Old-fashioned boiled icing, also known as royal icing or buttercream, is a classic yet versatile topping for cakes, cookies, and pastries. This traditional frosting, made by boiling sugars and other ingredients, brings back memories of home-baked treats and nostalgic flavors. Let's delve into the art and science of old-fashioned boiled icing, its history, types, and how to make it at home.

Boiled icing traces back to the mid-18th century, where it was primarily used as a glaze for cookies and gingerbread. Initially called "cooking sugar," it evolved into various forms, including immaculate white meringue and rich, creamy buttercreams we enjoy today. The process involves cooking sugar with additional ingredients like corn syrup, egg whites, or butter, resulting in a thick, spreadable, or pipable frosting.

types of Old-Fashioned Boiled Icing
The two main types of old-fashioned boiled icings are meringue and buttercream. Each has unique preparation methods and applications.

Meringue Icing: This airy, light, and sweet frosting is made from egg whites and sugar, often enhanced with vanilla or other flavors. It's perfect for piping decorative details, such as borders, shells, and rosettes. Meringue can be used to makeulates and topping for desserts like lemon meringue pie.
French Meringue

French meringue is the most common and simplest to make. Egg whites and sugar are whisked together over heat until they form a glossy, thick mixture.
Swiss Meringue: For a more stable and pipeable meringue, try Swiss meringue. Egg whites and sugar are whisked over a bain-marie until heated, then whipped until thick and glossy.
Italian Meringue

Italian meringue involves cooking a sugar syrup to the soft-ball stage (238°F/114°C) before gradually pouring it over whipped egg whites. This method yields an extra-stable meringue ideal for piping complex designs.
Buttercream Icing
Buttercream is rich, creamy, and indulgent. It's made by adding butter to cooked sugar syrup and whisking until light and fluffy. Buttercreams are fantastic for filling and frosting cakes, as well as piping flowers, leaves, and other embellishments.

A primary difference between meringue and buttercream icings lies in their stability and composition. Meringues are delicate and prone to weeping but lay beautifully on desserts. Buttercreams are more stable, pipeable, and can withstand higher temperatures, making them perfect for intricate decorations and cake fillings.
Classic American Buttercream









American buttercream is simple to make and calls for powdered sugar, butter, and milk or cream. It's sweet, creamy, and perfect for frosting and filling cakes.
European Buttercream: This type of buttercream features cooked sugar syrup and egg yolks, creating a denser, more flavorful result. It's ideal for cake fillings and small batches.
To master old-fashioned boiled icing, practice is key. Start with basic recipes, experiment with different flavors, and gradually tackle more complex techniques. Invest in a quality candy thermometer and sugar thermometer for precise results. With time and experience, you'll create show-stopping desserts with this timeless frosting.