Embarking on the journey of building a Commander deck? You're in the right place. The Commander format, introduced by Wizards of the Coast, offers a unique, fun, and strategic Magic: The Gathering experience. At the heart of this format lies the Commander deck, a 100-card singleton deck led by a legendary creature. If you're seeking inspiration and guidance, Reddit's Commander community is a goldmine of knowledge and creativity. Let's dive into the world of Commander deck building, using Reddit as our compass.

Reddit, with its vast and active Magic: The Gathering community, is home to numerous subreddits dedicated to Commander. From r/EDH (Elder Dragon Highlander, the original name for Commander) to r/CommanderTips, these platforms bustle with deck ideas, strategies, and advice. But where do you start? This guide will walk you through the process, using Reddit as our template.

Understanding the Commander Format
The Commander format is unique, with its own set of rules and strategies. Before delving into deck building, it's crucial to understand these fundamentals.

At its core, Commander is a 1-vs-1 format, with each player commanding a 100-card singleton deck. The goal is to reduce your opponent's life total to 0, exile all of their permanents, or force them to draw a card when they can't. The legendary creature that leads your deck, your 'Commander', is a vital part of your strategy and serves as a symbol of your deck's theme and playstyle.
Singleton Format

The singleton rule in Commander means you can only have one copy of any card (except basic lands) in your deck. This encourages diversity and strategic planning, as you can't rely on drawing multiple copies of the same card.
To illustrate, consider a deck built around the legendary creature Atraxa, Praetors' Voice. In this deck, you wouldn't include multiple copies of cards that synergize with Atraxa's abilities. Instead, you'd focus on a variety of cards that work well with her, ensuring your deck remains dynamic and engaging.
Mulligans and Starting Life Total

In Commander, you start the game with a full hand and a life total of 40. If you're not satisfied with your opening hand, you can 'mulligan' it, shuffling your hand back into your library and drawing one fewer card. This rule is designed to balance the singleton format and prevent players from being stuck with subpar opening hands.
Reddit users often discuss the optimal number of mulligans and the best opening hands. For instance, a post on r/EDH might discuss whether it's better to keep a hand with a powerful early-game card or mulligan for a more explosive hand. Engaging in these discussions can help you refine your deck-building strategies.
Building Your Commander Deck

Now that you understand the basics of Commander, let's delve into the deck-building process. Reddit offers a wealth of resources, from pre-constructed deck lists to in-depth strategy guides.
When building a Commander deck, consider the following steps. Each of these steps corresponds to a common thread on Reddit, allowing you to learn from the experiences of fellow Commander players.




















Choosing Your Commander
Your Commander is the face of your deck and the centerpiece of your strategy. When choosing a Commander, consider the following:
- Do you enjoy playing as this character?
- What kind of deck does this character inspire?
- What are the deck's win conditions, and are they interesting and engaging?
Reddit is filled with discussions about Commander choices. For example, a post on r/EDH might compare two popular Commanders, such as Najeela, the Blade-Blossom and Tazri, Beacon of Unity, discussing their strengths, weaknesses, and playstyles.
Crafting Your Deck List
Once you've chosen your Commander, it's time to build your deck list. Here are some tips, backed by Reddit discussions:
- Focus on a theme or strategy that complements your Commander. This could be a color combination, a specific mechanic, or a unique playstyle.
- Include a balance of tutors, removal spells, and card draw to ensure a consistent and engaging game.
- Consider your deck's mana curve, aiming for a balance between early-game threats and late-game finishers.
Reddit users often share their deck lists, inviting feedback and discussion. For instance, a post on r/EDH might showcase a deck built around the Commander Yisan, the Wanderer Bard, with users offering suggestions and critiques.
Testing and Refining Your Deck
After building your deck, it's essential to test it and make refinements. Reddit is home to numerous Commander players eager to test and discuss decks.
Consider joining a local playgroup or participating in online games to test your deck. After each game, analyze what worked and what didn't. Did you draw too many lands? Did you lack removal spells? Did your deck's strategy falter under certain circumstances?
Reddit discussions can provide valuable insights into deck refinement. For example, a post on r/EDH might discuss the optimal number of tutors in a deck, with users sharing their experiences and offering advice.
In the vast world of Commander, Reddit serves as a beacon of knowledge and creativity. From understanding the format's rules to building and refining your deck, the Reddit Commander community offers a wealth of resources and insights. So, grab your cards, join the conversation, and let the games begin!