Ice vs Underlayment: Shield Your Roof with the Best

Anna Aug 02, 2026

When it comes to protecting your roof from the elements, two crucial components often come into play: ice and water shield, and underlayment. Both serve distinct purposes, catering to different needs and situations. But which one is right for your roof, or can they even be used together? Let's delve into the intricacies of each, their roles, and when to use them.

Underlayment vs. Ice And Water Shield. What’s the Difference?
Underlayment vs. Ice And Water Shield. What’s the Difference?

Firstly, understanding your roof's unique requirements is key to choosing the appropriate protection. Each roof type, climate, and local building codes have their specifications. So, let's explore the ice and water shield and underlayment, and where they fit into your roofing equation.

Roofing Underlayment Types | Felt vs Synthetic | Peel-and-Stick Guide
Roofing Underlayment Types | Felt vs Synthetic | Peel-and-Stick Guide

Ice and Water Shield

The ice and water shield, also known as ice barrier or ice and water membrane, is a self-adhesive, waterproof layer placed at the roof's edges, valleys, and penetrations. Its primary function is to safeguard these vulnerable areas from water intrusion. It's particularly effective in regions with heavy snow and ice buildup, as it prevents water from backing up under the shingles and entering the roof.

Installing Grace Ice & Water Shield Underlayment - Fine Homebuilding
Installing Grace Ice & Water Shield Underlayment - Fine Homebuilding

Ice and water shields are made from a wide range of materials. Some are bituminous sheets with a self-adhesive backing, others are synthetic polymer sheets, or a combination of both. They're often designed to be peeled and stuck directly onto the roof, with built-in nails to secure them. But when and where should you use an ice and water shield?

When to Use Ice and Water Shield

Grace Ice & Water Shield 36-Inches x 75-Feet 200-Sq. Feet Rubber Roof Underlayment | 5003002
Grace Ice & Water Shield 36-Inches x 75-Feet 200-Sq. Feet Rubber Roof Underlayment | 5003002

Using an ice and water shield is prevalent in cold climates, where ice dams are common. These dams occur when the heat from the attic causes the snow and ice on the roof to melt, which then freezes along the colder roof edges. An ice and water shield helps prevent this water from seeping into your home. Additionally, always use an ice and water shield:

  • In valley areas, where snow and ice collect andidirist.
  • Around roof penetrations, like vents, skylights, and chimneys.
  • At the eaves, rakes, and any area where ice dams are prone to form.

Installing Ice and Water Shield

a flat roof being installed on a house
a flat roof being installed on a house

Focusing on the correct installation methods ensures the ice and water shield functions optimally. Always follow the manufacturers' instructions, but general guidelines include:

Adhesively secure the first course along the eave or rake, ensuring it overlaps the drip edge by at least 2 inches. Then, lay subsequent courses up the roof, always overlapping the previous one by at least 4 inches. Secure with fasteners where recommended, usually 6-8 inches apart. Always keep valleys open, and never install overlapping courses on the main roof field.

Underlayment

How to Install Ice Shield
How to Install Ice Shield

Underlayment, also known as roofing felt or tar paper, serves as a secondary layer of protection beneath the roofing material. Its purpose is to safeguard the roof from water damage in case the outer layer is compromised. Unlike the ice and water shield, underlayment covers the entire roof and isn't just limited to vulnerable areas.

Underlayment is typically made from fiberglass, organic felt, or synthetic materials. It's lightweight, easy to install, and provides a smooth surface for the roofing material. However, it's not waterproof and relies on its ability to shed water until the outer layer of roofing takes over. But when should you use underlayment, and how does it compare to ice and water shield?

several pieces of ice sitting on top of each other
several pieces of ice sitting on top of each other
Metal Roof Underlayment- Synthetic Felt paper vs. High temp Ice and water shield
Metal Roof Underlayment- Synthetic Felt paper vs. High temp Ice and water shield
the roof is being installed to protect it from falling snow and freezing up on top
the roof is being installed to protect it from falling snow and freezing up on top
Winter Woes: Ice Dams and Window Leaks | Kempenfelt Windows & Doors
Winter Woes: Ice Dams and Window Leaks | Kempenfelt Windows & Doors
two hands touching each other in front of a blue and black background with leaves on it
two hands touching each other in front of a blue and black background with leaves on it
How to install ice and water shield on the roof
How to install ice and water shield on the roof
an animated scene with ice formations and water
an animated scene with ice formations and water
James - We’ve been getting a lot of calls and questions about the irrational snow weather we’ve been experiencing in Southeastern Wisconsin lately, so we wanted to hop on here and break it down for you; what it means, what to watch for, and how to protect your home.  ❄️ What does this weather mean for your home? The constant freezing and thawing can cause big problems for roofs and gutters. Snow melts during the warmer parts of the day and refreezes at night, which creates ice buildup in places it shouldn’t be.  🧊 What is ice damming? Ice damming happens when melted snow refreezes at the edge of your roof. This creates a “dam” that prevents proper drainage. Water gets trapped behind it and can back up under your shingles, leading to roof leaks, interior water damage, stained ceilings, and even mold growth. A very common occurrence when you experience dramatic snowfall and then warmer weather following.  🏡 Warning signs of ice dams: • Large icicles hanging from gutters • Ice buildup along roof edges • Water stains on ceilings or walls • Peeling paint or warped drywall  🔧 How to address it: The best prevention is good attic insulation and ventilation so your roof stays cold and snow melts evenly. Safely removing excess snow from your roof can also help reduce the risk. Avoid chipping at ice, as that can damage your roof. Heat cables on the roofs edge can be installed, when snow isn't present, to help minimize this issue in the colder months.  If you’re seeing warning signs or have concerns, reach out to a trusted professional to prevent bigger issues down the road.  Stay safe and warm! ❄️ | Facebook
James - We’ve been getting a lot of calls and questions about the irrational snow weather we’ve been experiencing in Southeastern Wisconsin lately, so we wanted to hop on here and break it down for you; what it means, what to watch for, and how to protect your home. ❄️ What does this weather mean for your home? The constant freezing and thawing can cause big problems for roofs and gutters. Snow melts during the warmer parts of the day and refreezes at night, which creates ice buildup in places it shouldn’t be. 🧊 What is ice damming? Ice damming happens when melted snow refreezes at the edge of your roof. This creates a “dam” that prevents proper drainage. Water gets trapped behind it and can back up under your shingles, leading to roof leaks, interior water damage, stained ceilings, and even mold growth. A very common occurrence when you experience dramatic snowfall and then warmer weather following. 🏡 Warning signs of ice dams: • Large icicles hanging from gutters • Ice buildup along roof edges • Water stains on ceilings or walls • Peeling paint or warped drywall 🔧 How to address it: The best prevention is good attic insulation and ventilation so your roof stays cold and snow melts evenly. Safely removing excess snow from your roof can also help reduce the risk. Avoid chipping at ice, as that can damage your roof. Heat cables on the roofs edge can be installed, when snow isn't present, to help minimize this issue in the colder months. If you’re seeing warning signs or have concerns, reach out to a trusted professional to prevent bigger issues down the road. Stay safe and warm! ❄️ | Facebook
a person's hand covered in ice and water
a person's hand covered in ice and water

Using Underlayment

Underlayment is a standard component in most roofs, providing a base layer for the roofing material and protecting the roof deck. It's essential in all roof types, from asphalt shingles to metal roofs, and especially where secondary water protection is needed:

  • In warm climates, where more water gets absorbed into the underlayment before being shed.
  • Where high winds are common, as underlayment helps secure the roofing material.
  • When the outer roofing material takes longer to install (like with shakes or tiles), ensuring temporary protection.

Installing Underlayment

The installation of underlayment is a crucial step in the roofing process. Typically, it's laid out in horizontal Courses, starting at the eaves and working up the roof. The first course should extend at least 24 inches up the roof, with subsequent courses overlapping the ones below by at least 4 inches. Secure with fasteners, usually 6-8 inches apart, following the manufacturers' guidelines.

After underlayment installation, but before the application of the ice and water shield, take the time to inspect the roof for any penetrations, nail holes, or tears. Ensure everything is clean and dry before proceeding. This careful preparation ensures all components work together efficiently.

Ice and Water Shield vs. Underlayment: Can They Be Used Together?

The short answer is 'yes, they can be used together'. In fact, in many cases, it's recommended to use both an ice and water shield and underlayment. They complement each other, with the ice and water shield providing waterproof protection at vulnerable areas, while the underlayment safeguards the entire roof. Just remember, always install the underlayment first, followed by the ice and water shield to ensure it sticks correctly.

Considering both layers, along with proper attic ventilation, can significantly enhance your roof's resistance to water intrusion. That's why professional roofers often suggest using both whenever possible. But always consult your local building codes and consult with a professional roofer for the most accurate guidance for your roof.

In conclusion, understanding the roles of ice and water shield and underlayment, and how they complement each other, is vital in creating a strong, protective shield for your roof. Whether you're a homeowner eager to protect your investment or a roofer seeking to provide the best service, grasping the intricacies of these components ensures your roof stands ready against the elements.