"Malls Closing in 2017: A List of Shuttered Shopping Centers"

By Mary

The year 2017 marked a significant shift in the retail landscape, with a wave of mall closures sweeping across the United States and beyond. This phenomenon, often referred to as the "retail apocalypse," was driven by a confluence of factors that forever changed the brick-and-mortar retail scene.

Key Players and Casualties

Some of the most prominent casualties of the 2017 mall closure trend included major retail chains like Sears, JCPenney, and Macy's. These once-thriving department stores announced numerous store closures, with many of them shuttering their locations in malls. For instance, Sears closed 350 stores in 2017, while Macy's and JCPenney combined closed over 200 locations each.

Malls Most Affected

Malls that were most affected by these closures were typically older, Class B and C properties located in secondary and tertiary markets. These malls often struggled to attract and retain tenants, as retailers sought out more profitable and accessible locations. According to a report by Green Street Advisors, the number of "dead malls" - those with vacancy rates of 40% or higher - increased by 20% between 2010 and 2017.

a closed shopping mall with a closed sign on the gate and no parking signs behind it
a closed shopping mall with a closed sign on the gate and no parking signs behind it

Driving Factors Behind Mall Closures

The 2017 mall closure trend was not a standalone event but rather a symptom of broader changes in the retail industry. Several factors contributed to this phenomenon:

  • E-commerce Growth: The rise of online shopping, led by giants like Amazon, drew customers away from physical stores and malls.
  • Changing Consumer Behavior: Shifts in consumer preferences, such as a growing demand for experiences over material possessions, also contributed to the decline of traditional malls.
  • Evolving Retail Landscape: The growth of off-price retailers, dollar stores, and other non-traditional formats further challenged the viability of many malls.
  • Overexpansion and Oversaturation: Many malls were built during the retail boom of the 1990s and 2000s, leading to an oversupply of retail space that could not be sustained.

Adapt or Die: Mall Transformations

In response to the 2017 mall closure trend, many mall owners and operators began exploring innovative strategies to adapt to the changing retail landscape. These efforts included:

  • Repurposing vacant retail space for alternative uses, such as offices, apartments, or entertainment venues.
  • Investing in experiential retail concepts, like food halls, event spaces, and unique retail offerings, to draw customers back to malls.
  • Embracing technology to enhance the shopping experience, such as implementing mobile ordering, augmented reality, and other digital innovations.

Some malls even underwent dramatic physical transformations, such as the redevelopment of the former Meadowlands Xanadu mall in New Jersey into the American Dream Meadowlands, a massive entertainment and retail complex.

an empty building with some windows and blinds on the side walk in front of it
an empty building with some windows and blinds on the side walk in front of it

Success Stories

Despite the challenges faced by many malls in 2017, some properties managed to thrive and even flourish. Successful malls typically shared several key characteristics, such as:

  • Prime locations in densely populated, affluent areas.
  • Diverse tenant mixes, including a strong anchor tenant and a mix of specialty retailers, restaurants, and entertainment options.
  • Regular reinvestment in property maintenance, renovations, and innovative amenities.

Examples of thriving malls include the Galleria in Houston, Texas, and the King of Prussia Mall in King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, which remained among the top-performing malls in the United States throughout the 2017 retail shakeup.

Looking Ahead: The Future of Malls

The 2017 mall closure trend served as a wake-up call for the retail industry, forcing property owners, retailers, and consumers alike to reevaluate the role of malls in the modern retail landscape. As the industry continues to evolve, it is clear that successful malls of the future will be those that can adapt, innovate, and offer customers compelling reasons to visit in person.

American Malls Are Closing: How Retail Changed (And I Did Too) — J's Everyday Fashion
American Malls Are Closing: How Retail Changed (And I Did Too) — J's Everyday Fashion

While the retail apocalypse may have claimed many victims in 2017, the story of malls is far from over. As the industry enters a new chapter, characterized by increased focus on experiential retail, digital integration, and creative reuse, the malls that can successfully navigate these changes will continue to play a vital role in the retail ecosystem.

Wall Street bank says a quarter of shopping malls will close in 5 years
Wall Street bank says a quarter of shopping malls will close in 5 years
an empty shopping mall with two people walking in front of the glass doors and on the wall
an empty shopping mall with two people walking in front of the glass doors and on the wall
Major retailer starts closing down sale in Drake Circus
Major retailer starts closing down sale in Drake Circus
The Real Reason So Many Mall Department Stores Are Closing - The List
The Real Reason So Many Mall Department Stores Are Closing - The List
an empty shopping mall with lights on the ceiling and people walking in the hallway behind them
an empty shopping mall with lights on the ceiling and people walking in the hallway behind them
a tree in the middle of a building
a tree in the middle of a building
High street chain launches 60% off closing down sales at three more branches ahead of 29 shops shutting – see full list
High street chain launches 60% off closing down sales at three more branches ahead of 29 shops shutting – see full list
Here's a List of Stores Closed on Thanksgiving This Year
Here's a List of Stores Closed on Thanksgiving This Year
an escalator in a shopping mall filled with people
an escalator in a shopping mall filled with people
people are walking around in the lobby of a shopping mall
people are walking around in the lobby of a shopping mall
four young women standing in front of a wall with purple lights on it and one wearing sunglasses
four young women standing in front of a wall with purple lights on it and one wearing sunglasses
Inside an Abandoned Shopping Mall With Everything Left Behind
Inside an Abandoned Shopping Mall With Everything Left Behind
Stores closings slash mall property values 15% in a year
Stores closings slash mall property values 15% in a year
people shopping in a clothing store with sale signs above the racks and clothes on display
people shopping in a clothing store with sale signs above the racks and clothes on display
Beloved Retail Giant Closing 7 Stores Before Memorial Day
Beloved Retail Giant Closing 7 Stores Before Memorial Day
an overhead view of people shopping in a mall
an overhead view of people shopping in a mall
25% of U.S. malls are expected to shut within 5 years. A new life won't be easy — CNBC
25% of U.S. malls are expected to shut within 5 years. A new life won't be easy — CNBC
the food court is empty and ready for customers to use
the food court is empty and ready for customers to use
there is a large movie theater with many pictures on the wall and in front of it
there is a large movie theater with many pictures on the wall and in front of it
H&M closes all its stores in South Africa after protests
H&M closes all its stores in South Africa after protests
people walking down an escalator in a shopping mall
people walking down an escalator in a shopping mall
Destroyed and Abandoned
Destroyed and Abandoned
people are walking through an indoor mall with escalators and tables on the ground
people are walking through an indoor mall with escalators and tables on the ground