Smarties Candy Sandwich Cookies Recipe

Betty Jul 24, 2026

Have you ever wondered how to make your favorite childhood candy, Smarties, at home? While you can't truly replicate the iconic, licorice-flavored, bite-sized discs, you can create a delightful candy coating that echos the classic Smarties taste. This homemade Smarties candy recipe isn't an exact duplicate, but it's a fun and delicious way to celebrate the beloved treat. Let's dive into the world of sugar,corn syrup, and a hint of secret flavoring!

Easy Smartie Cookies Recipe - Sweetest Menu
Easy Smartie Cookies Recipe - Sweetest Menu

Before we begin, it's essential to note that making candy at home requires patience, attention to detail, and safe handling of hot sugar. This recipe is not suitable for children without adult supervision. Now, let's get started with our adventure into creating a tasty Smarties-inspired candy!

Recipe Rock Candy  & Tutorial
Recipe Rock Candy & Tutorial

Gathering Ingredients and Tools

Creating your Smarties-like candy involves selecting the right ingredients and tools. Here's what you'll need:

the cake has been decorated with candy and is in a tin foil container, next to an instagram post about it
the cake has been decorated with candy and is in a tin foil container, next to an instagram post about it
  • Sugar: A crucial ingredient, providing the candy's structure and sweetness.
  • Corn syrup: Helps achieve a smooth, glossy candy texture by preventing sugar crystallization.
  • Water: Dissolves sugar and creates the candy base.
  • Cream of tartar: Enhances the candy's texture and prevents sugar from crystallizing.
  • Flavoring: A licorice extract or similar flavor will help mimic the classic Smarties taste.
  • Food coloring: For that iconic Smarties red.
  • Candy thermometer: Measures the temperature of the sugar mixture, crucial for determining when it's ready to be molded.
  • Candy molds: You'll need small, round molds to shape your Smarties-like candy. Silicone candy molds are a flexible and easy-to-use option.

Understanding the Candy-Making Process

Jello Candy Melts (We Actually Tested Them)
Jello Candy Melts (We Actually Tested Them)

Candy-making involves two critical stages: creating a sugar syrup and allowing it to cool and harden. To create our Smarties-inspired candy, we start by dissolving sugar, corn syrup, and water on the stove. By slowly heating this mixture, we allow the sugar to fully dissolve and reach the hard candy stage. Once our syrup reaches the right temperature, we quickly stir in our flavoring and food coloring before quickly pouring it into molds.

The cooling and hardening process is where our patience comes in. As the candy cools, it transforms from a liquid sugar syrup into a solid, delicious treat. Once the candy has set, usually after a few hours, it's time to pop them out of the molds and enjoy your homemade Smarties-like candy!

Preparing the Sugar Syrup

two pictures with the words smarties blondies on them and one has chocolate chip cookies
two pictures with the words smarties blondies on them and one has chocolate chip cookies

To begin, combine 2 cups of granulated sugar, 1/2 cup of corn syrup, 1/2 cup of water, and 1/4 teaspoon of cream of tartar in a heavy-bottomed saucepan. Stir gently until the sugar is fully dissolved. Affix your candy thermometer to the side of the pan, making sure the tip is immersed in the mixture but not touching the bottom. Cook the mixture over medium heat, without stirring, until it reaches 300°F (149°C). This should take about 15 to 20 minutes. Be patient and keep an eye on the thermometer; it's essential not to let the mixture boil over or caramelize.

Once your mixture reaches 300°F (149°C), remove it from heat and carefully stir in 1/2 teaspoon of licorice or anise extract and a few drops of red food coloring. Quickly pour the hot candy mixture into your prepared molds, filling each cavity completely. Be cautious, as the candy will be extremely hot. If you're using silicone molds, you might need to place them on a baking sheet for easier handling and transportation.

Letting the Candy Set and Enjoying Your Creation

Smarties Squashies Copycat: Soft Chewy Candy at Home
Smarties Squashies Copycat: Soft Chewy Candy at Home

As the candy cools and hardens, it's time to be patient. This process can take several hours, depending on your room temperature and humidity. You can expedite the process by placing the molds in the refrigerator, although this isn't strictly necessary. Once your candy has set completely and is easily removable from the molds, it's time to indulge in your homemade Smarties-like treat!

Store any leftovers in an airtight container at room temperature, away from humidity and direct sunlight. They should keep for up to two weeks, but we're willing to bet they won't last that long!

How to Make Candy Buttons
How to Make Candy Buttons
colorful candy candies in a white bowl
colorful candy candies in a white bowl
Homemade Candy Wafers (Necco Wafer Copycat) - Sprinkle Bakes
Homemade Candy Wafers (Necco Wafer Copycat) - Sprinkle Bakes
Old Fashioned Honeycomb Candy
Old Fashioned Honeycomb Candy
20 Fun Homemade Candy Recipes - Busy Mom's Helper
20 Fun Homemade Candy Recipes - Busy Mom's Helper
25+ Easy To Make Homemade Candy Recipes
25+ Easy To Make Homemade Candy Recipes
Cool Whip Candy – Easy Dessert Recipe
Cool Whip Candy – Easy Dessert Recipe

Making Smarties-inspired candy at home is a fun and rewarding experience. Although the final product might not be an exact replica of the classic candy, it's a delicious way to enjoy the flavor and texture of your favorite childhood treat. So gather your ingredients, put on your candy-making apron, and get ready to enjoy a sweet taste of nostalgia!