The origins of Cinderella, a timeless tale of rags to riches, can be traced back to ancient folklore, with some of the earliest versions dating as far back as the 9th century. Unlike the sugarcoated version we're familiar with today, these original stories didn't always have the Happily Ever After ending we've come to expect.

One of the earliest surviving versions is "YehApóssin," an ancient Chinese story from the 9th century. In this story, the protagonist is not Cinderella but a rabbit, and the ending is far from happy. The rabbit, after helping an old woman, is sentenced to death for causing a flood when it tries to escape from a trap. This grim ending is a stark contrast to the modern, feel-good versions we're accustomed to.

The French Version: "La Cendrillon" by Charles Perrault
The most familiar version of Cinderella today is likely the one popularized by Charles Perrault in his "Tales of Mother Goose" published in 1697. Unlike its ancient counterparts, this version introduced the Fairy Godmother and the iconic ball, significantly influencing the modern interpretation of the story.

Transformations and Time Limits
Perrault's version introduced the magical transformations that we now associate with Cinderella. The pumpkin carriage, mice turned into horses, and the gown that self-destructs at midnight are all innovations from this telling. However, these transformations aren't a symbol of endless fortune. Instead, they emphasize the fleeting nature of Cinderella's good luck, with the midnight deadline representing the transience of her magical blessings.

What Happens After Midnight?
While Perrault's version is responsible for popularizing the transformative elements, it doesn't delve into what happens after the magic fades. He leaves it to the reader's imagination, only mentioning that the Prince, seeing that Cinderella has fled, is "Not at all displeased at this." This ambiguity allows for various interpretations, with some endings more hopeful than others.
Brothers Grimm's "Aschenputtel"

The Brothers Grimm's "Aschenputtel," published in 1812, is another influential version of the Cinderella story. This version is darker than Perrault's, with a greater emphasis on the cruel treatment of Cinderella by her stepfamily.
The Role of the Birds
In this version, it's not a Fairy Godmother but a tree on Cinderella's mother's grave that comes to her aid, with birds from the tree assisting her. The birds aid Cinderella by pecking at the kernels of grain that her stepfamily has commanded her to separate, earning her the nickname "Aschenputtel," or "Ash-Cinder," as she cannot keep up with the task otherwise.

Death and Deception
The Brothers Grimm's version also introduces death as a plot element. When the Prince visits Cinderella's house, her stepsisters attempt to deceive him into believing they are the true belle of the ball. In their desperation, they cut off parts of their feet to fit into the glass slipper, only for it to ultimately end in their deaths. The stepsisters' demise serves as a cautionary tale, reinforcing the story's theme of karma and the consequences of one's actions.









While these original endings might not fit the contemporary idea of a fairytale, they lay the groundwork for the rich, complex, and often bittersweet narratives that follow Cinderella's story. They remind us that storytelling is a vital, evolving art form, one that has borne witness to centuries of human experience and change.