled Over 10 Years After 3DS Release
All Paper Mario Games, Ranked
All Paper Mario Games, Ranked
Every Paper Mario Game, Ranked
Every Paper Mario Game, Ranked
an image of paper mario and his friends in front of a wall with lots of cartoon characters
an image of paper mario and his friends in front of a wall with lots of cartoon characters
an advertisement for paper mario the thousand - year book, featuring characters from different games
an advertisement for paper mario the thousand - year book, featuring characters from different games
Paper Mario: The Origami King Review -- The Legion of Stationary
Paper Mario: The Origami King Review -- The Legion of Stationary
several video game covers are displayed on a blue background with the words mario kart, paper mario and super mario
several video game covers are displayed on a blue background with the words mario kart, paper mario and super mario

Innovative Gameplay Mechanics

Paper Mario introduced us to the series' distinctive gameplay elements, like using environments (like chairs and podiums) as weapons or platforms. These mechanics make combat and exploration fresh and engaging.

Furthermore, its FP (FP) system, where you collect FP to perform special actions, added a level of strategy to battles. You had to plan when to use powerful moves, making fights more engaging than your average turn-based RPG.

Timeless Storytelling and Humor

The original Paper Mario's story, a classic save-the-princess tale, is timeless. However, it's the game's humor that truly shines. Witty dialogue, memorable characters, and creative use of(Item) references create an unforgettable adventure.

From the forgetful Merlow to the enigmatic Admiral Bobbery, Paper Mario's cast of characters is memorable, each bringing their unique charm to the table.

3. Paper Mario: The Origami King (2020)

Arriving on the Nintendo Switch, The Origami King brings the series into the modern era with open-world elements and a refreshingly different gameplay style. Its unique approach to storytelling and beautiful paper-craft aesthetic make it a worthy addition to the series.

The game's departure from the traditional RPG formula catches some off-guard, but those who embrace its new mechanics find a delightful, if not slightly abbreviated, adventure.

Fresh Combat Formula

The Origami King switches up the traditional turn-based combat, introducing a ring-based system. Players rotate and slide enemies around to create groups and take them out at once. It's a fun, strategic twist that, while not as deep as previous entries, offers a button-mashing good time.

Additionally, the game introduces stealth and platforming elements, adding variety and breaking up combat-heavy sections.

Magical World and whimsical Story

The Origami King's world, creased and collapsed by the Origami King, is visually stunning. Exploring the various re-folded environments is a joy, each providing hidden secrets and engaging puzzles.

The game's story, while lighter and more whimsical, is still charming and fun. Partner mechanics return, but this time your companions physical accompaniment you in the world, adding a layer of interactivity and humor.

4. Paper Mario: Sticker Star (2012)

Sticker Star, the first Paper Mario game for the Nintendo 3DS, took a divisive, minimalistic approach. It streamlined RPG elements and introduced sticker-based combat, which angered some fans but delighted others.

The game's exploration and puzzle-solving segments are fantastic, arguably the best in the series. Unfortunately, its lackluster story and sticker-based combat keep it from ranking higher.

Streamlined RPG Elements

Sticker Star simplifies RPG staples like leveling, experience, and healing items. While it makes the game more accessible, it also makes battles feel significantly less satisfying than in previous entries.

The new sticker combat system, while innovative, feels shallow compared to the evolution of gameplay in later entries. You stickickers to the battlefield to initiate actions, and the size and type of sticker determine the attack's strength and type.

Excellent Exploration and Puzzles

Where Sticker Star truly shines is in its exploration and puzzle-solving. The game's clever use of environment interaction and well-designed puzzles are addictively engaging. The sense of discovery and accomplishment is among the best in the series.

The World Map, a delightful return to top-down exploration, is a joy to navigate. It's filled with secrets, side-quests, and useful Battle Keys that add depth to your adventure.

5. Paper Mario: Color Splash (2016)

Marking the series' second appearance on the Wii U, Color Splash's biggest selling point is its visually striking world painted in vibrant colors. Unfortunately, its gameplay mechanics and storytelling let it down, keeping it at the bottom of our list.

The game'sitagelled as a 'postcard RPG,' but its shallow combat and lack of character development make it feel more like a postcard experience, beautiful but lacking in depth.

Visually Striking World

Color Splash's world, made up of living, interactive paintings, is breathtaking. The way environments react to your actions, bleeding color into the world, is an artistic marvel.

diseñado as a homage to the Paper Mario series, the game's visual style is simply gorgeous. It's just a shame the gameplay can't keep up with its looks.

Painting-Based Combat and Story

The game's painting mechanic, while interesting, feels gimmicky. You use colored cards to attack enemies and fill in outlook into the world, ultimately restoring color to the game's monochromatic landscape. This novelty, however, wears thin quickly.

Moreover, the story, while charming, feels disconnected from the rest of the series. It lacks the heart and humor that made previous entries shine, making Color Splash feel like a lesser Paper Mario.

In the end, every Paper Mario game offers a unique experience, filled with charm, humor, and engaging gameplay. Whether you're a veteran of the series or a newcomer, each entry provides unforgettable adventures in paper-craft worlds. So, grab your Mario cap and start exploring - the Mushroom Kingdom awaits!