Do you feel over ice and water shield? This phrase might seem like a riddle, but it's actually a question that's been sparking curiosity and conversation among homeowners, environmentalists, and even manufactures. It originates from the practice of adding a second layer of protection to ice and water shields used in roofing and wall construction. But why is this method gaining traction, and what does it mean for your home?

Let's delve into the world of ice and water shields, understanding their purpose, and why some experts suggest using an additional layer for enhanced protection.

The Role of Ice and Water Shields
Ice and water shields are a crucial part of modern roofing systems, particularly in colder climates. They are self-adhesive membranes that serve two key purposes: preventing water from infiltrating your home under the roofing or siding, and helping to manage ice dams that can cause significant water damage.

The shield's primary role is to act as a barrier, blocking water and ice, but it also aids in directing water away from the vulnerable areas of your roof and walls. This makes them an essential component in any roofing system, especially for those living in regions with heavy snowfall, ice dams, or frequent rainstorms.
Basic Installation of Ice and Water Shields

Traditionally, ice and water shields are installed along the eaves and rakes of a roof, as well as in valleys and around skylights and chimneys. They are typically applied in a strip, extending up the roof slope and overhang, providing a continuous barrier that water can't seep through.
Professional roofers ensure ice and water shields are installed correctly, following manufacturers' guidelines to optimize their waterproofing capabilities. However, the increasing realization is that these shields alone may not be enough to protect against severe weather conditions, leading to the question: do you feel over ice and water shield?
The ‘Feel Over’ Concept: A Second Layer of Protection

'Feel over' in this context refers to installing a second layer of ice and water shield membrane on top of the first. Instead of using one continuous strip, two overlapping strips are used, creating an additional safety net against water infiltration and ice dams. This practice has gained momentum due to several perceived benefits:
- Improved Waterproofing: The overlapping layer creates a second barrier, strengthening the protection against water and ice.
- Better Performance Under Extreme Conditions: Multiple layers can better withstand the force of pounding rain and expanding ice, preventing blow-offs and tears.
- Enhanced Energy Efficiency: The extra layer can help insulate the roof, improving its overall energy efficiency.
Misconceptions and Criticisms

Despite its growing popularity, the ‘feel over’ concept isn't without its controversies and misconceptions. Some critics argue that it's unnecessary, adding unnecessary costs and potentially making it harder for water vapor to escape.
Moreover, some experts contend that the ‘feel over’ method doesn't address the root causes of water intrusion, which are often installation errors or inadequate roof ventilation. They posit that focusing on proper installation and adequate ventilation would provide better long-term protection than simply adding more membranes.









Weighing the Pros and Cons
Before deciding whether to 'feel over' your ice and water shield, weigh the potential benefits against the drawbacks. Consider factors like your local climate, your roof's condition, and your budget. Consulting with a professional roofer can provide valuable insights tailored to your specific situation.
Remember, while an additional layer of protection might seem like a good idea, it's not always the best or most cost-effective solution. It's all about finding the right balance between protection, cost, and long-term maintenance.
Beyond the Shield: Other Steps to Protect Your Home
Regardless of whether you decide to 'feel over' your ice and water shield, there are other steps you can take to safeguard your home against water damage:
- Ensure Proper Roof Ventilation: Adequate airflow in your attic keeps ice dams at bay and prevents mold growth.
- Insulate Your Attic: Proper insulation keeps your home warmer in winter and cooler in summer, reducing the risk of ice dams.
- Regular Roof Maintenance: Regular inspections and timely repairs go a long way in preventing water damage and extending your roof's lifespan.
In conclusion, while the ‘feel over’ method has its proponents and detractors, it's one of several strategies you can consider to protect your home against water damage. The best course of action depends on your unique situation. Consulting with a professional roofer is always a good idea when deciding on changes to your roofing system."