Wuthering Heights Meets Twilight: A Gothic reference guide

Grace Aug 20, 2026

The literary influence of Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights on Stephenie Meyer's Twilight saga is undeniable, with many readers and literary critics pointing out striking similarities between the two works. Both novels are gothic romances that explore themes of love, obsession, and the supernatural, leading many to draw parallels between the two stories.

Heathcliff Wuthering Heights
Heathcliff Wuthering Heights

One of the most evident connections between Wuthering Heights and Twilight is the central love story between two star-crossed lovers who are divided by societal norms and personal demons. In Wuthering Heights, Catherine Earnshaw and Heathcliff cannot marry due to their social status, while in Twilight, Bella Swan and Edward Cullen are kept apart by their species—a human and a vampire.

a woman in a long black coat is walking up a hill with a castle in the background
a woman in a long black coat is walking up a hill with a castle in the background

The Connection between Catherine and Bella

Both Catherine Earnshaw in Wuthering Heights and Bella Swan in Twilight are strong-willed, independent heroines who challenge societal norms. They are both drawn to dark, brooding lovers—Heathcliff and Edward—who have a mysterious and dangerous past. Additionally, both Catherine and Bella are willing to risk everything, including their own lives, for their loves, displaying a level of devotion that verges on obsession.

a woman standing on top of a grass covered hillside under a cloudy sky at sunset
a woman standing on top of a grass covered hillside under a cloudy sky at sunset

However, while Catherine is ultimately indifferent to the suffering she causes to others in her pursuit of happiness, Bella is more selfless. She consistently puts Edward's safety above her own, even willing to give up her humanity to save him. This shows a growth and maturity that Catherine, despite her own troubled history, never quite achieves.

Catherine's Influence on Bella's Character

an image of people with different facial expressions on their faces and in the background are trees
an image of people with different facial expressions on their faces and in the background are trees

Stephanie Meyer has acknowledged the influence of Wuthering Heights on her own work, stating that Catherine's story inspired aspects of Bella's character. Both characters areorphans who grow up feeling like outcasts, and both have a deep-seated need for security and stability. However, while Catherine seems more content to destroy those around her than to find happiness herself, Bella's love story has a more hopeful and redemptive arc.

Bella's name itself is believed to be a reference to Wuthering Heights, as in the original novel, the character Isabella is a distant cousin of Catherine Earnshaw. Stephanie Meyer has confirmed this connection, stating that she chose the name Bella as a nod to the character from Wuthering Heights.

The Connection between Heathcliff and Edward

Wuthering Heights Art | Catherine and Heathcliff Spirits on the Moors | Emily Bronte Oil Painting | Book Lover Gift
Wuthering Heights Art | Catherine and Heathcliff Spirits on the Moors | Emily Bronte Oil Painting | Book Lover Gift

Like Heathcliff, Edward Cullen is a complex, tortured hero who has experienced unimaginable suffering. Both characters have been hardened by their pasts, making them suspicious of love and wary of trusting others. However, despite their initial aloofness, both characters are deeply devoted to their loves, Catherine and Bella, respectively.

Heathcliff's demonic possession by his love for Catherine is echoed in Edward's metaphorical "possession" of Bella. In both cases, the lovetriangle becomes a source of obsession and violence, leading to pain and destruction for all involved. However, while Wuthering Heights seems to wallow in this darkness, Twilight ultimately offers a redemptive resolution to the love story of Bella and Edward.

Other Influences and Differences

Twilight*Wuthering Heights
Twilight*Wuthering Heights

Beyond the central love story, both novels also share themes of the supernatural and the struggle between good and evil. While Wuthering Heights delves into the supernatural through its haunting atmosphere and questions of fate, Twilight pushes this further with its explicit supernatural elements—vampires, werewolves, and other mythical creatures.

Despite these shared themes and influences, Twilight diverges from Wuthering Heights in its optimistic outlook. Where Wuthering Heights seems determined to explore the darkness and destruction that love can cause, Twilight offers a more hopeful, romanticized view of love conquered, even in the face of adversity.

Wuthering Heights-  Revenge, Destruction, Deaths, Ghosts but happy ending
Wuthering Heights- Revenge, Destruction, Deaths, Ghosts but happy ending
Wallpaper, pfp
Wallpaper, pfp
~ For those who may need to translate the post:  One of Bella’s favorite books is Wuthering Heights  {#twilightsaga#eclipse#bellaswan#wutheringheights} Twilight Heights, Wuthering Heights Funny, Book Quotes Twilight, Stephanie Meyer Books, Twilight Book Quotes, Order Of Twilight Books, Books For Twilight Fans, Twilight Quotes Book, Twilight Saga Book Quotes
~ For those who may need to translate the post: One of Bella’s favorite books is Wuthering Heights {#twilightsaga#eclipse#bellaswan#wutheringheights} Twilight Heights, Wuthering Heights Funny, Book Quotes Twilight, Stephanie Meyer Books, Twilight Book Quotes, Order Of Twilight Books, Books For Twilight Fans, Twilight Quotes Book, Twilight Saga Book Quotes
a lone tree sitting on top of a hill under a cloudy sky with dark clouds
a lone tree sitting on top of a hill under a cloudy sky with dark clouds
Wuthering Heights (2011)
Wuthering Heights (2011)
a woman in a long dress walking through tall grass
a woman in a long dress walking through tall grass
a young woman with frizzy hair standing in front of trees and looking at the camera
a young woman with frizzy hair standing in front of trees and looking at the camera
twilight
twilight

The Influence of Gothic Literature on Both Novels

Both Wuthering Heights and Twilight draw heavily from Gothic literature traditions. They are filled with dark, atmospheric settings—Wuthering Heights' windswept moors and Twilight's foggy, rainy Washington state—and characters who struggle with their own dark natures and the forces that seem to haunt them. Both novels also feature a love story that is both passionate and forbidden, leading to tragedy and destruction.

However, while Wuthering Heights often seems to revel in the darkness of its story, Twilight endeavors to find light within that darkness. The latter offers a pop-Gothic twist on the traditional Gothic romance, with a greater emphasis on teen drama and melodrama alongside the darkness.

Themes of Love, Loss, and Redemption

Both novels explore complex themes of love, loss, and redemption. Wuthering Heights seems to suggest that love can be a destructive force, leading only to pain and suffering. However, Twilight ultimately offers a more comforting and reassuring message about the power of love to redeem and heal.

In Twilight, Bella's love for Edward not only saves him from his own self-loathing but also transforms him into a better, more empathetic person. This transformation mirrors Bella's own growth throughout the series, showing how love can be a force for good, capable of transcending even the most significant differences.

In the end, while both Wuthering Heights and Twilight are undeniably influenced by each other, they offer different perspectives on the themes of love, obsession, and the supernatural. While Wuthering Heights wallows in its darkness, Twilight ultimately offers a more hopeful, redemptive view of these themes. This difference reflects not only the literary influences on Meyer's work but also the changing societal attitudes towards love and romance over the past two centuries.