Is Felt Over Ice & Water Shield Necessary?

Anna Aug 02, 2026

When it comes to keeping your roof safe and sound, understanding the various ice and water shield products and their applications is crucial. One question that often arises in this context is: do you need felt over ice and water shield? This article will delve into this query, providing an in-depth exploration of the benefits, drawbacks, and best practices regarding ice and water shield usage.

two men working on the roof of a house
two men working on the roof of a house

Before we delve into the specific question, let's briefly understand what ice and water shield is. Ice and water shield is a self-adhesive membrane that's designed to protect the vulnerable areas of your roof from water damage. It's typically used alongside underlayment felt, but the need for felt when you've already applied ice and water shield is what we're primarily interested in.

a man is working on the roof of a house that has been covered with tarps
a man is working on the roof of a house that has been covered with tarps

Understanding Ice and Water Shield

The primary function of ice and water shield is to prevent water penetration in critical areas of your roof, primarily in valleys, eaves, and rakes, and around penetrations like chimneys, skylights, and vents. These are areas where water is most likely to intrude, given their design and the natural flow of water.

a house with cars parked in front of it and some trees on the side of the road
a house with cars parked in front of it and some trees on the side of the road

Ice and water shield is not just about protecting your roof; it's also about safeguarding your home's interior. By keeping water out, it prevents damage to ceilings, walls, and insulation, which can be costly to repair. It's thus a crucial component in residential roofing, a topic that's increasingly gaining traction in home improvement discussions.

Ice and Water Shield vs. Felt

Synthetic Felt
Synthetic Felt

Ice and water shield and felt underlayment serve different purposes and have distinct features. Felt underlayment is a traditional roofing material used to provide a water-resistant barrier for your roof, protecting it from wind-driven rain and snow. It's typically installed over the roof sheathing before shingles are added.

Ice and water shield, on the other hand, is designed to protect specific, vulnerable areas of the roof. It's less about creating a general barrier and more about sealing off points of potential entry. While felt provides a broad barrier, ice and water shield focuses on targeted defense.

Do You Need Felt Over Ice and Water Shield?

Q & A - What Felt Underlayment Should I Use? — AskARoofer
Q & A - What Felt Underlayment Should I Use? — AskARoofer

The short answer is, not necessarily. Ice and water shield is designed to provide comprehensive protection for the most vulnerable areas of your roof. Once it's applied, it's not obligatory to put felt over it. In fact, doing so may add unnecessary weight and costs to your roofing project.

However, there are certain scenarios where using felt over ice and water shield might be beneficial. For instance, if you live in an area with severe weather conditions or if you're using certain types of roofing materials that might require additional protection. It's always a good idea to consult with a professional roofer to ensure you're making the best decision for your specific situation.

The Role of Felt in Roofing

Installing Grace Ice & Water Shield Underlayment - Fine Homebuilding
Installing Grace Ice & Water Shield Underlayment - Fine Homebuilding

Although felt underlayment might not be necessary when you've used ice and water shield, it's still a valuable component in many roofing projects. Felt provides a secondary water barrier in case the primary barrier (your shingles) fails. It also acts as a wind barrier, preventing shingles from being lifted and dislodged in windy conditions.

Moreover, felt underlayment can help prevent moisture from getting into your attic or beneath your roof sheathing during the installation process. If it's a hot, sunny day, the ice and water shield can become quite hot, potentially damaging the shingles if they're not applied immediately. Using felt over the ice and water shield can provide a cool surface for the shingles to be laid on until they're ready to be installed.

The Best Roof Underlayments
The Best Roof Underlayments
Valleys on your roof handle the most water flow.
Valleys on your roof handle the most water flow.
How to Install Ice Shield
How to Install Ice Shield
a poster with instructions on how to keep your steps safe in freezing weather, including ice and snow
a poster with instructions on how to keep your steps safe in freezing weather, including ice and snow
Install Ice and Water Shield at Roof Wall Abutment | Roofer Training
Install Ice and Water Shield at Roof Wall Abutment | Roofer Training
Hydroshield Self Adhering Ice And Water Shield Ht Underlayment
Hydroshield Self Adhering Ice And Water Shield Ht Underlayment
143K views · 772 reactions | Quick ways to stay Warm! 🌨️ Easy, last minute tips for weathering freezing storms. Emergency ways to keep warm with things you already have at home. #snowstorm #freezing #coldweather #energyefficiency #storm | Jeff & Lauren | Facebook
143K views · 772 reactions | Quick ways to stay Warm! 🌨️ Easy, last minute tips for weathering freezing storms. Emergency ways to keep warm with things you already have at home. #snowstorm #freezing #coldweather #energyefficiency #storm | Jeff & Lauren | Facebook
a car is parked in front of a house with trees and bushes around the driveway
a car is parked in front of a house with trees and bushes around the driveway
scotchpad heavy duty water shield for furniture and upholstering, 32 ounce
scotchpad heavy duty water shield for furniture and upholstering, 32 ounce

When to Use Felt Over Ice and Water Shield

Given its benefits, using felt over ice and water shield might still be a good idea in certain circumstances. For instance, if your roof is highly exposed to the elements or if your local building codes require it. It's also worth considering if you're using metal roofing or clay tiles, which might benefit from the additional protection and slip resistance that felt underlayment provides.

Another situation where felt might be useful is if you're expecting a delay between the installation of the underlayment and the installation of the shingles. Felt can provide a temporary protective layer that can help prevent damage from wind, rain, and debris.

When to Forgo Felt Over Ice and Water Shield

Given the additional cost and weight that felt underlayment adds, it's not always necessary to use it over ice and water shield. If your ice and water shield is of high quality and your roof is not particularly exposed to the elements, you might not need the extra protection that felt provides.

Additionally, if you're aiming for a more minimalist, eco-friendly roofing design, forgoing felt underlayment could be an environmentally friendly choice. Felt is typically made from a non-biodegradable material called synthetic felt, which can end up in landfills if it's not handled properly.

Ultimately, the decision to use felt over ice and water shield will depend on your specific circumstances. Consulting with a professional roofer can help you make an informed decision that balances cost, protection, and sustainability.

Remember, understanding your roofing needs is a continual process. Regular maintenance and periodic inspections can help you stay on top of your roof's health, ensuring it continues to protect your home for years to come. So, don't forget to schedule regular check-ups, and always seek professional advice when uncertainty arises.

In the end, the key to successful roofing lies in understanding your specific needs and making informed decisions based on those needs. Whether or not you choose to use felt over ice and water shield, always ensure you're giving your roof the protection it deserves. Happy home improvement!