Does Ice & Water Shield Go Over Felt?

Anna Aug 02, 2026

The intersection of ice and water shield, often a gray area for homeowners, deserves a nuanced understanding, especially when it comes to roofing. Can ice and water shield go over felt? Let's delve into the details.

two men working on the roof of a house
two men working on the roof of a house

Beneath every roofing system lies a foundational layer designed to protect the underlying structure. In colder regions, this includes ice and water shield, a crucial component in preventing ice dams and water infiltration. But how does it integrate with felt?

a house with cars parked in front of it and some trees on the side of the road
a house with cars parked in front of it and some trees on the side of the road

Understanding the Role of Felt in Roofing Systems

In roof construction, felt, typically made of cloth or paper, serves as a barrier, preventing water from seeping into the roof. It's a traditional staple, but with the advent of modern materials, its role has evolved.

a man is working on the roof of a house that has been covered with tarps
a man is working on the roof of a house that has been covered with tarps

Felt alone, however, is not equipped to handle the unique challenges posed by ice dams. This is where ice and water shield comes into play.

The Need for Ice and Water Shield

Drip Edge Installation | Drip Edge | Roofing How To
Drip Edge Installation | Drip Edge | Roofing How To

Ice and water shield is a self-adhesive membrane that provides robust protection against ice dams and water infiltration in the most vulnerable areas of a roof, such as eaves, valleys, and penetration points. It's designed to be placed on top of the roof sheathing, not over felt.

It stretches and adheres to uneven and curved surfaces, forming a watertight seal that goes beyond what felt can offer. Ice and water shield's self-adhesive nature also means it sticks tenaciously, even in the most difficult conditions.

Ice and Water Shield's Position in the Roofing Layer Cake

Synthetic Felt
Synthetic Felt

Here's a simplified breakdown of a typical roofing layering: roof sheathing, ice and water shield, felt, then shingles or tiles. The ice and water shield goes on directly to the roof sheathing, followed by the felt, ensuring the felt layer doesn't disrupt the ice and water shield's adhesion.

Despite its name, ice and water shield doesn't 'float' on top of felt. Instead, itbonded to the roof sheathing, with felt layered above. This position ensures its protective benefits are fully harnessed, without the risk of it peeling off or being compromised by the felt.

The Interplay Between Felt and Ice and Water Shield

felt paper or water & ice
felt paper or water & ice

Felt's evolution has seen it become more than just a barrier. It now often serves as a base for the next layer up, providing stability and strength. In cold climates, this is usually ice and water shield, not the other way around.

Felt's role here is to provide a smooth surface for the ice and water shield to adhere to. It also helps distribute the weight and pressure of the ice and water shield evenly. Conversely, laying ice and water shield over felt means risking its adhesion and the entire roof's integrity.

The Best Roof Underlayments
The Best Roof Underlayments
Installing Grace Ice & Water Shield Underlayment - Fine Homebuilding
Installing Grace Ice & Water Shield Underlayment - Fine Homebuilding
How To Make Any Fabric Waterproof
How To Make Any Fabric Waterproof
Q & A - What Felt Underlayment Should I Use? — AskARoofer
Q & A - What Felt Underlayment Should I Use? — AskARoofer
Les meilleurs protège-gouttières pour les hivers canadiens
Les meilleurs protège-gouttières pour les hivers canadiens
How to install ice and water shield on the roof
How to install ice and water shield on the roof
How to Install Ice Shield
How to Install Ice Shield
a car is parked in front of a house with trees and bushes around the driveway
a car is parked in front of a house with trees and bushes around the driveway
Install Ice and Water Shield at Roof Wall Abutment | Roofer Training
Install Ice and Water Shield at Roof Wall Abutment | Roofer Training

Does Felt Affect Ice and Water Shield's Performance?

Incorrect application, such as placing ice and water shield over felt, can hinder its performance. Felt can create an uneven surface, compromising the ice and water shield's ability to adhere properly. It can also trap moisture, leading to potential damage and costly repairs.

Moreover, felt, particularly when old, can lose its flexibility and dry out, increasing the risk of cracks or splits. These can allow water to seep in, directly undermining the purpose of both the felt and the ice and water shield.

Best Practices for Installing Ice and Water Shield

To ensure optimal performance, ice and water shield should be installed directly onto the roof sheathing, not over felt. This allows it to create a complete shield around the roof's vulnerable points.

The felt then goes on top of the ice and water shield, providing a stable base for the final layer, be it shingles or tiles. If you're considering a renovation or new installation, consult with a professional to get the best advice tailored to your specific situation.

In the vast, dynamic world of roofing, there's no one-size-fits-all solution. But for those chilly regions prone to ice dams, one thing's clear: ice and water shield is a powerhouse in protecting your roof, but it's most effective when laid correctly, not over felt but on top of it.